I'd say Bonucci has made more costly errors (those leading to goal) than Chiellini. But Chiellini has been more error prone and is much less of a defender than he was a couple of seasons ago. Our only saving grace individually has been Barzagli and the fact that our defensive output has been much more than the sum of it's individual parts (having some really solid midfielders help).
Buy on AliExpress.com