I was only once the detective and the gun blazing option was introduced in the next game. You confused it with something else. I never blazed the gun as a detective.
But I'm behind you in all this. Even Tahir thinks the same way. When he order the gun blazing Jasper should have done it immediately, not the day later. Then, of course, he'd have proven that he's really the D and people could have voted for someone else in the last minutes in order to save him.
Unless they voted no lynch in the last minutes, then another player should have been lynched now.
If I was the narrator Tahir was gonna be a victim of lynching, even though it wasn't gonna look fair.