Mumbai Shootings (5 Viewers)

sidd

Junior Member
Sep 1, 2005
228
Ze....its not about blaming Pakistan....the Mariott bombings shocked and saddened us equally........But dont reject the fact that the ISI is responsible for the creation on such outfits such as LET, atleast in terms of providing training and logistical support. We arent saying Pakistan as a nation is responsible for this attack....but till now its established that the LET is......now how they sailed off with so much explosives and ammo...or trained in how to used em is anyones guess....btw the terrorist is custody has said that they were trained by an ex ISI officer.
I have nothing against pakistan as a nation or its people....but i wish they would have never supported these cunts in the first place to being with.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

Zé Tahir

JhoolayLaaaal!
Moderator
Dec 10, 2004
29,281
I haven't read anything about it being a fact that they were from Pakistan, sidd. As a matter of fact media and government officials have poured into Faridkot where this guy claims to be from and there's no trace.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/7759309.stm

Even if the ISI supported LET at some point, do you really think they're the only intelligence agency in the world to support separatists? Hasn't/doesn't India support Balochi and Ismaili seperatists in Pakistan? Brahamdagh Bugti is stirring up shit in Balochistan all the time, do you see us hounding your government down?
 

baggio

Senior Member
Jun 3, 2003
19,250
Last time I checked Lashakar-e-Taiba was banned over there. So unless you know the inner workings of the government or the ISI I really don't care what you have to say about that because it's nothing but hearsay.

You know why they retracted their statement? Because a) they're morons b) they realized that sending a senior official made them look guilty. About the satellite phone: do you really think that these people "forgot" it on the boat? This was one of the most well planned and executed crimes to the point where they had food stashed in the hotel rooms. I find it very hard to believe. All this might be true I would just like you to wait until you jump the gun.

I totally understand your frustration and I'm not telling you to point your fingers at anyone. Just don't point it at Pakistan every time you hear bang. Most Pakistani's are suffering with you. I don't think there's any Pakistani that I know or on these forums that doesn't feel bad about this. I followed the siege hour-by-hour and I was as angry as anyone about what was going on. Heck, I even saw the funeral of Karkare.

Correction. One was found on Kasav. The other one was in the boat, not as much forgotten as they needed to leave it there, because they'd planned to sail back on the 28th of November. Full marks for audacity.

I dont point fingers at Pakistan everytime I hear a bang. However, this time, there is no leeway for benefit of the doubt. Because the attacks on our monuments and the loss of lives, holding a city under siege for 60 hours has left me feeling nothing but devastated. With a trail of destruction that's got it's identity written all over it. The Lashkar maybe banned in Pakistan, then I wonder what Yousuf was doing dictating orders from Karachi. I agree, that terrorists cannot be racially or facially profiled, but Pakistan's stance has been soft for too long. And if they dont crack down hard enough, I fear they'll know first hand why India is developing into a world superpower.

You wont believe the kind of news that is reported on Pakistani channels, clips of which I just saw on youtube, where they say we orchestrated the attacks to get world opinion in our favour. It leaves me incredelous.
 

baggio

Senior Member
Jun 3, 2003
19,250
In Sanatan Dharma (Hinduism), the color deep saffron is associated with sacrifice and salvation. Saffron or "Bhagwa" is often worn by "Sanyasis" who have left their home in search of the ultimate.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saffron_(color)

is this true?


Yes, they were all wearing it. To disguise themselves as Hindus, they'd even unfortunately made it all too obvious when they walked in to their respective operations with 'tilaks' on their foreheads. Trying too hard to look Hindu I must say. And now that their identities have been established it's just showing the world how hard they tried to look Hindu, and subsequently, Indian.

Great planning like Ze said.
 

icemaη

Rab's Husband - The Regista
Moderator
Aug 27, 2008
36,323
Correction. One was found on Kasav. The other one was in the boat, not as much forgotten as they needed to leave it there, because they'd planned to sail back on the 28th of November. Full marks for audacity.

I dont point fingers at Pakistan everytime I hear a bang. However, this time, there is no leeway for benefit of the doubt. Because the attacks on our monuments and the loss of lives, holding a city under siege for 60 hours has left me feeling nothing but devastated. With a trail of destruction that's got it's identity written all over it. The Lashkar maybe banned in Pakistan, then I wonder what Yousuf was doing dictating orders from Karachi. I agree, that terrorists cannot be racially or facially profiled, but Pakistan's stance has been soft for too long. And if they dont crack down hard enough, I fear they'll know first hand why India is developing into a world superpower.

You wont believe the kind of news that is reported on Pakistani channels, clips of which I just saw on youtube, where they say we orchestrated the attacks to get world opinion in our favour. It leaves me incredelous.
Where'd you get that from? The terrorist who got caught said that they were specifically told not to return home or get caught alive...

I don't believe any of this media bullshit anymore... One point they say they were supposed to go home after killing 5000 people (like thats possible, the returning home part that is) and another time they say they were told to keep killing until they get killed...
 

baggio

Senior Member
Jun 3, 2003
19,250
I'm guessing your location is obviously across the border, and not Bangalore since you havent been following the news enough or not getting all the channels. Pay attention the next time.

The terrorists were lured into the operation being told they would not have to lay down their lives. And would come out alive.


From a news page:
One of the Mumbai attackers, Ajmal Amir Kamal confessed that the group had planned to sail out on November 27th. Their recruiters had even charted out the return route for the attackers and stored it on the Global Positioning System (GPS) device, which they had used to navigate on their way to the Mumbai shoreline. He also confessed that they were all trained in marine warfare along with the special course "Daura-e-Shifa" conducted by Lashkar-e-Toiba. Ajmal identified his associates as Abu Ali, Fahad, Omar, Shoaib, Umer, Abu Akasha Ismail, Abdul Rahman (Bada) and Abdul Rahman (Chhota) - all Pakistani citizens.
 

icemaη

Rab's Husband - The Regista
Moderator
Aug 27, 2008
36,323
And about the harbouring Dawood part... Dawood spent a considerable amount of time in Dubai... Why didn't we pressurize the UAE goverment to extradite him to India, even though we knew for sure that the Pakistan government wouldn't sent him to India once he set foot on Pakistan soil?

My only point is that we should not only be pointing fingers at others, we should be doing something ourselves... the number of people around me, who wants India to wage war against Pakistan is staggering... But the number of people I see asking for the removal of the head of IB or RAW is close to none... nobody talks about making a central agency to investigate terror...

There was a report in the newspaper today, when a person walked into the CST with a licensed revolver, passed the metal detector a few times and still the policemen didn't bother checking him... when he later showed them the gun and asked them why they didn't stop him, they said they didn't hear the metal detector beep...

These are things in our control which we aren't willing to improve on... yet we correctly or incorrectly blame Pakistan and forget our duties as a citizen of this country...
 

icemaη

Rab's Husband - The Regista
Moderator
Aug 27, 2008
36,323
I'm guessing your location is obviously across the border, and not Bangalore since you havent been following the news enough or not getting all the channels. Pay attention the next time.

The terrorists were lured into the operation being told they would not have to lay down their lives. And would come out alive.


From a news page:
One of the Mumbai attackers, Ajmal Amir Kamal confessed that the group had planned to sail out on November 27th. Their recruiters had even charted out the return route for the attackers and stored it on the Global Positioning System (GPS) device, which they had used to navigate on their way to the Mumbai shoreline. He also confessed that they were all trained in marine warfare along with the special course "Daura-e-Shifa" conducted by Lashkar-e-Toiba. Ajmal identified his associates as Abu Ali, Fahad, Omar, Shoaib, Umer, Abu Akasha Ismail, Abdul Rahman (Bada) and Abdul Rahman (Chhota) - all Pakistani citizens.

I'm sorry Baggio... I'm sitting in Karachi talking to Asif Ali Zardari while I made up that news...

From a news site in your country (obviously I'm not an Indian citizen, right?)
:(

Kasab told investigators they were given blueprints of all the four targets - Taj Hotel, Oberoi Hotel, Trident Hotel and Nariman House. They also received training in swimming and sailing, besides the use of high-end weapons and explosives.

Now that Kasab has been captured alive, he fears the worst for his family as chacha had given strict instructions that they should not return alive at any cost.

Kasab has told the police that he didn't know driving. His associate Abu Ismail Dera Ismail Khan, 25, drove the Skoda car they used for the get-away after the police vehicle they seized after killing ATS chief Hemant Karkare broke down.

When their Skoda neared Girgaum chowpatty, they ran into a police barricade. Ismail Khan succumbed in the ensuing exchange of fire and Kasab got injured in the hand. He was taken to Nair Hospital where he has been kept under heavy police protection.

http://www.dnaindia.com/report.asp?newsid=1210832&pageid=2
 

icemaη

Rab's Husband - The Regista
Moderator
Aug 27, 2008
36,323
Now we are talking...

Navy chief admits to intelligence failure

New Delhi: In a startling admission, the Indian Navy says the Coast Guard had intelligence about the boat that brought the terrorists to Mumbai.

The fishing trawler hijacked and used by the terrorists was intercepted by the Coast Guard in Indian territorial waters.

But the Coast Guard let the boat go after finding its documents in order.

Navy Chief Admiral Sureesh Mehta said that the Coast Guard was made aware of a possible sea attack and that ships had been deployed off Gujarat coast.

He also admitted lacunae existed in coastal security and intelligence sharing, and that better coordination was needed among the security and intelligence agencies.

But he also said the systemic failure that was brought about by Mumbai terror attacks needed to be taken stock of, says Navy chief as no actionable intelligence inputs were provided.


http://ibnlive.in.com/news/navy-chief-admits-to-intelligence-failure/79541-3.html
 

baggio

Senior Member
Jun 3, 2003
19,250
Iceman, the 'kill yourself' bit has been misunderstood by you. Operatives such as those in the Lashkar or Al Qaida, have a policy wherein they are made to understand that they'd rather be dead than captured alive to avoid leaking sensitive information as Kasav has been doing. Obviously, he'd underestimated policemen with 303s thinking they'd never match his AK-56 machinery. Unfortunately for him, they've got him with their lathis and kept him alive and if he were to return home now, he knows what awaits him and his family.

I dont know if you've ever been to Bombay from Bangalore or wherever it is you're at. :rolleyes: You sure dont sound like an Indian to me bro (not with your opinions at this point anyway) But you'll notice the palpable anger that's spilling on the city's streets. And you know what? We're cursing our politicians right now more than we are the Pakistanis, and rightfully so. So when you feel proud about putting up information like the Navy Chief admitting intelligence failure make sure you contextualize it, because this is not justifying anybody's actions.

Anyway, I dont want any further discussion on this issue with you or with anyone else. I've stayed away from this thread because I dont want it to go anywhere untoward but some responses got me involved.

Now, if you're keeping abreast of the news, we're going to be handing a list of most wanted terrorists to Pakistan, and dont intend to strike at them (fortunately for them) at this point.

Let's hope the world gets a ringside view of their co-operation.
 

icemaη

Rab's Husband - The Regista
Moderator
Aug 27, 2008
36,323
Iceman, the 'kill yourself' bit has been misunderstood by you. Operatives such as those in the Lashkar or Al Qaida, have a policy wherein they are made to understand that they'd rather be dead than captured alive to avoid leaking sensitive information as Kasav has been doing. Obviously, he'd underestimated policemen with 303s thinking they'd never match his AK-56 machinery. Unfortunately for him, they've got him with their lathis and kept him alive and if he were to return home now, he knows what awaits him and his family.

I dont know if you've ever been to Bombay from Bangalore or wherever it is you're at. :rolleyes: You sure dont sound like an Indian to me bro (not with your opinions at this point anyway) But you'll notice the palpable anger that's spilling on the city's streets. And you know what? We're cursing our politicians right now more than we are the Pakistanis, and rightfully so. So when you feel proud about putting up information like the Navy Chief admitting intelligence failure make sure you contextualize it, because this is not justifying anybody's actions.

Anyway, I dont want any further discussion on this issue with you or with anyone else. I've stayed away from this thread because I dont want it to go anywhere untoward but some responses got me involved.

Now, if you're keeping abreast of the news, we're going to be handing a list of most wanted terrorists to Pakistan, and dont intend to strike at them (fortunately for them) at this point.

Let's hope the world gets a ringside view of their co-operation.
I'ven't misunderstood the 'kill yourself' thing... If you check other news sites you'll come to know that they have come here on a suicide mission... only this time they didn't blow themselves up...

The reason my opinion sounds alien to you is because I haven't let my heart rule my head... yet...

Just critisizing the politicians is not enough... It wasn't only the politicians who were at fault... It was an intelligence failure... It took the navy 5 days to accept that... Instead we were blaming the Pakistani government from the word go... If the government had accepted an intelligence failure at first and then blamed Pakistan, I wouldn't have been irked as I'm now... You know how us Indians get hyped up when Pakistan is involved in anything, let it be war or cricket... So by pulling the 'its Pakistan who did it' line, the government managed to limit its damage in the firing line... People got so fired up around me that they wanted immediate military action on Pakistan... That to me is stupidity... The government successfully managed to turn the eye of a substantial number of people from questioning their failure... and to an extent that of the IB, RAW and the Navy...
I don't see people coming out from nowhere into this forum and screaming at our government... but I see a lot of people screaming at the ISI...
Ours bombing of Pakistan will not reduce the number of terrorist attacks in the future... It might only increase it... But our tightening of security forces, putting up NSG in major cities, upgrading the weapons used by our police officers etc. will allow us to thwart the attempts of terrorist attacks on our soil...


I am an Indian and proud to be one... Its one of the reasons why I'm still in India, even though I've been offered a better life abroad... Its one of the reasons I pay my taxes and not try to fake my returns... Its one of the reasons I don't bribe police officers and say things like 'Whats the use of paying to the goverment, it goes to the politicians pockets anyways'... My love for this country remains the same, terrorist attack or not... Just because I don't hate/blame Pakistan for everything happening around our country doesn't make me a lesser Indian...

And for the record, I've a soft corner for Pakistanis... I've lived around them for a long time... They are no different from us... they go through the same (actually more) problems like us... Most people who call for Pakistans blood have never met a Pakistani in real life... I'm not saying all of them are good, but there's evil everywhere... They are a misunderstood lot in India, just like Indians are in Pakistan... I think you get the flow...

I've been to bombay a couple of times but not recently...
 

HelterSkelter

Senior Member
Apr 15, 2005
20,567
Pakistan,a country at the hub of all terrorism,a country that has had a poltician assasinated,had 3 assasination attempts on the previous President,had the Marriott blown up,had the entire FIA building in Lahore blown up,a country that sufferes from terrorist activites every other day,a country that has a large chunk of its army battling these very terrorists...

Yes im sure,we as the biggest victims of terrorism worldwide,would enjoy provoking our nuclear power of a neighbhour.It all makes perfect sense.

A bird sneezed in Chennai.The ISI and Pakistani Government were involved,right?

So Baggio,your blood boils?Fuck that.Why are you people so fucking obsessed with Pakistan?The attacks on the parliament back in the day,and you blame Pakistan..and boom,your troops come out on the border.The Mumbai killings,and you blame Pakistan..and now you'll move your troops out on the border again.Is anti-ISI and anti-Pakistani Government notions is all they teach you in India?I mean,for fucks sake,is RAW some innocent body that does not screw in Pakistan?But do you see us blaming you for the countless acts of terrorism that we've suffered from?So Mumbai got attacked.Boo Fucking Hoo.Multiply what you feel by a million,and that'll give you an idea about what people in Pakistan suffer from.But do we blame India everytime?Benazir's assasination,The Marriott blasts,The FIA attack,The attack's on Musharaff,The support for Akbar Bugti etc...do we whine about how India was responsbile?Your OWN fucking political analysts have come out and defended Pakistan and said that the Indian media shouldnt stir up a useless propaganda.I dont know their names,but if i read their comments next time,ill mention them here.You know what's funny?The fact that your Government has not come up with any hostile statements,but your oh-so-innocent Media,is on its usual anti-Pakistan propaganda.Dana Perino has come in and defended Pakistan.And no,before you give me your boring theory about how these terrorists were groomed..i'll remind you of what Ahmed,Tahir and I have been talking about for the last 6 pages - The ISI,The Pakistani Governmet,and these terrorists,are seperate entities.The Government does not control the ISI.The Chief Of The Army Staff does.Terrorists operating from within Pakistan cannot all be controlled.If they could,then we wouldnt be at the center of all this mess in the first place.Lahore,Karachi,Islamabad,Quetta..it doesnt matter where the calls were located from.The calls could be located from my next door neighbour for all i fucking care,but the ISI and the Pakistani Government CANNOT control them.I repeat,if it could,then we'd be cleaning up the mess in our country rather than going in for a little adventure in Mumbai.

Honestly,grow the fuck up and clear up the anti-Pakistan trash that your motherfucking media has stuffed inside you.If your blood boils,so does mine.
 

baggio

Senior Member
Jun 3, 2003
19,250
icεmαή;1822425 said:
I'ven't misunderstood the 'kill yourself' thing... If you check other news sites you'll come to know that they have come here on a suicide mission... only this time they didn't blow themselves up...

The reason my opinion sounds alien to you is because I haven't let my heart rule my head... yet...

Just critisizing the politicians is not enough... It wasn't only the politicians who were at fault... It was an intelligence failure... It took the navy 5 days to accept that... Instead we were blaming the Pakistani government from the word go... If the government had accepted an intelligence failure at first and then blamed Pakistan, I wouldn't have been irked as I'm now... You know how us Indians get hyped up when Pakistan is involved in anything, let it be war or cricket... So by pulling the 'its Pakistan who did it' line, the government managed to limit its damage in the firing line... People got so fired up around me that they wanted immediate military action on Pakistan... That to me is stupidity... The government successfully managed to turn the eye of a substantial number of people from questioning their failure... and to an extent that of the IB, RAW and the Navy...
I don't see people coming out from nowhere into this forum and screaming at our government... but I see a lot of people screaming at the ISI...
Ours bombing of Pakistan will not reduce the number of terrorist attacks in the future... It might only increase it... But our tightening of security forces, putting up NSG in major cities, upgrading the weapons used by our police officers etc. will allow us to thwart the attempts of terrorist attacks on our soil...


I am an Indian and proud to be one... Its one of the reasons why I'm still in India, even though I've been offered a better life abroad... Its one of the reasons I pay my taxes and not try to fake my returns... Its one of the reasons I don't bribe police officers and say things like 'Whats the use of paying to the goverment, it goes to the politicians pockets anyways'... My love for this country remains the same, terrorist attack or not... Just because I don't hate/blame Pakistan for everything happening around our country doesn't make me a lesser Indian...

And for the record, I've a soft corner for Pakistanis... I've lived around them for a long time... They are no different from us... they go through the same (actually more) problems like us... Most people who call for Pakistans blood have never met a Pakistani in real life... I'm not saying all of them are good, but there's evil everywhere... They are a misunderstood lot in India, just like Indians are in Pakistan... I think you get the flow...

I've been to bombay a couple of times but not recently...


Try finding a thread here called 'India rocks'. We'd gone through similar reactions in the 06 blasts. Through that thread, you'll know how much I am for unity in the sub continent. I dont know too many Pakistanis in person, though I was in touch with Salman and Ze on these forums when I had a little more time on my hands. Salman in particular knows how chilled out I normally am, and before I forget, have both my Nani and Dadi hailing from Model Town Lahore.

So there is definitely a sense of nostalgia when it comes to pre-partition especially when I hear their stories. And how they wish these countries never broke up. It doesnt take much to see how similar we are as people either. Someone in the family is to marry a girl with Pakistani origin, and it's a wedding all of us would be looking forward to, for the mix of culture and tradition that it will bring. So dont misintepret the statements. I've never had any problems with Pakistani people, because like you are quite right in saying, they are no different. I dont understand them, but I do islam, coz I've got a lot of muslim friends. It really is an issue with the politicians that represent them and the sorry excuse for an intelligence agency and army that is given the responsibility of defending them. Collectively speaking, I dont rate Pakistan very highly as a country, because of its lax approach to democracy and regressive ideologies. That is probably why they aren't as thriving a nation as India is. We belong to the free world, our ways and methods are such.

You know why we get 'hyped' which I wouldn't agree with as a term, is because we chase a united front. Their artists come here to earn a living, their citizens do too, we accept them with open arms. So if there is something of this nature that finds its roots on their soil, we are bound to feel a sense of anger. And we should be allowed to do so. I'm sick and tired of seeing the news around me, and especially hearing the opinions of people like these.

http://in.youtube.com/watch?v=Eij5o7XizIA

If you follow the pictures being relayed on channels here, of people on the streets you'll see, there is no communal tension here. Both, Hindus and Muslims are united in this war against terror and that's how it should be. Unlike '93, there is a sense of maturity that gives me so much confidence in our great country.

I'm completely for everything that you say in terms of security. There is no doubt in my mind that we introspect before we question others. But that's what has happened here. A knee jerk reaction at this point would make things highly unstable. And at the same time, this anger needs to be channelised. But that's exactly how the government has been approaching it. We're not saying Pakistan failed us. We're saying our intelligence was caught off, but Pakistan now needs to co-operate given the leads we've got. Which is exactly what should be happening.

The NSG can no longer be the preserve of the capital, to the best of my knowledge the RAW had passed on this information before the attack. But because of these guys coming in on the night of the operation, it was very hard to trace anything down, due to the lack of specifics.

It's like one of the debates on the news here threw up. The government doesnt deserve any of the taxes so they can buy themselves fancy cars and dole out land to their bed buddies. It's taken an event like this on our symbol of culture, wealth, art, architecture and power to wake up and take notice of the times we live in. Like 9/11 wasn't enough.

Having said all of this, I think India has the right to defend itself as a sovereign state. And bring the guilty to justice. There is no other way to react to such a dastardly act, whatever the consequences.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 5)