Mafia 2020 - Find the carrier (22 Viewers)

[Osman]

We have been playing with the exact same format ever since I joined this forum almost 10 years ago.

Anyway, given that there is a recruiter, do you still think a no-lynch strategy is the right way to go?

Yeah I usually dont like it but no lynch strat makes sense for the first day.


And I was the one who introduced mafia to this forum, but havent played here in a while (dont necessarily have to have same set up every game). Played a XT mafia game last week, and there was no recruiter, so kinda forgot this one had that.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Osman]

It’s me.

Welcome Sidd, have you played mafia before?

 

[campionesidd]

Yeah I usually dont like it but no lynch strat makes sense for the first day.


And I was the one who introduced mafia to this forum, but havent played here in a while (dont necessarily have to have same set up every game). Played a XT mafia game last week, and there was no recruiter, so kinda forgot this one had that.

makes sense for the g’s sure.
You usually don’t like it because usually you are a C. Something different this time?

- - - Updated - - -

Welcome Sidd, have you played mafia before?

Third time.

 

[Alen]

Bunch of useless nonsense in this thread so far.
The only good thing I read is that Janna's cat died.

 

[ALC]

makes sense for the g’s sure.
You usually don’t like it because usually you are a C. Something different this time?

- - - Updated - - -


.

Good point, Osman and Voller possibly conspiring together

 

[Osman]

makes sense for the g’s sure.
You usually don’t like it because usually you are a C. Something different this time?

- - - Updated - - -



Third time.

No I dont usually like it because it makes for an inactive day without little to go on for 2nd day. But its safer then the alternative of blind lynching on nothing first day. Especially in small game where every C matters more.



But hey, if you have thoughts on it, please share, what should be done?

 

[campionesidd]

Good point, Osman and Voller possibly conspiring together

They don’t seem to agree with each other, but maybe they are conspiring behind the scenes.

 

[Alen]

We are 12 people playing.
Right now we're 9 Cs and 3 Gs. Every civilian has a 27% chance to vote for a G and 73% chance to vote for a C.
If the Cs don't lynch a G tonight and when the Gs whack one of the Cs, there will be 7 Cs and 3 Gs. After recruiting it becomes 6vs4 and tomorrow night it could be game over.

I also think that no lynch makes sense for today. Once the Gs whack a C it's gonna be 8 vs 3 (7 vs 4 after recruiting) and it gives the Cs (and the D) at least one more day to find the Gs.

No lynch

 

[ALC]

No I dont usually like it because it makes for an inactive day without little to go on for 2nd day. But its safer then the alternative of blind lynching on nothing first day. Especially in small game where every C matters more.



But hey, if you have thoughts on it, please share, what should be done?

if you’re a G, who do you recruit?

- - - Updated - - -

They don’t seem to agree with each other, but maybe they are conspiring behind the scenes.

typical G behavior

 

[campionesidd]

No I dont usually like it because it makes for an inactive day without little to go on for 2nd day. But its safer then the alternative of blind lynching on nothing first day. Especially in small game where every C matters more.



But hey, if you have thoughts on it, please share, what should be done?

Im really torn.
On one hand I think we should vote for someone who is inactive, because they are useless, but the auto lynch will take care of that. On the other hand, many G’s often to over compensate by posting too much.

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

Yeah I usually dont like it but no lynch strat makes sense for the first day.


And I was the one who introduced mafia to this forum, but havent played here in a while (dont necessarily have to have same set up every game). Played a XT mafia game last week, and there was no recruiter, so kinda forgot this one had that.

How else are we going to find Gs if not by lynching? As we determined the D can't trust anyone to be an intermediary. Even so it will take a minimum of two days (if he's lucky) before he can confirm one G and one C.

 

[Völler]

We are 12 people playing.
Right now we're 9 Cs and 3 Gs. Every civilian has a 27% chance to vote for a G and 73% chance to vote for a C.
If the Cs don't lynch a G tonight and when the Gs whack one of the Cs, there will be 7 Cs and 3 Gs. After recruiting it becomes 6vs4 and tomorrow night it could be game over.

I also think that no lynch makes sense for today. Once the Gs whack a C it's gonna be 8 vs 3 (7 vs 4 after recruiting) and it gives the Cs (and the D) at least one more day to find the Gs.

No lynch

But what are you hoping to gain from that additional day? It will give the G's a free whack, and we won't get any information regarding the voting pattern. Or are you just banking on the detective investigating a G?

 

[Alen]

How else are we going to find Gs if not by lynching? As we determined the D can't trust anyone to be an intermediary. Even so it will take a minimum of two days (if he's lucky) before he can confirm one G and one C.

It's only 12 of us playing and that's the problem. If we lynch a C tonight and the D doesn't make a good investigation tonight, tomorrow it will likely be game over.

 

[Völler]

if you’re a G, who do you recruit?

- - - Updated - - -



typical G behavior

Wtf are you on? Are you just calling everyone out in the thread?

 

[ALC]

Wtf are you on? Are you just calling everyone out in the thread?

im trying to gauge reactions and yours is sketchy

- - - Updated - - -

On a more serious note, I find it helpful to see who’s been posting

- - - Updated - - -

 

[Alen]

Can we make it a rule for this game that the Gs can't recruit in the first two days?

There are only 12 people playing and if they recruit someone today or tomorrow, the game could be over in 2 days.

 

[ALC]

 

[Alen]

Wait, so auto-lynch if you don't post 15 times a day?

Half of us will be dead by tonight

 

[Klin]

Klinny
Are we gonna catch some g's together.
My concussion has been horrible lately.

- - - Updated - - -


Hahaha what a lame excuses
Piotrr

I feel you. It's painful at times.

 

[campionesidd]

Yeah, I feel like 15 posts a day is too high for a minimum.