Paul Pogba (180 Viewers)

How many minutes will he play for jj in 23-24 season?


  • Total voters
    33
  • Poll closed .

adRHCP

Senior Member
Nov 7, 2012
6,635
Pogba is easily the midfielder who get's the most freedom on our team, and to be honest even as a "CAM" he'd be asked to defend as he does right now, every player here is asked for defensive contribution.

I don't believe football is as rigid as those numbers suggest, if we play 3-5-2, 4-3-1-2, 3-4-1-2... I don't think it matters really, formations are not symmetric, not every player fills their spot exactly the same as the one next to him, or the one on the other side of the pitch.

Some people turn crazy at the slightest suggestion of Dybala playing on a 4-3-3, or something other than not an specifically named SS. Messi plays on a "4-3-3" that has Suárez as a CF, yet he seems to be doing OK, even when he has been playing as a CF for the most part of the latest years. I don't think it matters where you "place" a player on a formation, they have their own style, their movements and tasks asked by their coach, formations are nothing more than a way to simplify it for people to understand them.
 

LiquidPLP

Senior Member
Jun 9, 2012
12,237
It doesent. Its an aspect of his game hes great at so why take it away from him? Its what makes him a complete midfielder
You surely never kicked a ball in your life, lol. Defensive work always influence attacking players because it tires them much more (than attacking). It's so much easier to play with the ball but I can see why Allegri prefers Pogba as LCM/B2B and why he'd like to have someone else for the AM spot (which I believe he still wants). Pogba is too much of a beast to not use him while defending, because he's tall and very strong. He can also keep the ball very well under pressure as well as drive it from our halt to opponent's. It'd be a waste to have 3 CMs that can only defend and putting Pogba as AM on top of that.

Besides we have had too many injuries this season so Allegri didn't really have a chance to experiment with midfield. Poor start made him fight for every point because if he won nothing this year his future here wouldn't look too bright.
 

TheTruth

Junior Member
Aug 24, 2015
260
You surely never kicked a ball in your life, lol. Defensive work always influence attacking players because it tires them much more (than attacking). It's so much easier to play with the ball but I can see why Allegri prefers Pogba as LCM/B2B and why he'd like to have someone else for the AM spot (which I believe he still wants). Pogba is too much of a beast to not use him while defending, because he's tall and very strong. He can also keep the ball very well under pressure as well as drive it from our halt to opponent's. It'd be a waste to have 3 CMs that can only defend and putting Pogba as AM on top of that.

Besides we have had too many injuries this season so Allegri didn't really have a chance to experiment with midfield. Poor start made him fight for every point because if he won nothing this year his future here wouldn't look too bright.
This.

He's our most effective midfielder on the ball, thats why its important to have him deep and let him receive the ball early especially if an opponent is pressing us high.
Pogba's offensive game is based on receving the ball early and advance. And he's a great tackler actually, against Milan he had more successful tackles than any other player on the pitch. Restricting him as an AM is basically ruining everything what makes him great for this team and individually.
 

zizinho

Senior Member
Apr 14, 2013
51,816
You surely never kicked a ball in your life, lol. Defensive work always influence attacking players because it tires them much more (than attacking). It's so much easier to play with the ball but I can see why Allegri prefers Pogba as LCM/B2B and why he'd like to have someone else for the AM spot (which I believe he still wants). Pogba is too much of a beast to not use him while defending, because he's tall and very strong. He can also keep the ball very well under pressure as well as drive it from our halt to opponent's. It'd be a waste to have 3 CMs that can only defend and putting Pogba as AM on top of that.

Besides we have had too many injuries this season so Allegri didn't really have a chance to experiment with midfield. Poor start made him fight for every point because if he won nothing this year his future here wouldn't look too bright.
So you agree with me? :shifty:
 

LiquidPLP

Senior Member
Jun 9, 2012
12,237
So you agree with me? :shifty:
If it was up to me I still would try Pogba as AM because we have a freak talent in the squad and still no treq Allegri asked for since he came. With Conte I was questioning his decisions all the time but Allegri taught me not to do it any more with CL final and the team's revival. I do it only on occasions like Alex Sandro being benched for Evra :p

As I wrote I don't agree that defending doesn't influence Pogba's offensive game which you implied.
 

Hydde

Minimiliano Tristelli
Mar 6, 2003
39,011
I would love to see him as AM, but to do that he seems to need to mature more. Some months ago he seemed to take all the wrong decitions in the 3/4 of the field (impossible shots, trying to dribble 4 players and losing the ball etc, being annoying), and thats a no go for a treq... but as of late he seems to be playing more composed with every passing game.

If Allegri used Vidal as a false treq, i dont see how he cannot use pogba who has a GREAT tackle and an eye for passes goals and dribbles. But i can see the issue of not letting pogba recover the ball deeper and help on the midfield, as he can do that very well.

If we sign berardi, i would like to see Pogba, Morata, DYbala and berardi all at the same time...and by using pogba as a treq this will not be possible,

So for the time being.. he will have to stay where he is, which is very good anyways.
 

zizinho

Senior Member
Apr 14, 2013
51,816
If it was up to me I still would try Pogba as AM because we have a freak talent in the squad and still no treq Allegri asked for since he came. With Conte I was questioning his decisions all the time but Allegri taught me not to do it any more with CL final and the team's revival. I do it only on occasions like Alex Sandro being benched for Evra :p

As I wrote I don't agree that defending doesn't influence Pogba's offensive game which you implied.
the thing is, Pogba is already having the freedom to go forward a lot. as an AM he would still be required to drop back and help defending. the only difference to now would be that he would play more centrally and we would have another CM next to Marchisio-Khedira with Khedira and the other CM defending the flanks. right now in the 3-5-2 he is the CM with most freedom to go forward and with Alex Sandro on that side he is able to find space more easier. by playing him further and more centrally he wont have as much space to take the ball and run with it and would be droping back for the ball a lot to free himself up. Basically its not worth it, changing his position would be a waste and there is no point doing it really
 

Ocelot

Midnight Marauder
Jul 13, 2013
18,943
Honestly, in this situation things like AM or B2B are just labels. I think he spends as much time going forward this season as Vidal did last season (as an AM), really pushes up a lot virtually every attack.
 

rndmlgnd

Senior Member
Oct 29, 2015
694
The current box-to-box role is ideal for him. It's even adjusted a bit as he regulary goes into the oppositions box looking to recieve passes or contest a header.

Making him into a trequartista would only limit his influence on the pitch. Modern playmakers are all in the mould of Iniesta, tricky little guys with quick feet who are always moving between the lines and playing short passes. Pogba dwells to much on the ball, as he's almost impossible to get knocked off the ball and taken posession from. For that he needs space and a trequartista usually has to create space for himself as the middle of the pitch is always packed with opposition players.
 

Hydde

Minimiliano Tristelli
Mar 6, 2003
39,011
Also when faced against opposing defenders, he has this weird urge to try to dribble them instead to look for a pass. Is like in his veins.

But he has improved on this a little as of late
 

Scottish

Zebrastreifenpferd
Mar 13, 2011
10,460
Honestly, in this situation things like AM or B2B are just labels. I think he spends as much time going forward this season as Vidal did last season (as an AM), really pushes up a lot virtually every attack.
He doesn't go into the box too much though. I'm not sure if I consider that a waste or a good thing considering his height and technique are both plus points.

I've been thinking about Pogba;

Is it any coincidence that Pogba is a different player now that the team as a whole is settled? Does he really rely on the rest of the squad that much or was all of the responsibility just a big shock for him and he has adjusted to it now? How confident would you be in him carrying our midfield and team should we have a similarly depleted squad again?
 

Albo

Senior Member
Apr 13, 2009
11,463
This guy :heart:

[video=facebook;1370663939627498]https://www.facebook.com/Juventus/videos/1370663939627498/[/video]

Allegri " Now i have beaten you with my feet and my hands " :lol:
 

rndmlgnd

Senior Member
Oct 29, 2015
694
This guy :heart:

[video=facebook;1370663939627498]https://www.facebook.com/Juventus/videos/1370663939627498/[/video]

Allegri " Now i have beaten you with my feet and my hands " :lol:
Came in to post that, brilliant vid. I love the relationship between the players and Allegri, he looks like a really good coach to have.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 162)