5/10
The Good: Sandro, Rugani, and Dybala, getting rid of Isla and PDC
The Bad: Hernanes, Cuadrado, and Coman's sale leaving us really short/thin in attack
The Ugly: The acquisition of Zaza, Vidal's sale, the charitable donations of Llorente and Tevez
Our defense is potentially stronger with the addition of Rugani. The goalkeeping department is as solid as ever. Midfield has been visibly weakened, as Pirlo provided creativity and free kick expertise, while Vidal was a true warrior and incredibly difficult to replace. Our attack is shorn of the attacking prowess of Tevez (our top scorer for the last two years and best player last season) and lacking any creativity, aside from Dybala.
I'd give our goalkeeping 9 out of 10. Buffon and Neto are guarantees between the sticks. Our defense is a solid 8, as long as everyone can stay healthy. We have both youth and experience, and the likes of Rugani and Sandro only serve to strengthen this department. Our midfield is weaker, and we need everyone to be healthy. I don't like Hernanes, and I'm not convinced by Khedira. I don't rate Sturaro that highly like some (same applies to Berardi), but I expect Lemina to be a pleasant surprise. I am also hoping Asamoah regains full fitness soon, as I feel he will have a major impact playing in midfield this season. I say our midfield is a 7 at this point. Finally, moving onto our revamped attack, I am curious to see how far Dybala will develop this year, as he is our only creative outlet. We are quite thin in the attacking department with only 3 strikers and one SS. If Dybala is injured/suspended we are quite literally fucked. I would say our attack is a 7, due to scarcity of options and lack of creativity. Overall, the squad is a 7.5 and weaker than it was last season. We added more depth perhaps, but our starting 11 is most definitely not as strong as a year ago.
- - - Updated - - -
I'm serious. But right now every discussion is pointless. Let's wait for the end of the season and see who is right and who is wrong. Do we have a deal?

You have yourself a deal. End of the season? How about until the winter mercato?
