Mafia 2018! (20 Viewers)

piotrr

Мodеrator
Sep 13, 2011
34,009
He can certainly be a C, we also have no idea who the G's are. It's quite possible there is only one or two veteran players and even they can be inactive

Also people were going on about visibility with Jethro, wittl and ADP. They might have thought it was risky to switch it on at that point
Roles were sent after midnight and he was still posting after 1am. Plenty of time for Gs to organize the basic things.
Jethro clearly is mindfucked and doesn't know what he's doing here while ADP asked(?) about the inv before the game. Wittl turned it on just because and didn't say a thing about it. Here's where my vote comes from.
 

campionesidd

Senior Member
Mar 16, 2013
16,874
I can see two options:
1) Blondu is a G
2) Monty, Tomice and Radekas are G's. I think this one is more likely.I say this because Monty and Tomice have basically said the same thing over and over and Monty was quick to defend Radekas for no reason.
I go for Tomice.
 

X Æ A-12

Senior Member
Contributor
Sep 4, 2006
87,992
I’m pretty sure Kyle is a G. He’s the one really going for saving blondu, that way if blondu ends up being a C, he can use that as an excuse to clear himself. Why else would he be so hell bent on voting for someone else? A G would never protect one of their own this early. Just some food for thought.
What the fuck are you talking about? Have you been reading the thread?
 

Wittl

Senior Member
Contributor
Feb 21, 2017
11,311
So I went through all these pages and firstly I was about to vote for Campionesidd, ALC or Radekas because due some of the experienced posters (keeping themselves quiet with very few posts) their posting is quite suspiocious. For Basel93 I think he's just offline and for Jethro it’s just a feeling because his pm to me tells me he really has no idea.

Then I ask myself who could have jailed Voeller, cause this one wouldn't be a G. Might have it been fr3sh who was in a discussion with him, so he'd be innocent? Dunno!

About the others: I read all this Tomice, Monty, blondu etc discussion and I still ain't sure about it. So I ask myself how the fuck did I got 3 votes. It was pitbull first (don't really got why), then piotrr came out of the blue by accusing me for posting just a little and that my posts about drinking in Japan were fake and then Kyle followed the track (maybe to point the attention to someone else?).

But for now I think I'll go with piotrr.
 

radekas

( ͠° ͟ل͜ ͡°)
Aug 26, 2009
20,189
I can see two options:
1) Blondu is a G
2) Monty, Tomice and Radekas are G's. I think this one is more likely.I say this because Monty and Tomice have basically said the same thing over and over and Monty was quick to defend Radekas for no reason.
I go for Tomice.
You were quick to jump on me though and Monty gave an interesting opinion that a G would do that. I thought about voting for you but wasn't sure if anything more interesting would happen. You mentioning me again just like that settles this for me tonight.

Since I have no other leads.

campionesidd
 

campionesidd

Senior Member
Mar 16, 2013
16,874
You were quick to jump on me though and Monty gave an interesting opinion that a G would do that. I thought about voting for you but wasn't sure if anything more interesting would happen. You mentioning me again just like that settles this for me tonight.

Since I have no other leads.

campionesidd
Your comment seemed kinda suspicious, but not enough for me to vote for you. What is really suspicious though, is how quickly Monty jumped in to save you and deflect blame.
 

X Æ A-12

Senior Member
Contributor
Sep 4, 2006
87,992
why so many votes for Tomice?

Antisemitism or legit reasons?
Cause he is one of the better mafia players. Very likely that there is a G effort to end up with him lynched first day or at least end up a tie vote between him and someone else.

As I mentioned before Tomice took a very big risk today in talking about Blondu, claiming he had seen Blondu PMing posting screenshots etc. That is not how a G behaves on the first day. There is no need for them to take such a big risk early on as it almost always a C lynched the first day anyway.

i find it EXTREMELY unlikely that Tomice is actually a G and if he does get lynched today, ends up being C, then tomorrow we reread the thread and the suspects are those pushing for him.
 

radekas

( ͠° ͟ل͜ ͡°)
Aug 26, 2009
20,189
Your comment seemed kinda suspicious, but not enough for me to vote for you. What is really suspicious though, is how quickly Monty jumped in to save you and deflect blame.
He wasn't really defending me. He was mostly saying that I might have set up a trap for some inexperienced G to jump on my random comment about being a C. And it was a really good point.

Every time I play this game and I'm a C I will go with my first hunch on day 1 and I very often do hit a G (most people don't follow me though so it only turns out much later). I will just stick with you for the rest of the day unless something huge happens.
 

Tomice

Senior Member
Mar 25, 2009
3,024
I can see two options:
1) Blondu is a G
2) Monty, Tomice and Radekas are G's. I think this one is more likely.I say this because Monty and Tomice have basically said the same thing over and over and Monty was quick to defend Radekas for no reason.
I go for Tomice.
Yeah, that's why I was the first to point the finger at Monty for his invisibility thing and also voted for him. Few page ago I said again that after Blondu Monty is my main suspect.

I even screened his profile page for god sake :lol: Why would I do that if we were both G's?

I still can't see how I can defend myself since no one here even bothered to come up with any argument against me but people are acting like sheeps
 

radekas

( ͠° ͟ل͜ ͡°)
Aug 26, 2009
20,189
Cause he is one of the better mafia players. Very likely that there is a G effort to end up with him lynched first day or at least end up a tie vote between him and someone else.

As I mentioned before Tomice took a very big risk today in talking about Blondu, claiming he had seen Blondu PMing posting screenshots etc. That is not how a G behaves on the first day. There is no need for them to take such a big risk early on as it almost always a C lynched the first day anyway.

i find it EXTREMELY unlikely that Tomice is actually a G and if he does get lynched today, ends up being C, then tomorrow we reread the thread and the suspects are those pushing for him.
I dunno about Tomice being one of the better players after the fiasco he had with me being the D some years ago :D.

But I can dig the reasoning.
 

blondu

Grazie Ale
Nov 9, 2006
27,408
G's switching useless names just to get some posts and create chaos.

campionesidd its not a or b. imo tomice is innocent, even with those screenshots took i said i used a lot of tapatalk today and probably thats why he got me in the imbox several times. as i said, a G doesn't spend his entire day posting (me and tomice) esp in the first day. I don't think Kyle is a G.
 

campionesidd

Senior Member
Mar 16, 2013
16,874
Yeah, that's why I was the first to point the finger at Monty for his invisibility thing and also voted for him. Few page ago I said again that after Blondu Monty is my main suspect.

I even screened his profile page for god sake :lol: Why would I do that if we were both G's?

I still can't see how I can defend myself since no one here even bothered to come up with any argument against me but people are acting like sheeps
You are an experienced player who won't shy away from blaming other G's, especially someone who isn't in danger of getting lynched. Monty, with due respect is a noob, who seems to be defending certain players and blaming those who go after them.
 

Wittl

Senior Member
Contributor
Feb 21, 2017
11,311
G's switching useless names just to get some posts and create chaos.

campionesidd its not a or b. imo tomice is innocent, even with those screenshots took i said i used a lot of tapatalk today and probably thats why he got me in the imbox several times. as i said, a G doesn't spend his entire day posting (me and tomice) esp in the first day. I don't think Kyle is a G.
piotrr
 

X Æ A-12

Senior Member
Contributor
Sep 4, 2006
87,992
I dunno about Tomice being one of the better players after the fiasco he had with me being the D some years ago :D.

But I can dig the reasoning.
I would say a G plays more like Maddy has so far today. A usually aggressive person who has been lowkey just showed up, made some sarcastic posts, claimed that if Blondu ends up being a G then both myself and Tomice are too for some odd reason, doesn't really say much of substance but does manage to cast his vote for Tomice. A C Maddy imo would be more explosive and trying to stir things up but he really hasn't done that at all.

I invite you to look through his post history today
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 20)