Rosicky to Atletico Madrid (10 Viewers)

JCK

JCK

Biased
JCK
#23
May 11, 2004
125,381
#23
RochemBeck said:
That makes absolutely no sense. He's a better player nowadays than everybody in our midfield except for Vieira...how on earth is Rosicky not Juventus material..
Click to expand...
Well it makes a lot of sense to me as I don't rate Rosicky that much and I don't see anything special about him. He might me better than our midfielders but there are many other midfielders out there that are much better bar the fact that our midfielders (except for Vieira) have become beyond par.
 

Zlatan

Senior Member
#25
Jun 9, 2003
23,049
#25
Jeeks said:
Well it makes a lot of sense to me as I don't rate Rosicky that much and I don't see anything special about him. He might me better than our midfielders but there are many other midfielders out there that are much better bar the fact that our midfielders (except for Vieira) have become beyond par.
Click to expand...

Emerson?
 
Bjerknes

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
#27
Mar 16, 2004
115,980
#27
But I still do not understand how you can say Rosicky is not Juventus material, especially when the argument being used is the fact that he will travel to Madrid in the summer. He could easily light up La Liga next season and be one of the best players around, just like van der Vaart this year. Is he any less of a player just because he chose a more quiet location at a club he would prefer? Watch some of his performances and see..

Rosicky is an amazing player, one of my favorites, and he can open up any defense with his passing ability and vision. He's been doing it for years in Dortmund with players such as Jan Koller, Frings, Ewerthon, and Dede around him...is it somehow more difficult for such a player to reside around Trezeguet, Camoranesi, Del Piero, and Zambrotta instead? I don't think so, and infact he would probably become a better player with those guys around him. Not to mention the fact if there is one thing we lack its a player like Rosicky, and we should be able to manage 7 million for such an outstanding player. I love how we can field players such as Giannichedda and Blasi and an underperforming Nedved, however come in here and say Rosicky is not Juventus material. Each to his own I guess.
 
Stu

Stu

Senior Member
#28
Jul 14, 2002
17,557
#28
RochemBeck said:
But I still do not understand how you can say Rosicky is not Juventus material, especially when the argument being used is the fact that he will travel to Madrid in the summer. He could easily light up La Liga next season and be one of the best players around, just like van der Vaart this year. Is he any less of a player just because he chose a more quiet location at a club he would prefer? Watch some of his performances and see..

Rosicky is an amazing player, one of my favorites, and he can open up any defense with his passing ability and vision. He's been doing it for years in Dortmund with players such as Jan Koller, Frings, Ewerthon, and Dede around him...is it somehow more difficult for such a player to reside around Trezeguet, Camoranesi, Del Piero, and Zambrotta instead? I don't think so, and infact he would probably become a better player with those guys around him. Not to mention the fact if there is one thing we lack its a player like Rosicky, and we should be able to manage 7 million for such an outstanding player. I love how we can field players such as Giannichedda and Blasi and an underperforming Nedved, however come in here and say Rosicky is not Juventus material. Each to his own I guess.
Click to expand...
Good post.
 
Enron

Enron

Tickle Me
Moderator
#29
Oct 11, 2005
75,660
#29
RochemBeck said:
But I still do not understand how you can say Rosicky is not Juventus material, especially when the argument being used is the fact that he will travel to Madrid in the summer. He could easily light up La Liga next season and be one of the best players around, just like van der Vaart this year. Is he any less of a player just because he chose a more quiet location at a club he would prefer? Watch some of his performances and see..

Rosicky is an amazing player, one of my favorites, and he can open up any defense with his passing ability and vision. He's been doing it for years in Dortmund with players such as Jan Koller, Frings, Ewerthon, and Dede around him...is it somehow more difficult for such a player to reside around Trezeguet, Camoranesi, Del Piero, and Zambrotta instead? I don't think so, and infact he would probably become a better player with those guys around him. Not to mention the fact if there is one thing we lack its a player like Rosicky, and we should be able to manage 7 million for such an outstanding player. I love how we can field players such as Giannichedda and Blasi and an underperforming Nedved, however come in here and say Rosicky is not Juventus material. Each to his own I guess.
Click to expand...
Well see how good his when the USA and Czech Rep clash in the first round of the world cup.;)
 
Enron

Enron

Tickle Me
Moderator
#31
Oct 11, 2005
75,660
#31
Juventico said:
I agree with RochemBeck, Rosicky is definitely Juve Material, and we need urgently a good creative midfielder. Neddy is on his way out...
Click to expand...
Nedved is still decent but in all reality it would be a fantastic situation to bring in a young midfielder like Rosicky and allow him a couple years to split time with Nedved and settle down into the swing of things than to wait until Nedved runs out of steam and get stuck with the balls in hands.
 
peckface

peckface

approaching curve
#34
Oct 3, 2004
2,357
#34
Do we really need him? Alot of you wanted Hleb as well but I don't see neither of them really fitting into our system. I wanted Riquelme but he wouldn't satisfy Capello either since he preferes defensive abilities in the middle. Capello uses wingers, not playmakers. We are doing just fine with our current system and I don't see any reason to change it.

He'd make a great 2nd half sub though, but that would be an awful waste of talent...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 10)