out now?


  • Total voters
    166
  • Poll closed .

dolph

Senior Member
Mar 30, 2006
2,599
I sort of agree with you. However I don't buy the just being lucky argument. We've simply been more ruthless than quite a few of our opponents in the past. Scoring your chances is a big part of football.

Even if we use Neddy's favorite xG it shows that it was pretty close. So according to this stat our chances were fewer but much better in quality.

DXt6yZdXcAEKLkG.jpg
Offcourse its a big part of football. to be clinical, but it does not mean its a tactical masterclass that your opponent are not clinical. Its just luck or lack of quality in their finishing, and you cant give your own coach credit that the other teams finishing sucks.
 
Jun 6, 2015
11,391
Offcourse its a big part of football. to be clinical, but it does not mean its a tactical masterclass that your opponent are not clinical. Its just luck or lack of quality in their finishing, and you cant give your own coach credit that the other teams finishing sucks.
It's not only about opponents bad finishing. Allegri teams usually try to limit the actual quality chances of the opponent. Allegri loves control and by that I don't mean having the ball. I mean slowing the pace of the game down and putting the two blocks of four behind the ball when defending. At our best we did that to great effect under Allegri.

People are free to dislike such tactics, but it doesn't mean that you are somehow less deserving of a win using such tactics. The only real factual thing in football is the scoreline at the end of the game. That is what defines who was the better team. That involves defending, passing, scoring goals, goalkeeping etc.. It's simplistic to only look at who shoots more and has more of the ball, those are only parts of the game.

- - - Updated - - -

any rumblings on where Max will go next? Foletti, Grani and the rest of the gang need to feed their families
I think he'll take a break to wait for managerial positions open up next season.
 

dolph

Senior Member
Mar 30, 2006
2,599
It's not only about opponents bad finishing. Allegri teams usually try to limit the actual quality chances of the opponent. Allegri loves control and by that I don't mean having the ball. I mean slowing the pace of the game down and putting the two blocks of four behind the ball when defending. At our best we did that to great effect under Allegri.

People are free to dislike such tactics, but it doesn't mean that you are somehow less deserving of a win using such tactics. The only real factual thing in football is the scoreline at the end of the game. That is what defines who was the better team. That involves defending, passing, scoring goals, goalkeeping etc.. It's simplistic to only look at who shoots more and has more of the ball, those are only parts of the game.
Its even more simplistic to look at the score line only and then conclude, who is the better team.
And I do agree that Allegri’s biggest strenght is or at least has been, to set up the defense and hit teams on the counter. Our entire CHL run is his first season was prove of that, the game against Barca away in his 3 year was prove of that, the home game against Barca, when he was still Milan coach, was a Real tactical masterpiece, but you cant seriously watch the game against Tottenham and with a straight face tell me that we controlled that game, and it was some kind of tactical Masterclass performance.
 
Jun 6, 2015
11,391
Its even more simplistic to look at the score line only and then conclude, who is the better team.
And I do agree that Allegri’s biggest strenght is or at least has been, to set up the defense and hit teams on the counter. Our entire CHL run is his first season was prove of that, the game against Barca away in his 3 year was prove of that, the home game against Barca, when he was still Milan coach, was a Real tactical masterpiece, but you cant seriously watch the game against Tottenham and with a straight face tell me that we controlled that game, and it was some kind of tactical Masterclass performance.
That's what determines the better team though. We can disagree on how that should be accomplished, but in the end it doesn't change the fact that the point of football is to score more than your opponent and that's how the winner is decided. Better team is the one who is better at accomplishing that. The problem is that some can't accept this in today's football. People only accept the tiki-taka possession based football and don't give any credit to teams/managers who play a different style even if they accomplish better results.

You are right on the Tottenham game, we certainly didn't control the game like Allegri wants. That was our biggest problem in some games during some of the games during the last two years. We used to be completely dominant in controlling games. I remember stretches of games where the opponents didn't have any chances to score, yet people fail to acknowledge how dominant Allegri made us.
 

Strickland

Senior Member
May 17, 2019
5,859
I'm not sure there are many openings int top teams at the moment. Only Serie A teams seem to be changing coaches.
I think teams like PSG, Bayern, Chelsea, Arsenal or United would all change if they thought highly of Allegri and he was available,. All have okayish or good coaches, but if a much better option becomes available those are the coaches you ditch for the long term success
 
Jun 6, 2015
11,391
I think teams like PSG, Bayern, Chelsea, Arsenal or United would all change if they thought highly of Allegri and he was available,. All have okayish or good coaches, but if a much better option becomes available those are the coaches you ditch for the long term success
I'm not sure there are many clubs that like to just fire a manager because someone else is available. Pep is perhaps the only exception to that rule.
 

dolph

Senior Member
Mar 30, 2006
2,599
That's what determines the better team though. We can disagree on how that should be accomplished, but in the end it doesn't change the fact that the point of football is to score more than your opponent and that's how the winner is decided. Better team is the one who is better at accomplishing that. The problem is that some can't accept this in today's football. People only accept the tiki-taka possession based football and don't give any credit to teams/managers who play a different style even if they accomplish better results.

You are right on the Tottenham game, we certainly didn't control the game like Allegri wants. That was our biggest problem in some games during some of the games during the last two years. We used to be completely dominant in controlling games. I remember stretches of games where the opponents didn't have any chances to score, yet people fail to acknowledge how dominant Allegri made us.
I really dont agree on this. The better side is the most dominant controlling side in the match. I do realise its a question of definition though, but if your are the more dominant controlling side odds are you are going to be more succesfull in the long run.
Personally I like more possesion based attacking football, than what was normal under Allegri, but that does not mean I dont rate him as a coach, or dont recognise that he did a fantastic job here on the large scale.
 

Vialli_92

Senior Member
Mar 7, 2013
6,500
To me it looks like the management want to transition the club away from the setereotypical defensive approach of Italian football and move to a more modern way of playing with quicker transitions and higher pressing with the names being linked to the club

It really will not be an easy transition and will take some years before I think we successfully implement something like that and I think future managers will be picked on that style as well but if it fails in the next few years I have no doubt Allegri will be on the bench again as he's a guaranteed bet on winning and keeping consistency
 

.zero

★ ★ ★
Aug 8, 2006
82,842
To me it looks like the management want to transition the club away from the setereotypical defensive approach of Italian football and move to a more modern way of playing with quicker transitions and higher pressing with the names being linked to the club

It really will not be an easy transition and will take some years before I think we successfully implement something like that and I think future managers will be picked on that style as well but if it fails in the next few years I have no doubt Allegri will be on the bench again as he's a guaranteed bet on winning and keeping consistency
It’s much simpler than that actually. The club wants to conquer Europe.

But if they hire Sarri then they are content with conquering Italy and collecting TV revenues from knockout stage runs in the CL.

If that’s the case then it confirms that the club is being run the way it should be. Despite my conflicting views as a fan.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 

s4tch

Senior Member
Mar 23, 2015
33,651
...the management want to transition the club away from the setereotypical defensive approach of Italian football and move to a more modern way of playing with quicker transitions and higher pressing with the names being linked to the club
that's pure fantasy

juventus is all about the results, and the management is smart enough to leave tactics and style to whoever they'll hire
 

Vialli_92

Senior Member
Mar 7, 2013
6,500
that's pure fantasy

juventus is all about the results, and the management is smart enough to leave tactics and style to whoever they'll hire
We would not have sacked Allegri if that was the case, he has a proven winning formula and has come close to conquering Europe on 2 occasions. It does not make sense to sack Allegri if we are only interested in results
 

s4tch

Senior Member
Mar 23, 2015
33,651
We would not have sacked Allegri if that was the case, he has a proven winning formula and has come close to conquering Europe on 2 occasions. It does not make sense to sack Allegri if we are only interested in results
of course it does. management met allegri on a daily basis, and could see whether he was still able to motivate the squad. he probably wasn't.

do you remember last season's "the squad needed a shake-up and that was ronaldo" quotes? for this season, that will be a new coach.
 

lgorTudor

Senior Member
Jan 15, 2015
32,951
We would not have sacked Allegri if that was the case, he has a proven winning formula and has come close to conquering Europe on 2 occasions. It does not make sense to sack Allegri if we are only interested in results
If you missed it, we got beaten by Ajax

pls stop pushing that narrative that our board cares about 'Attacking play' or 'entertaining play'
 

Vialli_92

Senior Member
Mar 7, 2013
6,500
of course it does. management met allegri on a daily basis, and could see whether he was still able to motivate the squad. he probably wasn't.

do you remember last season's "the squad needed a shake-up and that was ronaldo" quotes? for this season, that will be a new coach.
Well you could be right but in my opinion I think the change of the style of play is the main reason for changing Allegri

- - - Updated - - -

If you missed it, we got beaten by Ajax

pls stop pushing that narrative that our board cares about 'Attacking play' or 'entertaining play'
Ajax have a very good team, maybe might have been a surprise at the time but looking at them now they have some top players in that team that could play for any top club

The lack of identity and any sort of attacking gameplan is why I think Allegri was let go, with Juve in Europe you didn't know what team was going to turn up or how they would approach the game so for me that is why we are linked with these attacking coaches because you know exactly how the team will play and what they will be trying to do
 
Jun 6, 2015
11,391
To me it looks like the management want to transition the club away from the setereotypical defensive approach of Italian football and move to a more modern way of playing with quicker transitions and higher pressing with the names being linked to the club

It really will not be an easy transition and will take some years before I think we successfully implement something like that and I think future managers will be picked on that style as well but if it fails in the next few years I have no doubt Allegri will be on the bench again as he's a guaranteed bet on winning and keeping consistency
I really don't think we're that far off from playing a more expansive style of football if we really wanted to. We have quite a few players that would actually be more suited to that kind of football. The technical level of our players isn't as bad as some seem to think.
 
Jun 6, 2015
11,391
Fuck style of play

Style wasn’t the reason we’ve bombed Serie A for the past 8 seasons


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
I think style has played a big part in our domination. We've been able to change our style for those past eight seasons when needed which has made us unpredictable. The problem is that there are plenty of people on this forum that only understand and accept one particular style of football. Having said that this seems to be a common theme among your usual football fans.
 
Last edited:

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 217)