This is exactly what I think. I think Allegri has been put into a pickle by Marotta in the sense that Marotta left it very very late after selling Vidal to wrap up our purchases in the transfer market. We had Alex Sandro, Cuadrado, Hernanes, who all figure to be important parts of this team, coming in after the season had already begun.
I honestly don't think we'll finish lower than 2nd, but even 3rd is managable as we'd be seeded in the CL playoffs and probably easily get in. As I said, if we finish in CL places and get out of group stage in CL this year, I'll be content with the both Allegri and Marotta having successfully navigated a very difficult transition. I won't be super happy to not win anything, but I'll accept that as a successful transition year.
If these things don't happen,
then Allegri and Marotta need to share blame and need to figure out what exactly went wrong this year.