Mafia : Immortality (9 Viewers)

[Klin]

A couple of thoughts about ILFJ's claim that he's the D.

Remember Alen saying that there was a game where the Gs tried to whack a BG that was protecting himself? The Gs lost.
Now, which player is most desired by the Gs to be recruited? Jailer.

ILFJ came here right before the jailing deadline claiming he's the D. If the jailer would have panicked he would put ILFJ in the jail. It would mean that J is amongst a couple active users just before the j deadline.

When the j deadline passed ILFJ wrote it was only a joke. Still a good situation for the Gs - BG is not sure about ILFJ's words. Usually during the first night BG just protects himself, so if Gs send an order to whack him when he's protected they could easily lost like Alen said. With ILFJ's words BG could decide to protect him in case he's the real D so the BG was unprotected during the night.

What if the jailer is active but not posting? How can they calculate that?

That would have been a pretty long shot for someone to claim he's the D so the BG could protect him instead of himself. What's the probability of the Gs whacking the BG blindly? Very low, unless really lucky.

Voting has been opened

What is your stance on moving the daytime at least 1 hour earlier?

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Tomice]

I must admit I made a bad move yeterday.

I honestly thought nither Salvo nor Shiek are G's, When I saw Matt vote Shiek I've voted as well to put some pressure on him or to smoke out the G's but it backfierd a bit as I've realised too late that Sheik isn't a G and so is Salvo probably and I've missed the voting deadline.

What can we do learn from all this thought? I think the most of the G's aren't in the votes for Salvo or Sheik. when it was clear they are both going to be voted off or atleast one of them and no lynch then they had no reason to rise suss by voting either.

A couple of thoughts about ILFJ's claim that he's the D.

Remember Alen saying that there was a game where the Gs tried to whack a BG that was protecting himself? The Gs lost.
Now, which player is most desired by the Gs to be recruited? Jailer.

ILFJ came here right before the jailing deadline claiming he's the D. If the jailer would have panicked he would put ILFJ in the jail. It would mean that J is amongst a couple active users just before the j deadline.

When the j deadline passed ILFJ wrote it was only a joke. Still a good situation for the Gs - BG is not sure about ILFJ's words. Usually during the first night BG just protects himself, so if Gs send an order to whack him when he's protected they could easily lost like Alen said. With ILFJ's words BG could decide to protect him in case he's the real D so the BG was unprotected during the night.

Very good post right there. If true or not

And lets assume Voller did unknowingly gave hints of being a special role it all adds ups. So far for me this is the only theory that might be true

 

[piotrr]

What if the jailer is active but not posting? How can they calculate that?

That would have been a pretty long shot for someone to claim he's the D so the BG could protect him instead of himself. What's the probability of the Gs whacking the BG blindly? Very low, unless really lucky.

See, i know there are a lot of if's in my post, it's just a probable theory. What's your opinion on ILFJ's behaviour yesterday? Just messing around to complicate things for Cs?

 

[Salvo]

So far, I am the most unsure about ILFJ, other than that, I sort of have to look at the inactive ones. We have seen, being quiet usually means you do not want to get involved, don't want to draw attention. Normally there is a G there somewhere.

 

[Klin]

See, i know there are a lot of if's in my post, it's just a probable theory. What's your opinion on ILFJ's behaviour yesterday? Just messing around to complicate things for Cs?

I don't really know. Let's ask a few questions though.

What would a G gain from such behavior?

- Finding out who's the jailer : Maybe, but still not that easy.
- The BG will protect ILFJ instead of himself and the Gs will make a lucky guess on whacking the BG : A pretty long shot.
- Get a reaction from the real D : Could be a cheap tactic, yeah. I've seen it work before.

What would a C gain from such behavior?

- Lulz?

 

[Cuti]

Fresh, Chocolate, Lemon and Gep have all been very quiet on the posting side, so personally i think at least 1 of them is a G...haven't decided as yet whom to vote for today though

 

[Klin]

So far, I am the most unsure about ILFJ, other than that, I sort of have to look at the inactive ones. We have seen, being quiet usually means you do not want to get involved, don't want to draw attention. Normally there is a G there somewhere.

This would be confirmed if you were a G, which explains why no one came to save you yesterday.

- - - Updated - - -

Fresh, Chocolate, Lemon and Gep have all been very quiet on the posting side, so personally i think at least 1 of them is a G...haven't decided as yet whom to vote for today though

What is your obsession with Mr. Chocolate?

 

[Bezzy]

Fresh, Chocolate, Lemon and Gep have all been very quiet on the posting side, so personally i think at least 1 of them is a G...haven't decided as yet whom to vote for today though

 

[Cuti]

I don't really know. Let's ask a few questions though.

What would a G gain from such behavior?

- Finding out who's the jailer : Maybe, but still not that easy.
- The BG will protect ILFJ instead of himself and the Gs will make a lucky guess on whacking the BG : A pretty long shot.
- Get a reaction from the real D : Could be a cheap tactic, yeah. I've seen it work before.

What would a C gain from such behavior?

- Lulz?

The real D could have blazed his guns I guess...though if he doesn't think that he is a G he might not risk it and let ILFJ take the heat of the Gs, or if he had investigated him, he can't blaze guns...it's a tough one

- - - Updated - - -

What is your obsession with Mr. Chocolate?

there were 3 other names, and i targetted no one specifically, just said that those are the 4 who have posted/participated least

 

[Klin]

The real D could have blazed his guns I guess...though if he doesn't think that he is a G he might not risk it and let ILFJ take the heat of the Gs, or if he had investigated him, he can't blaze guns...it's a tough one

- - - Updated - - -



there were 3 other names, and i targetted no one specifically, just said that those are the 4 who have posted/participated least

He could've still blazed his guns on him though as the D didn't receive any investigation results at that point.

I've noticed you voting for Mr. Chocolate yesterday too, without any particular explanation whatsoever. Anything I've missed on him?

 

[Tomice]

Should the D to invstigate ILFJ ?

 

[Salvo]

You don't really think they would be that careless, do you Klin? Was Lemon this quiet last time?

- - - Updated - - -

Its too hard to read Lemon, too new.

 

[Cuti]

He could've still blazed his guns on him though as the D didn't receive any investigation results at that point.

I've noticed you voting for Mr. Chocolate yesterday too, without any particular explanation whatsoever. Anything I've missed on him?

Yesterday I voted for choccie because of how he had voted in the afternoon, and had no reason to vote for anyone else cause I didn't think that Sheik was a G, and undecided about Salvo. In the evening I believe he changed his vote to no lynch, but I could not pick anyone else to vote for, so I left it on him. Not saying he is def a g, but not saying he is innocent either.

 

[piotrr]

You don't really think they would be that careless, do you Klin? Was Lemon this quiet last time?

- - - Updated - - -

Its too hard to read Lemon, too new.

Maybe Lemon's the D again

 

[Salvo]

Imagine

 

[Tomice]

Oh the horror

 

[Salvo]

Fresh, Chocolate, Lemon and Gep have all been very quiet on the posting side, so personally i think at least 1 of them is a G...haven't decided as yet whom to vote for today though

Gep was quiet the last game also, he ended up having a special role. Didn't want to draw attention, could be the same tactic if he was a G?

 

[piotrr]

Anyway, the D investigated somebody and knows his role already,right?

 

[Cuti]

have any votes been cast so far?

- - - Updated - - -

Should the D to invstigate ILFJ ?

If I were the D, i'd probably investigate Alen, as he has the highest number of posts by far (if you don't include the lynched sheik), and he has already started with his theories of who is teaming up with who, but that's just me

 

[Tomice]

Anyway, the D investigated somebody and knows his role already,right?

In here you can never know , just hope

have any votes been cast so far?

None so far I think

- - - Updated - - -

If I were the D, i'd probably investigate Alen, as he has the highest number of posts by far (if you don't include the lynched sheik), and he has already started with his theories of who is teaming up with who, but that's just me

Agree