Mafia 2020 - Find the carrier (15 Viewers)

[Völler]

why wouldnt we discuss it? surely there are reasons to/not to investigate someone, e.g; what Piotr said
idm leaving the D to his/her own devices

- - - Updated - - -

hindsight 20/20, we would have to come to a unanimous decision as to not rule anyone out who wanted to investigate someone else

By discussing it the G's will get a better idea of who the D might be. Plus the G's might give an unexperienced D bad ideas.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[piotrr]

Of course Mr Chocolate once was a Detective himself and got whacked on the first day if I remember correctly.

cmonn bruh i dont think i was whacked
pretty sure i didnt vote/didnt post enoiugh and got kicked

 

[Alen]

So if Kyle is the BG, how likely do you guys think that Janna is a G with another experienced vet there who’s telling her to lay low?

That's a possibility which we will have to ignore.
We will accept Kyle as a BG now.

We have 2 more hours until deadline. The D should think about who to investigate and then tell Kyle sometime before deadline. The D shouldn't wait to contact Kyle after he makes the investigation, because the Gs will find out who was investigated and if the D hits a G, the investigated G will act as a D.

 

[campionesidd]

I think the jailer fucked up by jailing Osman. Things would be a lot clearer if everyone was available.

 

[X Æ A-12]

@Tomice
so what is the minimum daily post count? is it still 15?

 

[Völler]

It's good to discuss cause the D himself probably won't ask those questions.

As i proposed Osman is a good candidate cause he won't be whacked.
I probably wouldn't investigate Voller, Alen or Klin cause if they are Cs there is a high chance they get whacked / recruited.

The more I think about this: Why do you think this was a good question to answer?

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

Imo the detective should not be taking suggestions from the group since there will be misdirections. The detective should stick to his gut.

I'm getting G vibes from you, trying to throw confusion into everything.

Of course the D should listen to suggestions and decide based on what makes sense. If he can't do that, then he surely shouldn't be able to trust his gut

 

[Tomice]

@Tomice
so what is the minimum daily post count? is it still 15?

10 posts, starting tomorrow

All changes to the rules are underlined in the OP

 

[Alen]

I think the jailer fucked up by jailing Osman. Things would be a lot clearer if everyone was available.

It's me and Kyle who kinda fucked up.
I completely forgot about the game and I showed up too late with the plan. Then Kyle showed up after the jailer's deadline and there was no time to execute the BG-Jailer cooperation plan.
Since the BG wasn't here, the jailer could not wait any longer and had to decide between jailing someone or not jailing anyone at all.

 

[ALC]

That's a possibility which we will have to ignore.
We will accept Kyle as a BG now.

We have 2 more hours until deadline. The D should think about who to investigate and then tell Kyle sometime before deadline. The D shouldn't wait to contact Kyle after he makes the investigation, because the Gs will find out who was investigated and if the D hits a G, the investigated G will act as a D.

so why are we ignoring that?

are you the experienced player who’s calling Janna a dumb bitch over PMs and telling her to not post and pretend she has meetings?

and didn’t you just make Kyle reveal his identity?

also, what would prevent a G from pm-ing Kyle pretending to be the D already? He’s gonna be mindfucked.

 

[piotrr]

The more I think about this: Why do you think this was a good question to answer?

I don't think everyone in this game is 'experienced' so saying some basics or things for thought won't hurt.
In the end it's of course the D's role to pick an investigation to stay undercover and have the most out of it. Here maybe he will have some help from the BG.

 

[X Æ A-12]

whoever is the D should sack up and tell me they are the D and who they are investigating tonight

 

[Völler]

I'm getting G vibes from you, trying to throw confusion into everything.

Of course the D should listen to suggestions and decide based on what makes sense. If he can't do that, then he surely shouldn't be able to trust his gut

Throwing confusion into what? I think I'm being pretty straightforward in my line of reasoning.

You don't think that everyone having a roundtable discussion on who to investigate will potentially help the G's figure out who the D is?

 

[Alen]

whoever is the D should sack up and tell me they are the D and who they are investigating tonight

Not yet.

No need to rush.

 

[X Æ A-12]

Not yet.

No need to rush.

why not? Does anyone actually not believe me?

and the BG role cannot be recruited so for what possible reason should the D not trust me?

 

[Alen]

why not? Does anyone actually not believe me?

and the BG role cannot be recruited so for what possible reason should the D not trust me?

Why should he tell you right now who is he going to investigate? Maybe he doesn't know.
Just give him time to think and then before deadline and before he sends Tomice the PM about the investigation, he contacts you and tells you what's his plan.

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

Throwing confusion into what? I think I'm being pretty straightforward in my line of reasoning.

You don't think that everyone having a roundtable discussion on who to investigate will potentially help the G's figure out who the D is?

Well I've only seen you opposing everything, but not suggesting anything.

On who to investigate specifically? Yeah, the D should decide that on his own

 

[Alen]

On who to investigate specifically? Yeah, the D should decide that on his own

We should keep looking for the Gs, though. That might help the D.

Lets talk about who do we find suspicious and why.
And maybe not tonight, but our posts today might be revealing tomorrow.

We shouldn't just wait for the deadline. Myself, I'll go over the thread once more.

 

[Völler]

Well I've only seen you opposing everything, but not suggesting anything.

On who to investigate specifically? Yeah, the D should decide that on his own

So you're getting G vibes from me for bringing up a point you essentially agree with?

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

We should keep looking for the Gs, though. That might help the D.

Lets talk about who do we find suspicious and why.
And maybe not tonight, but our posts today might be revealing tomorrow.

We shouldn't just wait for the deadline. Myself, I'll go over the thread once more.

If I were the D, I'd investigate Voller For reasons stated above - he doesn't seem to be interested in transparency but more like he wants to create doubt in the minds of the D and the less experienced players.

Klin too, but he's less subtle so maybe he's being genuine with his doubts.

- - - Updated - - -

So you're getting G vibes from me for bringing up a point you essentially agree with?

No, everything else