out now?


  • Total voters
    166
  • Poll closed .

zizinho

Senior Member
Apr 14, 2013
51,816
Pep had Zlatan ffs and didn't know what to do with him!
He could've turned Zlatan into a GOD, but he didn't know what to do. Had Pep managed Zlatan properly, he would've made the Van Bastens and Shevas of the world look like pussies with that Barca team.
Zlatan - Messi duo would be one of the best ever. He had no clue how to use Zlatan, even Mancini and Blanc figured it out :lol:
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

Fr3sh

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2011
37,254
Comparing prime Suarez to washed-up Henry who went to MLS a year later. And Villa to Neymar. :sergio:

- - - Updated - - -




Zlatan who has choked in Europe everywhere he went :baus:
Villa was as prolific if not more than Neymar, I remember he was scoring a stupid amount of goal despite playing of the wing, and Henry isn't/wasn't as great as Suarez, because Suarez is life. But Villa was absolutely amazing for Barcelona, Henry just came along for a ride and a free UCL trophy.

Zlatan got kicked out of Barca because he was doing what he wanted and he was about to smash records and force Messi to the wing, but Messi throw tantrum and Mama Pep got mad at Zlatan and kicked him out.
 

Post Ironic

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2013
42,253
What utter nonsense. No one has argued that Pep is the best coach of all-time or that he is even the best coach out there today... Most of us who acknowledge his merits don't even want him here... but you have to be a Trump-style lunatic to think he's some mediocre coach with no pedigree.

- - - Updated - - -

Villa was as prolific if not more than Neymar, I remember he was scoring a stupid amount of goal despite playing of the wing, and Henry isn't/wasn't as great as Suarez, because Suarez is life. But Villa was absolutely amazing for Barcelona, Henry just came along for a ride and a free UCL trophy.

Zlatan got kicked out of Barca because he was doing what he wanted and he was about to smash records and force Messi to the wing, but Messi throw tantrum and Mama Pep got mad at Zlatan and kicked him out.
:rofl:

Your memories of Villa at Barca are pretty damn shoddy. He certainly wasn't tearing up the scoring charts. 4 goals in 12 games in 10-11, Pep's 2nd CL title. Really tore it up.

And it was Eto'o who was the big scorer aside from Messi in Pep's first CL title. Villa wasn't there yet.
 
Jun 6, 2015
11,391
This Pep bashing is ridiculous. I don't like the guy but playing down his accomplishments is just sad. I have no clue why people have this huge urge to put him down nowadays every time there is the slightest of reasons (that applies to fans and pundits).

He has done very well thus far in his career and personally wouldn't bet against him winning a lot more in the future. People too often let emotions and personal preference cloud their judgement on things and somehow many see Pep as some kind of devil that is trying to change the game they love so much. Arrogant? Yes. Stubborn? Yes. Then again which manager on some level isn't.
 

Post Ironic

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2013
42,253
This Pep bashing is ridiculous. I don't like the guy but playing down his accomplishments is just sad. I have no clue why people have this huge urge to put him down nowadays every time there is the slightest of reasons (that applies to fans and pundits).

He has done very well thus far in his career and personally wouldn't bet against him winning a lot more in the future. People too often let emotions and personal preference cloud their judgement on things and somehow many see Pep as some kind of devil that is trying to change the game they love so much. Arrogant? Yes. Stubborn? Yes. Then again which manager on some level isn't.
:agree:

Great post.
 

Dostoevsky

Tzu
Administrator
May 27, 2007
89,022
This Pep bashing is ridiculous. I don't like the guy but playing down his accomplishments is just sad. I have no clue why people have this huge urge to put him down nowadays every time there is the slightest of reasons (that applies to fans and pundits).

He has done very well thus far in his career and personally wouldn't bet against him winning a lot more in the future. People too often let emotions and personal preference cloud their judgement on things and somehow many see Pep as some kind of devil that is trying to change the game they love so much. Arrogant? Yes. Stubborn? Yes. Then again which manager on some level isn't.
Because he left Barca and started choking hard.
 

Fr3sh

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2011
37,254
What utter nonsense. No one has argued that Pep is the best coach of all-time or that he is even the best coach out there today... Most of us who acknowledge his merits don't even want him here... but you have to be a Trump-style lunatic to think he's some mediocre coach with no pedigree.

- - - Updated - - -



:rofl:

Your memories of Villa at Barca are pretty damn shoddy. He certainly wasn't tearing up the scoring charts. 4 goals in 12 games in 10-11, Pep's 2nd CL title. Really tore it up.

And it was Eto'o who was the big scorer aside from Messi in Pep's first CL title. Villa wasn't there yet.
Whatever man, it's not like I follow Barca, I don't care for them. I just wanted Eto'o but Inter got him instead and he rewarded them with a treble.


Pep of course has some professional credentials and his a competent coach, however his skills are only apparent in certain fixed settings. He can't just be place in an average team and expect him to pull out some results, hell I'm even willing to bet that if he received the Liverpool job he wouldn't be doing all to much better then Klopp is right now. Pep needs to work with excellence to produce excellent results. He's no Conte, or Allegri, to be honest I prefer coaches that can create something out nothing, I rate the Ranieri's of the world. I'm serious, look at Mourinho's Chelsea, it was Ranieri that laid down the ground work, look at the Roma team he coached that failed to beat Inter was an excellent squad tinkered by the Tinkerman, even his Juventus side fresh out B was a decent squad. Pep can't do that, he can't do a third of what coaches like Ranieri can, that's why I rate Ranieri more then I will ever rate Pep.
 

Fr3sh

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2011
37,254
This Pep bashing is ridiculous. I don't like the guy but playing down his accomplishments is just sad. I have no clue why people have this huge urge to put him down nowadays every time there is the slightest of reasons (that applies to fans and pundits).

He has done very well thus far in his career and personally wouldn't bet against him winning a lot more in the future. People too often let emotions and personal preference cloud their judgement on things and somehow many see Pep as some kind of devil that is trying to change the game they love so much. Arrogant? Yes. Stubborn? Yes. Then again which manager on some level isn't.
Pep can clean @Post Ironic's dirty bum hole with his tongue.
 

lgorTudor

Senior Member
Jan 15, 2015
32,951
Pep's reputation on the mainstream football media is utterly out of proportion to his actual achievements. I rate Simeone, Conte, Allegri, Ancelotti, Emery (+maybe Zidane) higher that Pep.
 

zizinho

Senior Member
Apr 14, 2013
51,816
What utter nonsense. No one has argued that Pep is the best coach of all-time or that he is even the best coach out there today... Most of us who acknowledge his merits don't even want him here... but you have to be a Trump-style lunatic to think he's some mediocre coach with no pedigree.

- - - Updated - - -



:rofl:

Your memories of Villa at Barca are pretty damn shoddy. He certainly wasn't tearing up the scoring charts. 4 goals in 12 games in 10-11, Pep's 2nd CL title. Really tore it up.

And it was Eto'o who was the big scorer aside from Messi in Pep's first CL title. Villa wasn't there yet.
And no ones saying he sucks, just that there are better coaches out there. What he did with Barca and Bayern was great/good, but nothing extraordinary that no one else could do. At City i can see him become a failure because he wont be able to play his football brand with EPL players and he doesent know to play any other way. Hes a good coach that was in the right place at the right time but definitely not the best in the world and not justifiable of the hype around him
 

Dostoevsky

Tzu
Administrator
May 27, 2007
89,022
I'll give him one thing: Pep is classy and knows how to dress.

Let's keep this to Allegri.

And no, I'm not butthurt and abusing mod powers right now, I'd just like to keep it a bit cleaner here. I don't mind the topic, but we should move it somewhere else. Like EPL thread. Not that I would join it, because Pep is not worthy of my time. :D
 

Post Ironic

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2013
42,253
Whatever man, it's not like I follow Barca, I don't care for them. I just wanted Eto'o but Inter got him instead and he rewarded them with a treble.


Pep of course has some professional credentials and his a competent coach, however his skills are only apparent in certain fixed settings. He can't just be place in an average team and expect him to pull out some results, hell I'm even willing to bet that if he received the Liverpool job he wouldn't be doing all to much better then Klopp is right now. Pep needs to work with excellence to produce excellent results. He's no Conte, or Allegri, to be honest I prefer coaches that can create something out nothing, I rate the Ranieri's of the world. I'm serious, look at Mourinho's Chelsea, it was Ranieri that laid down the ground work, look at the Roma team he coached that failed to beat Inter was an excellent squad tinkered by the Tinkerman, even his Juventus side fresh out B was a decent squad. Pep can't do that, he can't do a third of what coaches like Ranieri can, that's why I rate Ranieri more then I will ever rate Pep.
You rate Ranieri who managed to make both us and Inter underperform? It's just another instance of overreacting to a single season. Ranieri won at LC and sucked at pretty much all the big teams he coached.

Ranieri > Pep is just beyond laughable.
 
Jun 6, 2015
11,391
Pep's reputation on the mainstream football media is utterly out of proportion to his actual achievements. I rate Simeone, Conte, Allegri, Ancelotti, Emery (+maybe Zidane) higher that Pep.
I actually think it's very mainstream to bash him at the moment. Seen plenty of English pundits do that this year because he has been "found out" at the marvelous PL.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 16, Guests: 567)