Rafa Márquez - D C, DM - Barcelona (12 Viewers)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Zé Tahir

JhoolayLaaaal!
Moderator
Dec 10, 2004
29,281
@ Tahir:

Dude, it's always been a league for older European and South American players and young Americans.
I just think it's the wrong approach.

Beckham put people in seats. That much is certain. But he's a mercenary.

It is turning into the NASL all over again, but this time the league is in better shape.
Did it improve tv ratings? Did people start going to/watching MLS games where Beckham was not playing?
 

Enron

Tickle Me
Moderator
Oct 11, 2005
75,661
I just think it's the wrong approach.
It's only game in town. In order to incorporate a more European model, we'd have to completely overhaul the way athletics are structured in the US.

Who is going to want to come and play in the US that hasn't already been a great success? The MLS doesn't really have the cash flow to compete with the top European leagues for transfer fees and salaries. There is no "Champion's league" (there is but it's nowhere near the cash cow of the European version) to draw top players. There is no great footballing history.
 

Zé Tahir

JhoolayLaaaal!
Moderator
Dec 10, 2004
29,281
So you're saying the MLS should reject players like Henry?

The league won't get anywhere doing that.

What would you suggest?



It might have. I don't have the raw numbers in front of me.

It's only game in town. In order to incorporate a more European model, we'd have to completely overhaul the way athletics are structured in the US.

Who is going to want to come and play in the US that hasn't already been a great success? The MLS doesn't really have the cash flow to compete with the top European leagues for transfer fees and salaries. There is no "Champion's league" (there is but it's nowhere near the cash cow of the European version) to draw top players. There is no great footballing history.
Its not about rejecting players from playing here but not signing almost has-been players whose main draw are the millions they're going to get before their retire.

I think they should just focus on their own home grown talent and not sign aging players on ridiculous deals from abroad. You should build history and not try to buy it. The Chelsea and Man City model creates the atmosphere mercenaries live off of and that doesn't help build history.
 

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
115,984
Its not about rejecting players from playing here but not signing almost has-been players whose main draw are the millions they're going to get before their retire.

I think they should just focus on their own home grown talent and not sign aging players on ridiculous deals from abroad. You should build history and not try to buy it. The Chelsea and Man City model creates the atmosphere mercenaries live off of and that doesn't help build history.
I couldn't call Henry a has-been though. He's only 32, so he has a couple good years left.

Unfortunately, to increase the stature of the league and to have it gain more respect, having top-notch Europeans over here is a must. This is also important from a business perspective. And lets face it, football is all about business nowadays.
 

Enron

Tickle Me
Moderator
Oct 11, 2005
75,661
Its not about rejecting players from playing here but not signing almost has-been players whose main draw are the millions they're going to get before their retire.

I think they should just focus on their own home grown talent and not sign aging players on ridiculous deals from abroad. You should build history and not try to buy it. The Chelsea and Man City model creates the atmosphere mercenaries live off of and that doesn't help build history.
The majority of the players in the MLS are young Americans. So the base is there. You've got guys like Omar Gonzalez, Tristan Bowen, Robbie Findley, etc coming up.

The Beckham deal was a debacle, no doubt about it.

But signing players like Lungberg, Henry, Angel, isn't going to hurt the league's development. You have to remember that it's still under 20 years old, it's still growing.
 

Mark

The Informer
Administrator
Dec 19, 2003
97,627
Marotta just said that it's not true and didn't make an offer for him because he doesn't want to participate in a bidding war for him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 12)