It was also Autocratic or have you forgotten that? The Communist Yugoslavia is not something to be admired, in the same way that the Soviet Union is not to be admired. As for the break-up of the Yugoslavia, the people in Croatia,Serbia,Bosnia,Macedonia etc. have a right to Self-Determination. They voted for it and believe me we admire your countries more now than we ever did when they were Yugoslavia.
You said one of the biggest nonsense.
Life in Yugoslavia was better than life in many Western countries will ever be.
And one more thing,nobody voted for anything,it is more complicated than that.
Yugoslavia had several ethnic groups and both separatism and nationalism of every group was forbidden and very well controlled.
But despite that Yugoslavia was one of the most respected countries than.
I was very young when Yugoslavia dissapeared, but sill my parents and every other sane persone will tell you that we lived in paradise and everyone admired us.
You said it perfectly ,Gordan.
Right well that settles it,
you are completely insane, good day to you sir.
What kind of argument is that.
Calling someone insane because he is stating his opinion.
Oh yeah right ,you are that guy who said Africans are idiots.
no not at all, i was just trying to break it down to irishzebra.
how did u reach that conclusion irishzebra?? i mean just cos they were a communist nation does'nt necessarily mean they r evil or nothing special. as a communist nation it had it flaws no doubt but that does'nt make it any less of a country.
ok as for the second bolded part, how would u feel if one day u woke up and found out that a city or two ( for example cork i noticed u referred to it when u were discussing the disqualification of ireland from the wc0 in ireland decide to break up from ireland and form a new state whould u be pro that or would u object. after all if they do "have a right to Self-Determination??
if things worked with yr logic then a lot of nations face the same scenerio as the one that occured in yugoslavia. countries like iraq, syria, turkey, sudan, etc are all in the same boat.
Good point Bisco.
I don't know about Albanian minority, but I know that few years before war Kosovo and Vojvodina got bigger autonomy which was something they wanted, especially at Kosovo.
Exactly!!!!
I love how movies educated people that in communism everything is bad, they torture you on every corner of that country, people there are piss poor and dumb etc.
Still my opinion is that Yugoslavia was more about socialism than communism...
Yes but at the same time Guantanamo base ,with it's torturing ,exists.
An invalid argument is invalid no matter how simple you make it.
The fact that the entire media and governmental control of the country that your parents grew up in was under Marshall Tito begs to differ. Any information from an Autocratic regime about quality of live within it is Bullshit, it always has been. And I'm sure you remember that Yugoslavia had to implement IMF conditions and came damn near to total finnacial destruction in 1990-1991. I believe over 1 Million workers were laid off.
If Cork itself wanted to cecede i would be fucking thrilled, it would actually be the happiest moment of my life. There is not legal definition of 'Peoples' in formal international law but customarily it is people who have ties of mutual affection or sentiment that unanimously desire independence. all those people you mentioned i.e. the Kurds Sudanes minorites w/e deserve their own homelands if this condition is met.
You are obviously pseudo informed.
One million workers ,do you know what are you talking about...
The crisis started with a war, which we all ex Yugoslavs consider for the most stupidest and the worst thing that ever happened in our lives.
But we all know now who was arming the different sides.
About the separatism-ok 400 000 Serbs live in Chicago,would you accept if they wanted to form their own country there?
Do you know how many Bosnian people live in Sweden,what would happen if they wanted it for themselves???
We know Marshall Tito was a socialist but he used coercion to hold together Yugoslavia which was a patch-work of seperate peoples, much liek Russia today.
His autocratic regime was indeed brutal, as all are. You don't sacrifice Liberty for Comfort.
Yugoslavia was a product of post WW2 peace process.
The superpowers of the time let Yugoslavia to be formed and the superpowers influenced on the collaps of Yugoslavia.
As I said I was too young to remember, but I would have to disagree with you. Ofcourse Tito wasn't saint and had some "brutal" methods but coercion he used I think was mostly aimed at radicals, and trust me whole history of Balkan is about radical movements. Under Tito's guidance extremist didn't had a chance, but after he died everything went downfall.
Very well put.
And what does define a radical in this case? Anyone that isnt to the dictators liking? You see the fallacy of that dont you?
No, the radicals that wanted to start secession.
It was not only the case in Yugoslavia,
1- in USA there is group that want independent Texas,
2- I lived in Italy and they have a move for Padania (which represents the North very developed part).Some secessionists want to separate the Northern part from the Southern,but the law treat them extremely drastic.
3-In Spain there are terrorist groups fighting for their part of the land,that's separatism.
4-Abhazia the part of Georgia which are heading towards the independence.There is a war because of that.
All the separatism moves I mentioned are aiming at the countries stability and territorial sovereignty and that's why these radical moves are treated drastically.
I especially liked this part:
"Another common problem is that the industry can choose which data to publish, and which to leave unavailable. Much has been written on eye-catching stories, such as the difficulties in getting clear information about the number of suicide attempts in industry trials of SSRI antidepressants4 or the number of heart attacks in patients on rofecoxib (Vioxx)".
The doctors here -- those arrogant pricks

-- like to think they are above pharma sales and marketing. However, there is absolutely no question that it completely affects the decisions they make to recommend drugs to their patients. That's why the pharma reps keep dropping the Big Benjamins on these efforts.
And many docs will be the first in line to take big pharma money if they are invited to a sponsored medical talk on a luxury golf resort.
Exactly ,same thing here.