The point about his ability to transform broken teams tactically and most importantly mentally stands even if he had a bad season at Chelsea, which he still ended with a trophy and happened due to off the pitch fall out with management early in the season.
Great coaches have bad seasons often but then bounce back. His record doesn't have to be 100% for the point to stand he is not Floyd Mayweather. Liverpool just had a bad season by their standards and objectives. Klopps Dortmund collapsed at the end of the cycle. Zidane had a bad season at Madrid. So did Allegri with us and may happen again this season. Same with Simeone or even Tuchel.
None of these cases cancel the overall trend of their work which is winning. We are about to watch him try Spurs now.
If he somehow makes this turd Spurs win a trophy of any kind or by some magic even the EPL, would that satisfy you? Or would you still consider the one Chelsea season as evidence that he is not a great builder?
He had a fall out with management for the players they sold - Matic and Costa, that doesnt mean he had issues with the players like Mourinho had before him. And if your theory of him transforming teams is true, he should have done the same with that team. They went from champions to 5th place, missing out on CL. From 93 pts to 70. And dont give me the FA Cup. Pirlo inherited a 83 pts team, lost 2 leaders in midfield Pjanic and Matuidi, finished 4th with just 5 pts less, and won the Coppa and Supercoppa. Passed the CL group stage. All this in his first season as a coach ever, yet you guys dub him a joke.
Teams can have bad years, end of cycle happens, but Conte just won the title comfortably in his first season. That team was at their peak still and failed bad. Show me a season of Zidane, Klopp, Allegri like that. Hes a tantrum thrower, he wanted to riot when we sold Matri and Giaccherini ffs, so he has only himself to blame if he doesnt trust the team he was given. Look at Allegri now, shit team but he keeps playing Szczesny to restore his confidence, then Morata now with his shit form. Rabiot is garbage all year but he sees something in him and keeps giving him chances. Allegri could easily go out and complain about how garbage this team is. Or throw a tantrum for losing Pirlo, Vidal, Tevez and getting a unproven Dybala and Khedira. Or losing Pogba without replacement. No 10e in 100e restaurant comments, no where we came from etc.
I dont know the objectives of Tottenham, but i doubt its winning League Cup or Conference League. They will get more money by relegating to Championship than playing those. It will be great if they win anything ofcourse, but i think the clubs objectives are top4 in England rather than a small cup. Lets see how he does in the league