I too don't buy this "Gila is overrated" line. Overrated by who? His mom? He didn't show in the top 50 of the FIFA World Player of the Year awards, and I am expecting something similar for the Ballon d'Or. So unless we're all expecting him to shoot fire from his ass when playing on the pitch, I don't see how he's not living up to the level of regard he's currently given.
He plays for a talent- and economics-decimated team in Parma (now a major relegation battler) and has still managed to be the 4th leading scorer in the league ... ahead of Boijinov, Totti, and certainly Zlatan. This and he is still only 22 years old with a huge potential career ahead of him to get better.
Sour grapes in this case, I'm afraid.