Paulo Dybala (176 Viewers)

Legend or Rookie? ***non-official poll***


  • Total voters
    140
  • Poll closed .

Hust

Senior Member
Hustini
May 29, 2005
93,703
Paulo, as I’ve said from the first day he arrived in Turin - and as I’ll repeat, because I’m convinced about what I say - his performances - and by that I don’t mean goals because he could end the season with 15 goals and then one year maybe get 20, but those are his numbers as well as the assists that he gets - Paulo is a player who can’t be the striker in a big team.

“He could play as a striker when he was at Palermo, because Palermo played 50 metres from the goal but Juventus play 20 metres from the goal.

“In that situation Paulo can’t be the striker, and in fact his best performances, all Paulo’s goals, came because he arrived from deep.

“Just look at the goal he scored in Verona, the second goal. He started almost as a mezzala, and in fact he could probably play as a mezzala in an attacking midfield.”
..
 

zizinho

Senior Member
Apr 14, 2013
51,816
And why exactly is it a problem that we play 20 meters from the goal? I'd love to hear his explanation, as to me, this just looks like an excuse to play Higuain on every chance, regardless of form
 

Nedved96

Senior Member
Sep 1, 2017
7,198
Nope

Ultimately, it looks like Max sees Dybala's other qualities (dribbling, passing, playmaking) as too valuable. He probably thinks it would be a waste to play Dybala as striker. The problem is that Dybala, on top of being our most creative player, is also our best finisher.
 

zizinho

Senior Member
Apr 14, 2013
51,816
Nope

Ultimately, it looks like Max sees Dybala's other qualities (dribbling, passing, playmaking) as too valuable. He probably thinks it would be a waste to play Dybala as striker. The problem is that Dybala, on top of being our most creative player, is also our best finisher.
i think hes wasted away from the goal, and its not like he would be camping in the box all the time like a Toni for example. the beaty of him at CF is that he gives you all those other qualities, so when he drops deeper, you have an extra man for creating. and with Mandzukic next to him, you have an aerial threat to compensate for Dybis lack of

- - - Updated - - -

No, that's why we play all our long balls to our best winger, Mandzukic.
yep. with Mandzukic out there, you dont need a CF to do CF things, but be an all around threat in and out of the box
 

MikeM

Footballing Hipster celebrating 4th place with Tuz
Sep 21, 2008
12,849
does Higuain?

- - - Updated - - -

i dont see what Higuain can do that Dybala cant, to make one a starting CF for a big club and the other not. the only thing i can think of is that Higuain is 2 footed
This is really the important point which I've said before also. It's fine if Max thinks that Dybala is not good as a #9 if we hold the ball within 20 metres of the opposition goal all match. Fine, you want a #9 who can be physical, win headers, etc.

But Higuain doesn't do that either!

But Max is too smart to not see this. I think he's just trying to keep the lockerroom happy. Imagine he comes out and says that absolutely Dybala can play as a lone striker. That just fuels a ton of speculation and drama.
 

Hængebøffer

Senior Member
Jun 4, 2009
25,185
This argument has been debunked so many times now. If you are part of a project then money should not be an option. What happened to; this player is indispensable or not for sale? Look at Saurez for Liverpool for example, no amount of money was worth what they were offered, and it looks like they've learned their lesson with Coutinho. Look at Man Utd with De Gea and Bayern when Ribery was the next best thing? The best players win you the league end of. You think the money for Mbappe will benefit Monaco? Or how about you ask any Barcelona fan if they prefer the money they were given for Neymar or would of kept him? Pogba is actually the type of player we need at the moment, and I firmly believe we would have won the CL in 2017, if we have kept him. Fact is I don't blame Man Utd fans for getting hyped, because of the way we portrayed ourselves since 2015.
So Neymar didn't believe in Barcelona's project? Of course it's not all about money, but it's not all about "the project" too. And there's many other nuances too. But money is a big factor (if not the biggest) factor. I only see Messi and Ronaldo as unbuyable players in todays game.
 

X Æ A-12

Senior Member
Contributor
Sep 4, 2006
87,955
This is really the important point which I've said before also. It's fine if Max thinks that Dybala is not good as a #9 if we hold the ball within 20 metres of the opposition goal all match. Fine, you want a #9 who can be physical, win headers, etc.

But Higuain doesn't do that either!

But Max is too smart to not see this. I think he's just trying to keep the lockerroom happy. Imagine he comes out and says that absolutely Dybala can play as a lone striker. That just fuels a ton of speculation and drama.
The solution is 4-3-3 with Dybala wide right. Not perfect but better than at CAM despite what some posters here would say :baus:
 

MikeM

Footballing Hipster celebrating 4th place with Tuz
Sep 21, 2008
12,849
The solution is 4-3-3 with Dybala wide right. Not perfect but better than at CAM despite what some posters here would say :baus:
I think his best positions in order:

Second striker (barely exists in football anymore) Hard to fit a team around that.
Centre forward
Right wing (inside forward)
CAM
 

X Æ A-12

Senior Member
Contributor
Sep 4, 2006
87,955
I think his best positions in order:

Second striker (barely exists in football anymore) Hard to fit a team around that.
Centre forward
Right wing (inside forward)
CAM
Probably correct, at least out wide he has space to receive the ball and turn, take a touch or two without always running into immediate pressure. Goes some way to mitigating his first touch issues.
 

Hydde

Minimiliano Tristelli
Mar 6, 2003
38,987
The solution is 4-3-3 with Dybala wide right. Not perfect but better than at CAM despite what some posters here would say :baus:
Probably correct, at least out wide he has space to receive the ball and turn, take a touch or two without always running into immediate pressure. Goes some way to mitigating his first touch issues.
yes and yes.

I think it will be the only solution to play , at least according to what max says. I agree with this one to be honest. Been saying that dybala should play wider from some time. His Am experiment well didnt went well...and to be honest his best trait is to come in from the right and unleash his left leg shoot.

This way we cancontinue using mandz and Higuain and CF, and Douglas on the other side.

All of this without tweaking our 3 man midfield, which is a priority above anything else right now.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 153)