Rock and Voll All Nite: The Mafia Strikes the Music Industry (19 Viewers)
- Thread starter Kate
- Start date
That's a good point. 
Honestly, when I find something suspicious, I ask questions until I get answers. Both to see how the person and the rest will react. And I dunno what a plausible excuse would be in his case, but this doesn't seem like one.
- - - Updated - - -
I've had that song stuck in my head the whole day. 
Honestly, when I find something suspicious, I ask questions until I get answers. Both to see how the person and the rest will react. And I dunno what a plausible excuse would be in his case, but this doesn't seem like one.- - - Updated - - -
Hmm.. Just read the thread.
Haven't really got much. Blondu just made a newbie-mistake. Don't think he's a G.
Dodo is the only one I find suspicious due to him/her? changing to invisibility mode. Soooo....
Dodo and the Dodo's
Haven't really got much. Blondu just made a newbie-mistake. Don't think he's a G.
Dodo is the only one I find suspicious due to him/her? changing to invisibility mode. Soooo....
Dodo and the Dodo's
On one hand I'm kind of reluctant of voting dodo because of last game, when sidd basically did the exact same thing and got lynched. On the other hand back then I had much stronger feeling of Sidd being a C then I have right now with dodo in all honesty.
One thing that bothers me about dodo's case is his reasoning in explaining why he did it, not much sense there and it can either be because he really wasn't sure on all the rules from the beginning so his reasoning is flawed from the start or he indeed got the PM from the G's late like someone suggested (Mohad I think?) and that was the best he could come up with under pressure, I don't see an option where the G's told him to reason like he did. especially this one:
It's probably the worst answer you can give, ever.
I'm leaning for voting dodo for now, everything else in terms of suspicious posting, there is just too many I can't wrap my head around it yet , definitely need a second reading
- - - Updated - - -
Why?
One thing that bothers me about dodo's case is his reasoning in explaining why he did it, not much sense there and it can either be because he really wasn't sure on all the rules from the beginning so his reasoning is flawed from the start or he indeed got the PM from the G's late like someone suggested (Mohad I think?) and that was the best he could come up with under pressure, I don't see an option where the G's told him to reason like he did. especially this one:
It's probably the worst answer you can give, ever.
I'm leaning for voting dodo for now, everything else in terms of suspicious posting, there is just too many I can't wrap my head around it yet
, definitely need a second reading- - - Updated - - -
Why?
Blondu is playing a Bezzy-kinda game imo Don't think he's a G though, this is a good summary why:
It's possible to play as a G without turning on your invisibility mode, but it's very difficult - and while blondu might obviously be completely faking it, his behaviour in this thread so far doesn't seem to be that of a player who's capable of that.
Nah, first of all, not everyone played the last game (I had no idea about this for example). Secondly, it's still basically a staple of Mafia to tell your fellow Gs to turn on invisibility mode - someone did that every time when I was one. And thirdly, there's a good reason for that: Repeating myself, but it's very difficult to play a G without invisibility, especially on the long run and knowing about the stalker capabilities of Völler and some other guys.
J0ker makes a lot of sense if Dodo isn't a G - convinient bandwagoning without trying to draw too much attention to himself (not that that worked).
For now, Dodo. It's not a solid case by any means, but a first day pick never is.
- - - Updated - - -
Meh, I actually think his story is as solid as it could be, considering the circumstances
Don't think he's a G though, this is a good summary why:It's possible to play as a G without turning on your invisibility mode, but it's very difficult - and while blondu might obviously be completely faking it, his behaviour in this thread so far doesn't seem to be that of a player who's capable of that.
Nah, first of all, not everyone played the last game (I had no idea about this for example). Secondly, it's still basically a staple of Mafia to tell your fellow Gs to turn on invisibility mode - someone did that every time when I was one. And thirdly, there's a good reason for that: Repeating myself, but it's very difficult to play a G without invisibility, especially on the long run and knowing about the stalker capabilities of Völler and some other guys.
J0ker makes a lot of sense if Dodo isn't a G - convinient bandwagoning without trying to draw too much attention to himself (not that that worked).
For now, Dodo. It's not a solid case by any means, but a first day pick never is.
- - - Updated - - -
It's probably the worst answer you can give, ever.
I'm leaning for voting dodo for now, everything else in terms of suspicious posting, there is just too many I can't wrap my head around it yet , definitely need a second reading
I'm leaning for voting dodo for now, everything else in terms of suspicious posting, there is just too many I can't wrap my head around it yet
, definitely need a second reading
They are annoying, especially as Cs. They've done damage no matter their role and we had a nice rule not to let them play. They won't vote for an investigated G, just because they feel like it. Personally I wouldn't let them play, but since we let them do it for whatever reason, then lets get rid of them asap.