Of course your vote will kill the discussion. That's given. Everyone, both Cs and Gs, will follow your lead, and that'll be that.
The issue is that if we follow the pattern of just blindly following you (when you don't have any intel), we won't really get smarter about anyone's behavior. I sure as hell hope your plan works out (even if it will make me look bad), but I'm still not a huge fan of this idea.