Rosetta Stoned is one of their best songs... the buildup and the 'overwhelmed as one would be...' part is maybe my favourite part in any Tool song. Although for epic I don't think you can beat the last minute and a half of The Patient and Schism.
Right In Two is amazing too. I assume you must be referring to Intension and Viginti Trees which I agree with.
RS has it's moments IMO, i like it but i guess not as much as you do. It has fantastic lyrics though, and i like the fact they were experimenting with new elements, that's always welcomed. It was a pretty entertaining song to see live in 2007.
Right in two is a pretty meh song to Tool's standard, and yes, i was referring to Intension/Viginti Trees and the instrumental tracks. I love instrumental musci in general and i love it when they feel and sound kinda connected to the rest of the album, that's not the case in 10k days.
When you wait that long you expect a lot. And those excuses of songs weren't enough to fill that hole.