Based on my own overage ratings during the entire season: Marchisio, Buffon, Canna, Trez, Poulsen, Sissoko, Candreva & Legro.
Again, this is based on how I rated each individual player throughout the entire season.
This is not based on how I remember the season. Because believe me, I'm surprised myself that I rated someone like Canna higher than Diego, since that is definitely not how I remember it today.
I guess what I remember now, is not exactly the same as what happened over an entire season...
And now back to the deck talk!