Many people in Tuz here are convinced that he's flopping at United but the reality is completely different. Pogba has a long career ahead so it's premature to come up with a verdict on his United stint.
I'd say he is flopping thus far, just by the fact he had been terrible every time he has faced one of the top 4 sides in EPL. It's the same reason I'd say Mourinho has been a flop thus far. Pogba doesn't put the effort in. He constantly doesn't track back, abdicates defensive and positional responsibilities. I recall this happening very occasionally here, but nowhere near as often. He's turned into a bit of a flat-track bully.
However, he could still easily turn it around and become one of the best CMs in football. Only time will tell. He has all the tools. We'll see if he's willing to put in the work required over the next few years.
- - - Updated - - -
I'm convinced we made a shitty deal by offloading him, year later the market exploded and we probably could've received double that amount + our team would've been stronger with him here, but of course no one knew that the 78m eur we received would look funny as fuck a year later.
But he's not living up to expectations at ManUtd, at least so far, he should've taken the team to a new level, but instead they seem to have taken him down to their level.
We sold him a year early. Hindsight is 20/20 as they say, but it seems quite obvious now. We should have wrapped up Matuidi and Pjanic before selling him last summer and made United explode the transfer market for him. Unfortunately we did neither. It worked out alright in the end as the purchases we made from his sale got us back to the CL final, but it could have worked out even better if we waited a year.