Mafia : Immortality (23 Viewers)
- Thread starter Zacheryah
- Start date
But it makes little sense for him to come out so openly if he's a G.
I did it once. I was investigated on day 1. We learned that, but we didn't know who was the D who investigated me. Suddenly, Fred started attacking me like mad, telling me how I'm a liar who's full of shit. It was clear that he's the D. When I accepted my faith, knowing that Fred will go public and tell them about my role, the jailer put Fred in jail. I knew what I had to do. I lied that I'm the D and I investigated Fred, who turned out to be a G. I even asked the BG to protect me. The BG Pmd me and told me he'll protect me. Naturally, we lynched Fred and we whacked the BG. The next day I was lynched, but the job was done. Killed the D and the BG in one day.
In such occasions it's normal to lie about being the D. But did we have a similar situation yesterday? Zach did make changes in the rules about the D investigating. But could the Gs learn who was investigated as early as the time when ILFJ came public saying that he's the D? I pretty much doubt it.
I did it once. I was investigated on day 1. We learned that, but we didn't know who was the D who investigated me. Suddenly, Fred started attacking me like mad, telling me how I'm a liar who's full of shit. It was clear that he's the D. When I accepted my faith, knowing that Fred will go public and tell them about my role, the jailer put Fred in jail. I knew what I had to do. I lied that I'm the D and I investigated Fred, who turned out to be a G. I even asked the BG to protect me. The BG Pmd me and told me he'll protect me. Naturally, we lynched Fred and we whacked the BG. The next day I was lynched, but the job was done. Killed the D and the BG in one day.
In such occasions it's normal to lie about being the D. But did we have a similar situation yesterday? Zach did make changes in the rules about the D investigating. But could the Gs learn who was investigated as early as the time when ILFJ came public saying that he's the D? I pretty much doubt it.
I'm not sure if this says anything, but I bothered to analyse the happenings in the last 40 minutes....
At 23:23 we had a situation where Sheik, Salvo and No Lynch had 3 votes, while Cuti and Fresh had 2 votes. It's very probable that at least 1 of these 4 was a G, which would mean that a G was in danger of being voted out. Everything could have happened from here on. If 1 of them was indeed a G, it's here, right after 23:23 that I'll try to search for a G (or Gs) trying to save their buddy and voting for someone else who had 3 or 2 votes. And naturally, the Gs would have went for a C here, not for No Lynch.
What happens afterwards:
- Piotrr comes up at 23:29 and votes Sheik, which puts Sheik in lead with 4 votes.
- Sheik changes from Fresh to No Lynch, which equals Sheik and No Lynch at 4 votes. Now we have 4:4 and the Gs would like Sheik to win, not No Lynch.
- Kyle changes from Sheik to Salvo, and now Salvo and No Lynch have 4 votes, while Sheik is back at 3. Typical C move from Kyle here, imo.
- Matt changes from Sheik to Salvo, so now Salvo has 5, No Lynch 4 and Sheik 2. Pretty fishy if you ask me. Almost as if Matt didn't want a No Lynch here.
- Sheik votes Salvo in order to save himself, and now Salvo is at 6, No Lynch at 3 and Sheik is safe at 2.
- ILFJ changes from Fresh to Sheik, and we now have the situation Piotrr talked about, where Salvo had 6, while Sheik and No Lynch are at 3.
Zach fucked up with his calculations at this point, but later he fixed the problem.
Now we enter the last 15 minutes.
- Soren votes no lynch. Something a G wouldn't do if both Salvo and Sheik are Cs, but would do if he's trying to save Salvo. Salvo is at 6 now, No Lynch at 4 and Sheik at 3.
- I (Alen) say that if Salvo is a G, the Gs will go for the No Lynch and try to save him. But it doesn't happen. Instead....
- Matt votes Sheik and now Salvo is at 5, No Lynch at 4, Sheik at 4.
- Tomice votes Sheik, so we have Salvo and Sheik at 5, No Lynch at 4
Nothing changed in the last 4 minutes.
So, in case both Salvo and Sheik were civilians (the Gs would want either dead. Everything except No Lynch), the suspects are those who made sure we won't have no lynch: Piotrr, Matt, ILFJ and maybe Tomice.
In case Salvo is a G, the suspects are those who tried to save him: Piotrr, ILFJ, Matt and Tomice. The same 4
Plus Soren
Also, have in mind that one or both of Cuti and Fresh could be Gs, and at one point they were in danger with 2 votes when the most endangered member had 3 votes. In that case Piotrr, Matt and ILFJ were the first ones who started voting for Salvo and Sheik, and insured that these two have much more votes than Cuti and Fresh.
At 23:23 we had a situation where Sheik, Salvo and No Lynch had 3 votes, while Cuti and Fresh had 2 votes. It's very probable that at least 1 of these 4 was a G, which would mean that a G was in danger of being voted out. Everything could have happened from here on. If 1 of them was indeed a G, it's here, right after 23:23 that I'll try to search for a G (or Gs) trying to save their buddy and voting for someone else who had 3 or 2 votes. And naturally, the Gs would have went for a C here, not for No Lynch.
What happens afterwards:
- Piotrr comes up at 23:29 and votes Sheik, which puts Sheik in lead with 4 votes.
- Sheik changes from Fresh to No Lynch, which equals Sheik and No Lynch at 4 votes. Now we have 4:4 and the Gs would like Sheik to win, not No Lynch.
- Kyle changes from Sheik to Salvo, and now Salvo and No Lynch have 4 votes, while Sheik is back at 3. Typical C move from Kyle here, imo.
- Matt changes from Sheik to Salvo, so now Salvo has 5, No Lynch 4 and Sheik 2. Pretty fishy if you ask me. Almost as if Matt didn't want a No Lynch here.
- Sheik votes Salvo in order to save himself, and now Salvo is at 6, No Lynch at 3 and Sheik is safe at 2.
- ILFJ changes from Fresh to Sheik, and we now have the situation Piotrr talked about, where Salvo had 6, while Sheik and No Lynch are at 3.
Zach fucked up with his calculations at this point, but later he fixed the problem.
Now we enter the last 15 minutes.
- Soren votes no lynch. Something a G wouldn't do if both Salvo and Sheik are Cs, but would do if he's trying to save Salvo. Salvo is at 6 now, No Lynch at 4 and Sheik at 3.
- I (Alen) say that if Salvo is a G, the Gs will go for the No Lynch and try to save him. But it doesn't happen. Instead....
- Matt votes Sheik and now Salvo is at 5, No Lynch at 4, Sheik at 4.
- Tomice votes Sheik, so we have Salvo and Sheik at 5, No Lynch at 4
Nothing changed in the last 4 minutes.
So, in case both Salvo and Sheik were civilians (the Gs would want either dead. Everything except No Lynch), the suspects are those who made sure we won't have no lynch: Piotrr, Matt, ILFJ and maybe Tomice.
In case Salvo is a G, the suspects are those who tried to save him: Piotrr, ILFJ, Matt and Tomice. The same 4
Plus Soren Also, have in mind that one or both of Cuti and Fresh could be Gs, and at one point they were in danger with 2 votes when the most endangered member had 3 votes. In that case Piotrr, Matt and ILFJ were the first ones who started voting for Salvo and Sheik, and insured that these two have much more votes than Cuti and Fresh.