Iraq. Is it better now?? (AKA ISIS/ISIL/IS/name-of-the-week-here) (18 Viewers)

Is Iraq better now?

  • Yes

  • No


Results are only viewable after voting.

Ocelot

Midnight Marauder
Jul 13, 2013
18,943
Just for info both Sajida and Zeyad were already convicted of previous crimes according to the Jordanian law. They were trialed since 2006 and 2007, but as execution stopped being implemented in Jordan since around 8 years. It was resumed just before two months when 21 people were executed for their crimes that took place at 2003 and 2004. SO, simply Sajida and Zeyad were already decided to be executed since years, but they were waiting for their time.
I assumed so, and I do not want to make it sound as if those executions were in any way as abominable as the actions of IS (though I do in general not think much of arguing about the extent of the horribleness of a crime, this logic can lead to a lot of fucked up conclusions rather easily). However, the fact remains that the timing of the executions very strongly implies that they are thought of as actions of vengeance against the IS, whether that was the only intention behind the action or it was done to satisfy public outrage does not really matter here. The executions were at least in their timing the result of political reasoning, not jurisdictional, and that is in my opinion to be rejected.

Moreover, I think one could question if such executions really send the right signals anyways. Not even talking about their ascension to martyrdom, or acts of vengeance by the IS, I do believe that when combatting terrorist movements, it is important to maintain some sort of a "moral high ground", as naive as that may sound. Otherwise, recruition by those terrorist movements is facilitated massively.
 
OP

ReBeL

The Jackal
Jan 14, 2005
22,871
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #2,484
    A Turkish newspaper said today that Turkish authorities arrested for the first time a Turkish member in IS

    - - - Updated - - -

    EU chides Jordan for hangings after pilot killed

    (Reuters) - The European Union combined a statement of solidarity with Jordan over the killing of one of its military pilots by Islamist fighters with criticism of its immediate execution of two Iraqi jihadists.

    "While all efforts must be made to counter terrorism and hold the perpetrators accountable, our reaction to the threat posed by (Islamic State) needs to be consistent with our common values on justice and the rights of prisoners," foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini said in a statement on Wednesday.

    "Our action has to be guided by the respect of international human rights law and humanitarian law. The European position against death penalty remains unchanged and we believe capital punishment does not serve any deterrent purpose."

    Condemning the killing of captured F-16 pilot Mouath al-Kasaesbeh, she praised Jordan's role in the "front line in the battle" against Islamic State and taking in refugees from Syria and Iraq. On Wednesday, Jordan hanged Sajida al-Rishawi, an Iraqi woman who took part in suicide bomb attacks 10 years ago, and a senior al Qaeda prisoner, Ziyad Karboli, also an Iraqi.

    http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/02/04/us-mideast-crisis-jordan-eu-idUSKBN0L81JR20150204

    - - - Updated - - -

    A work by a Moroccan artist today...
     

    Attachments

    king Ale

    Senior Member
    Oct 28, 2004
    21,689
    her execution looked too much like an eye for an eye reprisal and seemed to go astray of due process. Daesh needs to be dealt with with troops on the ground and a true commitment to eradicate them, if anything killing that prisoner only made jordan look weak imo
    Who denies that? (although I have zero hope of it happening given how almost every party which is able to do something does either want Daesh to exist (and help them) or has no motivation of eradicating them. Not exactly on topic but not that far off either: Read this: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/04/u...s-saudi-princes-patrons-of-al-qaeda.html?_r=1). But at this point of time, questioning these executions either as an inherently wrong action or as a useless revenge is absurd. I'm like good fucking riddance. Hope the same thing happens to the rest of them who have turned my home to a shithole a place to live and hope even worse things happen to those oil thirsty blood thirsty criminals who created, funded and condoned these animals.

    Yup.

    Jordan trying to imitate ISIS isn't exactly an improvement.

    The best way to deal with a drunk person who is threatening people with a gun at your party isn't also to get drunk and get out your gun.
    How is that "imitating" Daesh?

    Yup. The best way is therapy :agree:

    An eye for an eye is very rarely the way to go, and that applies for this case as well imo. While I would in general argue against any from of the death penalty (and nothing else happened there essentially), here we have the added problem that the executed weren't primarily executed beacuse of their wrongdoings (at least the timing very strongly suggests that) , but because of political calculation.
    It was not an eye for an eye. How does it matter what the purpose of these executions was? Those guys were convicted of killing of several people. They were kept alive for political reasons which were not relevant anymore.
     

    Lion

    King of Tuz
    Jan 24, 2007
    36,185
    the solution to stopping monsters like isis is excecution of their family members live tv.

    so u want to join isis? cool we are going to burn ur family on live tv as punishment.


    yeah eye to eye doesnt always work, but sometimes to u need to use absolute brutality to make ur enemy submit. see hiroshima
     

    Maddy

    Oracle of Copenhagen
    Jul 10, 2009
    16,545
    the solution to stopping monsters like isis is excecution of their family members live tv.

    so u want to join isis? cool we are going to burn ur family on live tv as punishment.


    yeah eye to eye doesnt always work, but sometimes to u need to use absolute brutality to make ur enemy submit. see hiroshima
    :tup:
     

    Lion

    King of Tuz
    Jan 24, 2007
    36,185
    i see isis similar to japan in ww2.

    people dedicated to obey the emperor. men women, and children were willing to lay down their lives for him.

    it took a barbaric act, one that show cased the difference in power to end the war.

    edit: this is the big problem. this isis shit heads believe they are going to heaven because they have been brainwashed. so they dont care what happens to them. want to really hurt them? target their family
     
    OP

    ReBeL

    The Jackal
    Jan 14, 2005
    22,871
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #2,491
    Just for info, IS said that the building where the pilot was burnt near is where their families were killed by one of the coalition attacks, so thinking their families murder will make them stop is just a dream IMO.
     

    king Ale

    Senior Member
    Oct 28, 2004
    21,689
    i see isis similar to japan in ww2.

    people dedicated to obey the emperor. men women, and children were willing to lay down their lives for him.

    it took a barbaric act, one that show cased the difference in power to end the war.

    edit: this is the big problem. this isis shit heads believe they are going to heaven because they have been brainwashed. so they dont care what happens to them. want to really hurt them? target their family
    Are you being sarcastic or stupid? :kiss:
     

    Azzurri7

    Pinturicchio
    Moderator
    Dec 16, 2003
    72,692
    I disagree. Sajida for example had been kept alive for all these years for a purpose, which is non-existent today. She already lived much more than what she deserved.
    Executing Sajida is good, that's not the point, point is it didn't hit Daesh much.

    her execution looked too much like an eye for an eye reprisal and seemed to go astray of due process. Daesh needs to be dealt with with troops on the ground and a true commitment to eradicate them, if anything killing that prisoner only made jordan look weak imo
    :agree: no other solution. Obama is still sleeping though :touched:
     

    Raz

    Senior Member
    Nov 20, 2005
    12,218
    Western propaganda?

    If I had to guess, Rebel will post some article how some other side 10 years ago did similar stuff to the other side of muslims, so this is just what is deserved...
     
    OP

    ReBeL

    The Jackal
    Jan 14, 2005
    22,871
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #2,498
    I never said I'm supporting them. What I said all over this thread is that to get rid of the whole conflict, you have to make sure justice prevails in the region. They will have no more excuses to be existent. Otherwise, IS and similar organizations will be there all the time...
     
    OP

    ReBeL

    The Jackal
    Jan 14, 2005
    22,871
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #2,500
    Shia minority in Yemen just made a military coup and announced the whole country "presidency, parliament, government" is theirs.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Aljazeera: IS just announced that an American hostage was killed as a result of one of the coalition attacks...
     

    Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 17)