Jem83

maitre'd at Canal Bar
Nov 7, 2005
22,870
buying zaza wasnt a blunder. he is not a bad player imo.

buying zaza AND mandzukic is. why buy both when u have morata?
Yeah well I didn't mean that Zaza is a bad player or that he isn't worth 18 million. He probably is worth that much. I'm just saying that if it was so imperative that we got that AM this summer, we should've prioritized differently. The money we spent on Zaza could've gone into landing a top AM (18 million + the reported / assumed 25-30 mill that we currently have left would probably be enough to land us a Draxler or a Mikhtaryawhatevs).

And as you said, we also bought Mandzukic. So Zaza wasn't really needed. Not as much as a trequartista, anyway.
 

PedroFlu

Senior Member
Sep 20, 2011
7,166
Honestly, at this point, if Draxler is not possible, just stay put and let's roll.

We've already spent more than 50M on transfers, it's a lot. Mistakes were made, good transfers too.

With the current squad, we have 2 very wildcards: Asamoah and Khedira. I won't count on neither of them.

Starting team - 4312:

Buffon - Licht, Bonucci, Chiellini, Sandro - Marchisio, Pogba, Sturaro - Pereyra - Morata, Mandzukic.

Bench: Neto - Caceres, Rugani, Barzagli, Evra - Padoin, Vitale - Dybala - Coman, Cuadrado, Zaza.


Conclusion is the squad is unbalanced, unless we can count on Asamoah and Khedira (as far as we know, we can't).

Defense and attack great depth, midfield very poor depth.

Starting team much inferior to last season's starting team.

Chemistry yet to be seen - there could be issues on the offensive front.

This while spending around 55M (including sales)

- - - Updated - - -

Now the best case scenarium: we sign Draxler and he fits perfectly as an AM. Dybala's performances force his way into the starting lineup. Mandzukic is dropped to the bench in favour of a more fluid and countering style in Europe. Alex Sandro offers great offensive force on the left. Khedira and Asamoah fully recover. Zaza is loaned out.

4312/ 433:

Buffon - Licht, Bonucci, Chiellini, Sandro - Marchisio, Pogba, Pereyra - Draxler, Dybala, Morata.

Bench: Neto - Caceres, Rugani, Barzagli, Evra - Asamoah, Khedira, Sturaro - Coman, Cuadrado, Mandzukic.


That would be a hell of a starting team and a hell of a bench.
 

Post Ironic

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2013
42,253
Honestly. We made some great signings. Dybala, Mandzukic, Sandro. And some half-decent ones in Khedira, Cuadrado, Neto.

These weren't the problem. The problem is how we dealt with other clubs wanting our players. We knew Tevez and Pirlo would leave, basically for free, but also freeing up their wages for other earners in the club. This is fine, losing Tevez especially hurts, but it was inevitable, and we did everything we could to keep him.

Vidal being sold almost out of nowhere, at a bargain price, is alright too, as Beppe kept saying we were going to sign a top CAM, or a very versatile Midfield player (who could take over Vidal's role as our CAM, but also play B2B in other formations, etc). Sucks to lose Vidal, but everything pointed to a replacement being signed.

Then, these last two weeks and all of a sudden we're giving Llorente for free, and Beppe is suggesting no CAMs are available that are Juventus quality, but money is not the issue, we would spend whatever amount on the right player. And to top it off he says "individual players are not decisive", as though in some way trying to soften the blow of failing to land our targets.

We may well play a 3-5-2, 4-3-1-2, 4-3-3, whatever else this year, and we might even succeed, but the amount of if's he has created with his failure in this mercato, and the pressure he's heaped on Allegri by almost forcing him to change formation from the one that got us to a CL final, it's quite frankly ridiculous. Not signing a CAM after everything that went on this summer is a massive failure on his part.

I'll still play the wait and see how the season goes, but if things go south this year, the summer mercato has been a colossal fuck-up on Beppe's part.
 

Klin

نحن الروبوتات
May 27, 2009
61,692
If money was no matter than why the fuck didn't we pay the 50 mil required to get a top player of Isco/Goetze/Oscar calibre? Beppe sounds ridiculous when saying there are no Juve material AMs available. That's because you left it to the last goddamn week of the mercato. :sergio:
Huge Beppe fan and that will never change, but he has commited one terrible mistake this mercato: Zaza.

Let's say we have around 25-30 million now, to spend on an AM. Which isn't enough.

Then it appears to me that the real blunder was buying Zaza for 18 mill. Those 25-30 mill + the "Zaza money" would be enough to get us that AM, but now it's impossible.
If you can't find a big player to invest in then don't sell Vidal. It's really that simple
Yeah well I didn't mean that Zaza is a bad player or that he isn't worth 18 million. He probably is worth that much. I'm just saying that if it was so imperative that we got that AM this summer, we should've prioritized differently. The money we spent on Zaza could've gone into landing a top AM (18 million + the reported / assumed 25-30 mill that we currently have left would probably be enough to land us a Draxler or a Mikhtaryawhatevs).

And as you said, we also bought Mandzukic. So Zaza wasn't really needed. Not as much as a trequartista, anyway.
Honestly. We made some great signings. Dybala, Mandzukic, Sandro. And some half-decent ones in Khedira, Cuadrado, Neto.

These weren't the problem. The problem is how we dealt with other clubs wanting our players. We knew Tevez and Pirlo would leave, basically for free, but also freeing up their wages for other earners in the club. This is fine, losing Tevez especially hurts, but it was inevitable, and we did everything we could to keep him.

Vidal being sold almost out of nowhere, at a bargain price, is alright too, as Beppe kept saying we were going to sign a top CAM, or a very versatile Midfield player (who could take over Vidal's role as our CAM, but also play B2B in other formations, etc). Sucks to lose Vidal, but everything pointed to a replacement being signed.

Then, these last two weeks and all of a sudden we're giving Llorente for free, and Beppe is suggesting no CAMs are available that are Juventus quality, but money is not the issue, we would spend whatever amount on the right player. And to top it off he says "individual players are not decisive", as though in some way trying to soften the blow of failing to land our targets.

We may well play a 3-5-2, 4-3-1-2, 4-3-3, whatever else this year, and we might even succeed, but the amount of if's he has created with his failure in this mercato, and the pressure he's heaped on Allegri by almost forcing him to change formation from the one that got us to a CL final, it's quite frankly ridiculous. Not signing a CAM after everything that went on this summer is a massive failure on his part.

I'll still play the wait and see how the season goes, but if things go south this year, the summer mercato has been a colossal fuck-up on Beppe's part.
What is happening tonight?

:delpiero:
 

JuveJay

Senior Signor
Moderator
Mar 6, 2007
74,965
Huge Beppe fan and that will never change, but he has commited one terrible mistake this mercato: Zaza.

Let's say we have around 25-30 million now, to spend on an AM. Which isn't enough.

Then it appears to me that the real blunder was buying Zaza for 18 mill. Those 25-30 mill + the "Zaza money" would be enough to get us that AM, but now it's impossible.
Maybe, but we need Zaza now, if the plan all along was to sell Llorente (as we all believed it was). We need at least four real forwards.

- - - Updated - - -

- - -[/COLOR]
I think he is trying to say we won't move away from our evaluations of a player and that the other teams need to be realistic as well.
That's how I understood it, and he seems to be referring to the stupid money being thrown around elsewhere. Basically teams are asking for more than we want to pay, even for players who aren't much of an upgrade or at all.

Just Beppe being Beppe.
 

Post Ironic

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2013
42,253
Maybe, but we need Zaza now, if the plan all along was to sell Llorente (as we all believed it was). We need at least four real forwards.
Wouldn't it have been better to sign more of a versatile SS-type as our 4th striker? I don't see Zaza deserving any playing time ahead of Morata or Mandzukic, and DYbala can also play as a CF if needed...
 

JuveJay

Senior Signor
Moderator
Mar 6, 2007
74,965
Wouldn't it have been better to sign more of a versatile SS-type as our 4th striker? I don't see Zaza deserving any playing time ahead of Morata or Mandzukic, and DYbala can also play as a CF if needed...
I don't know, if Mandzukic gets injured it only leaves Morata, and he often isn't a central reference in attack.
 

Post Ironic

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2013
42,253
I don't know, if Mandzukic gets injured it only leaves Morata, and he often isn't a central reference in attack.
True... but then wouldn't that cause problems with a Dybala-Morata front 2 regardless? Or are you thinking if we play a front 2 that it will be Mandzukic as the constant and Dybala and Morata who rotate?
 

Hydde

Minimiliano Tristelli
Mar 6, 2003
38,987
Yeah well I didn't mean that Zaza is a bad player or that he isn't worth 18 million. He probably is worth that much. I'm just saying that if it was so imperative that we got that AM this summer, we should've prioritized differently. The money we spent on Zaza could've gone into landing a top AM (18 million + the reported / assumed 25-30 mill that we currently have left would probably be enough to land us a Draxler or a Mikhtaryawhatevs).

And as you said, we also bought Mandzukic. So Zaza wasn't really needed. Not as much as a trequartista, anyway.
This is what i said earlier... why we prioritized Zaza over a cAM after we bought Dybala?. This was the fuck up of the year for Marotta. He should have punced right after selling Vidal..and without buying ZAZA. That mercato would have been excellent. We would just have needed to sort out Asa and Khedira...but this was way easier that we are facing now withot an AM that allegri requested aeons ago.

Lets hope allegri doesnt get mad at this. He surely can sort it out.

buying zaza wasnt a blunder. he is not a bad player imo.

buying zaza AND mandzukic is. why buy both when u have morata?
:tup:

Honestly, at this point, if Draxler is not possible, just stay put and let's roll.

We've already spent more than 50M on transfers, it's a lot. Mistakes were made, good transfers too.

With the current squad, we have 2 very wildcards: Asamoah and Khedira. I won't count on neither of them.

Starting team - 4312:

Buffon - Licht, Bonucci, Chiellini, Sandro - Marchisio, Pogba, Sturaro - Pereyra - Morata, Mandzukic.

Bench: Neto - Caceres, Rugani, Barzagli, Evra - Padoin, Vitale - Dybala - Coman, Cuadrado, Zaza.


Conclusion is the squad is unbalanced, unless we can count on Asamoah and Khedira (as far as we know, we can't).

Defense and attack great depth, midfield very poor depth.

Starting team much inferior to last season's starting team.

Chemistry yet to be seen - there could be issues on the offensive front.

This while spending around 55M (including sales)

- - - Updated - - -

Now the best case scenarium: we sign Draxler and he fits perfectly as an AM. Dybala's performances force his way into the starting lineup. Mandzukic is dropped to the bench in favour of a more fluid and countering style in Europe. Alex Sandro offers great offensive force on the left. Khedira and Asamoah fully recover. Zaza is loaned out.

4312/ 433:

Buffon - Licht, Bonucci, Chiellini, Sandro - Marchisio, Pogba, Pereyra - Draxler, Dybala, Morata.

Bench: Neto - Caceres, Rugani, Barzagli, Evra - Asamoah, Khedira, Sturaro - Coman, Cuadrado, Mandzukic.


That would be a hell of a starting team and a hell of a bench.

I agree that what is fuking us up is the unreliability of Asamoah and <khedira. That must be very worrying because we are 2 player less, and we cant count on them not getting injured.

We may well play a 3-5-2, 4-3-1-2, 4-3-3, whatever else this year, and we might even succeed, but the amount of if's he has created with his failure in this mercato, and the pressure he's heaped on Allegri by almost forcing him to change formation from the one that got us to a CL final, it's quite frankly ridiculous. Not signing a CAM after everything that went on this summer is a massive failure on his part.

I'll still play the wait and see how the season goes, but if things go south this year, the summer mercato has been a colossal $#@!-up on Beppe's part.
All good posts guys.
 

JuveJay

Senior Signor
Moderator
Mar 6, 2007
74,965
True... but then wouldn't that cause problems with a Dybala-Morata front 2 regardless? Or are you thinking if we play a front 2 that it will be Mandzukic as the constant and Dybala and Morata who rotate?
I think those three will rotate, but that some games or moments in games will call for more of a reference in attack, and Morata doesn't always relish it. He's good off the shoulder and battles but much better with the ball at his feet.
 

Suns

Release clause?
May 22, 2009
22,087
I'm worried, I'm not seeing the red line this summer by Beppe. He's all over the place. Not only with the signings but also with the departures. He has sold some very important players on the pitch and some good chemistry guys off it as well (Pepe, Llorente, Storari).

Alex Sandro is the only improvement, the rest are are downgrades.

I'm worried, expecting a transitional year.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 90)