Mafia 2020 - Find the carrier (6 Viewers)

[ALC]

@ALC

explain yourself. Why do i find you so suspicious?

Are you going on a power trip right now? You have a special role and think you can just throw around random accusations based on whatever hunch you have?

I voted Klin because he was acting weird and not being very available. Feel free to look through my posts. It’s a coincidence that he ended up being a C. If we believe whoever contacted you is the D.

anyways my next choice would be bezzy.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Osman]

Why is Bezzy ur next choice?

 

[Osman]

Suits yourself Osman. When you'll see im a C if im lynched, you'll have some explaining to do

Ok, so you are fine with being lynched. You heard him folks, he doesnt mind being lynched, chop chop. Thanks, thats a weight off my shoulder.

 

[Osman]

Kudos for knowing Alen and Klin were Cs all the time.
But since you were/are so convinced that i'm a G you lose all the credibility.

Not saying Cerval is not a G as his posts are fishy but as i said earlier, unsuccessful lynch might harm us quick. So for now No Lynch, until Kyle comes with some ideas.

So rather then consider the option of voting Cerval, you rather we vote no lynch?

 

[Cerval]

Kudos for knowing Alen and Klin were Cs all the time.
But since you were/are so convinced that i'm a G you lose all the credibility.

Not saying Cerval is not a G as his posts are fishy but as i said earlier, unsuccessful lynch might harm us quick. So for now No Lynch, until Kyle comes with some ideas.

We won't win the game by voting no lynch each day either

Ok, so you are fine with being lynched. You heard him folks, he doesnt mind being lynched, chop chop. Thanks, thats a weight off my shoulder.

I dont mind being lynched if that can help us to win the game the next day. But id rather stay alive if given the choice since we'll be down by 2 tomorrow if this stands

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

Kyle being the only certain C, he has to decide who he has a hunch on and everyone has to follow.

That's the only way we have a chance of getting a G. He could ending be wrong and we lynch a C, but we all have nothing to go on and its al still a guess. If we leave it open for everyone to go after whoever they feel like it would be easy for the Gs to spread their votes and ensure that no G is touched.

Unless we all agree to vote for the same person, whoever Kyle picks, we will have zero chance of getting a G tonight. They simply will not allow it

Does that make sense to you all?

@Kyle say your pick and I will follow, unless it's me of course

 

[ALC]

Why is Bezzy ur next choice?

did you not see my previous posts?

she claimed to have a work phone call at 10 pm so she couldn't make it in time for the voting. then she was here and in the thread, just didn't vote. i think another G is telling her to lay low and voting for klin would've made her look too suspicious.

 

[Osman]

No it doesnt make sense @Quetzalcoatl, only thing that makes sense is not spreading votes too much, but everything else is bit too simplistic. Everyone should share their thoughts and their suspicions, and go for it if strong enough conviction, its better if its narrow few then too spread, but a single voice in the BG deciding the votes alone without no investigation is not the sole solution to things. He has the same information as us and the same odds to fish out a G without D's direct results. Going for his only choice might backfire just as much. Wittle down a list of suspects and why instead, and this should be done by EVERYONE. You narrow that down by actively sharing your thoughts and why, otherwise its easy to hide for Gs.

- - - Updated - - -

did you not see my previous posts?

she claimed to have a work phone call at 10 pm so she couldn't make it in time for the voting. then she was here and in the thread, just didn't vote. i think another G is telling her to lay low and voting for klin would've made her look too suspicious.

Thats solid enough start off reason. So @Bezzy, what do you say?


Also, ALC, any thoughts on other members?

 

[Cerval]

@Mr Chocolate

For someone that was supposed to be active, you didn't deliver yet. From my perspectives the likelihood of at least one G being barely active is high.

If you continue this way you'll get autolynched and we'll find out

 

[Mr Chocolate]

I don't think we should no-lynch again, there should defs be a lynch decision by tonight.
I think Bezzy would be my choice, she was in the thread towards the end yesterday and said nothing, when it was crucial to the strat that everyone said they wernt the BG
but plenty of time left and plenty of posting for ppl to convince otherwise

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

No it doesnt make sense, only thing that makes sense is not spreading votes too much, but everything else is bit too simplistic. Everyone should share their thoughts and their suspicions, and go for it if strong enough conviction, its better if its narrow few then too spread, but a single voice in the BG deciding the votes alone without no investigation is not the sole solution to things. He has the same information as us and the same odds to fish out a G without D's direct results. Going for his only choice might backfire just as much. Wittle down a list of suspects and why instead, and this should be done by EVERYONE. You narrow that down by actively sharing your thoughts and why, otherwise its easy to hide for Gs.

Of course you would be against it.

Yeah make a list of suspects based off of gut feelings... that'll get us a list of 9 out of the 11 people here.

We cant even use yesterday's voting as a guide, it tells us nothing. At least we know Kyle's motive with his choice, even if he may be wrong. We know at least he's not trying to protect anyone.

You got Cerval, he's "suspicious"? I got you, ALC, Voller... Someone reading this is gonna have me as a suspect, somehow. How are we gonna go anywhere like that?

If you're a G you love it when there are 3, 4, 5 options for lynching... it's too easy to make sure no G is lynched.

there are 8 Cs now. If the lawyer and jailer contact Kyle, he will know 5 out of the 8. Meaning he has to guess between 3 Cs and 3 Gs... a 50% chance. The rest of us know 3 out of 8 - 5 Cs vs 3 Gs... a 38% chance of finding a G.

I repeat, the Gs are happy if we all are going after different people. Its easy for them to hide like that.

If Kyle wrongly picks a C, then we lose a C like we would anyway. If he rightly picks a G, there is no escaping for them

 

[Mr Chocolate]

personally i don't think its Piotrr purely for the fact that he suggested the "say your not the BG" tactic, which would not be in a G's best interest

 

[Cerval]

personally i don't think its Piotrr purely for the fact that he suggested the "say your not the BG" tactic, which would not be in a G's best interest

I'm not saying piotrr is def a G, we'll see how the day goes, but he could as well have suggested that to give himself some creds. That's the thing we need to get the lynch spot on and make the best decision. Today is do or die

 

[ALC]

Kyle being the only certain C, he has to decide who he has a hunch on and everyone has to follow.

That's the only way we have a chance of getting a G. He could ending be wrong and we lynch a C, but we all have nothing to go on and its al still a guess. If we leave it open for everyone to go after whoever they feel like it would be easy for the Gs to spread their votes and ensure that no G is touched.

Unless we all agree to vote for the same person, whoever Kyle picks, we will have zero chance of getting a G tonight. They simply will not allow it

Does that make sense to you all?

@Kyle say your pick and I will follow, unless it's me of course

The only problem with Kyle picking based on his gut is that he is now big headed because he has a special role and everyone knows it.

I'd be fine with him picking based on the Ds findings. NAd you do have a point that he knows more Cs than we do, so I'm fine iwthh im giving feedback but straight letting him pick randomly seems unsafe.

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

The only problem with Kyle picking based on his gut is that he is now big headed because he has a special role and everyone knows it.

I'd be fine with him picking based on the Ds findings. NAd you do have a point that he knows more Cs than we do, so I'm fine iwthh im giving feedback but straight letting him pick randomly seems unsafe.

Another thing is protecting the D. What if the D ends up being a lynching target? Does Kyle then come out and say "guys, you can't lynch him..."

Why? Well he's obviously the D then?

 

[ALC]

Another thing is protecting the D. What if the D ends up being a lynching target? Does Kyle then come out and say "guys, you can't lynch him..."

Why? Well he's obviously the D then?

the jailer and lawyer should definitely be in touch with kyle and working behind the scenes to protect each other

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

the jailer and lawyer should definitely be in touch with kyle and working behind the scenes to protect each other

Protect who?

 

[piotrr]

So rather then consider the option of voting Cerval, you rather we vote no lynch?

If i was a G i'd be happy to lay low and let you lynch Cerval, especially that yesterday you saw me as a main suspect and now you turned to Cerval. But instead of going with the flow with Cerval i'd rather vote no lynch since no one can be 100% sure Cerval is a G and we can't afford to be losing 2 Cs per day.

 

[Mr Chocolate]

so Kyle should let everyone know when the Lawyer and Jailer contact him in case a G pretends to be one?

 

[piotrr]

there are 8 Cs now. If the lawyer and jailer contact Kyle, he will know 5 out of the 8. Meaning he has to guess between 3 Cs and 3 Gs... a 50% chance. The rest of us know 3 out of 8 - 5 Cs vs 3 Gs... a 38% chance of finding a G.

I repeat, the Gs are happy if we all are going after different people. Its easy for them to hide like that.

If Kyle wrongly picks a C, then we lose a C like we would anyway. If he rightly picks a G, there is no escaping for them

that's basically what i said earlier in the morning


Even if Kyle chooses the person to vote for and it turns to be a C - he still should have (given the J and L contacted him) greater % chance to find a G than any of us.