I hammered on about this at the start of the season and with the way things have played out I kind of see its uses, but honestly I still don't think the Next Gen team helps us as much as we think.
I get that it's good for younger players to get competitive game minutes against adult opposition, and probably just like in Serie A all the teams in Serie C play out of their skins because it's not only Juve but they probably see the players as pampered princes who at ten years younger earn more than they ever have. I also get that it's good for potential first-team players to stay at Juventus rather than go on loans, so that if/when they become 1st team starters that they will count as homegrown. Furthermore one of the most successful squads in recent decades was made up to a significant degree by academy graduates: Barcelona in the 2010s. Any way we can work towards nurturing our own talents is something to support for sure.
However, I just feel that if a player is already too old for the primavera and isn't yet good enough for the first team then we either loan him to see how he does in Serie A. Even if he still comes up short we sell hopefully for a profit or just release. To hold onto players until they are as old as 23 in case they become good enough, and slowing massaging them into the squad across several seasons is a demonstration of the attitude which I think we all know stinks. The one about upholding 'experience' to a point of fault and not wanting to risk playing young players in case they fuck up (and then keeping Bonucci and the rest of the bombscares at the team)
The worst part is that some of these 19/20/21 year olds that we have right now look good enough to be rotated into the squad. Why did we spend cash money on Paredes when we had somebody all along who plays like the best version of Paredes, even looks like him and in his little game time looks like he's keen to prove himself, and looks unfazed by the prospect of playing first team for Juventus? Why will we (we absolutely will btw) hang onto Kean for the next 2/3 years while we have this Yildiz kid, who won't cost us nearly 30m just in transfer fees? Soule and Iling Junior do not look good enough to play for us, and actually keeping them playing for the Next Gen I think is not the right approach, we should be giving them much more first team game time to see where they are at. If the reason is that, at 19 they don't look close, they probably aren't gonna make it.
I dunno, I'm probably just a troglodyte who doesn't get it. I just think it's ludicrous to maintain a 'youth' team which includes players at age 23. That's not a youth team, that's players we want to believe may be good enough for us but probably won't be. If they were, they'd be forcing their way in.
Is it a coaching problem with not implementing it correctly? Is the idea good but Allegri doesn't get it? Ideally would the coach be doing the rotational introduction I'm talking about? Is it that we have such a large volume of talent coming through we need the Next Gen as overflow until we figure out who is going to make the cut and who not, and we figure 23 is enough time to decide? If somebody can be bothered explaining it to me all over again I'd be much obliged.