Hydde

Minimiliano Tristelli
Mar 6, 2003
38,987
What concern me a little is our backline. Our top guys are ageing... and then we have the bonuccis and ogbonnas. On top of it all, Italy as a whole is producing more bonuccis everyday. Who will we buy in this case?.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

Pirlo's Beard

Junkie Joe Joyce
Oct 2, 2013
11,411
This romantic notion that we'll keep churning out amazing players and live happily ever after is great. And our transfer strategy is fine at this moment in time. But let's take you all on a virtual tour of our team, and maybe this beautiful Utopian dream can make way for a bit of realism.







Left back: As far as actual left backs go, we have 1. His name is Partice Evra. Where is his potential replacement in a year or twos time? Where is this young future legend, this bright young prospect lad who's ready to step in? I don't see him, and Asamoah is not the answer. Not for a back 4, not unless you want to turn a very good midfielder into a mediocre full back.



CB: Our best defender is 33 and increasingly injury prone, our 2nd best defender is not far behind in both regards. Do we have one of these ready made replacements waiting for his chance? Do we? No.

We're pinning all of our hopes on Rugani, who is absolutely an unknown quantity at this point in time. He may be ready in 4-5 years time IF he turns out like we all want him to.


Pirlo. The sole creative spark on our team. Needless to say we have absolutely no solution when he's finished. Our already worryingly small source of creativity will be gone and what do we do? Rely on Marchisio to unlock opposition defences on a consistent bases? Yeah... no.





So we can all live in the 90's again, or we can wake up and understand that unless we invest properly (No, NOBODY is suggesting we pull a City/Madrid/united) but we must invest properly to just MAINTAIN our current level in the next few years when our defence, and the heart of our midfield is finished. These 10M net spending windows are fine right now. But you can bet everything you own on the fact we are not going to strike it lucky several times in one Summer replacing the core of our team. If we can not afford top class youngsters at the very least, then I hope you all make peace with Bonucci and Ogbonna starting all of our games 2 years from now. And I do not want to hear a single complaint from ANYBODY who is suggesting we have no real need for a 'top' player when some of our own TOP players are 2-3 years away from being finished at this level.

Back in the day we or any other sensible club for that matter could find some amazing deals. Talented youngsters would come for a reasonable fee, and all was well. Nowadays unless you strike it lucky with contract issues/general unhappiness any useless young scrub who's had a half decent season playing in an obscure league will end up costing an arm & a leg. Wake up people, enough of this 'tradition' talk when we all know damn well that if you don't get with the times you fall behind.
 

Hist

Founder of Hism
Jan 18, 2009
11,619
This romantic notion that we'll keep churning out amazing players and live happily ever after is great. And our transfer strategy is fine at this moment in time. But let's take you all on a virtual tour of our team, and maybe this beautiful Utopian dream can make way for a bit of realism.







Left back: As far as actual left backs go, we have 1. His name is Partice Evra. Where is his potential replacement in a year or twos time? Where is this young future legend, this bright young prospect lad who's ready to step in? I don't see him, and Asamoah is not the answer. Not for a back 4, not unless you want to turn a very good midfielder into a mediocre full back.



CB: Our best defender is 33 and increasingly injury prone, our 2nd best defender is not far behind in both regards. Do we have one of these ready made replacements waiting for his chance? Do we? No.

We're pinning all of our hopes on Rugani, who is absolutely an unknown quantity at this point in time. He may be ready in 4-5 years time IF he turns out like we all want him to.


Pirlo. The sole creative spark on our team. Needless to say we have absolutely no solution when he's finished. Our already worryingly small source of creativity will be gone and what do we do? Rely on Marchisio to unlock opposition defences on a consistent bases? Yeah... no.





So we can all live in the 90's again, or we can wake up and understand that unless we invest properly (No, NOBODY is suggesting we pull a City/Madrid/united) but we must invest properly to just MAINTAIN our current level in the next few years when our defence, and the heart of our midfield is finished. These 10M net spending windows are fine right now. But you can bet everything you own on the fact we are not going to strike it lucky several times in one Summer replacing the core of our team. If we can not afford top class youngsters at the very least, then I hope you all make peace with Bonucci and Ogbonna starting all of our games 2 years from now. And I do not want to hear a single complaint from ANYBODY who is suggesting we have no real need for a 'top' player when some of our own TOP players are 2-3 years away from being finished at this level.

Back in the day we or any other sensible club for that matter could find some amazing deals. Talented youngsters would come for a reasonable fee, and all was well. Nowadays unless you strike it lucky with contract issues/general unhappiness any useless young scrub who's had a half decent season playing in an obscure league will end up costing an arm & a leg. Wake up people, enough of this 'tradition' talk when we all know damn well that if you don't get with the times you fall behind.
I've been saying this exact same thing for months now but no one is listening
 

Zacheryah

Senior Member
Aug 29, 2010
42,251
Asamoah is a valid choice to be reschooled to leftback, as we wont find a better one soon anyway

Pirlo is not really an issue. With Coman and potentially Rabiot and Sturaro we got that area covered.

Centreback is an issue we need to focus on next summer.

Considering development of Berardi and Coman/Pereyra, we dont need to waste money on the top winger
 

Hist

Founder of Hism
Jan 18, 2009
11,619
Asamoah is a valid choice to be reschooled to leftback, as we wont find a better one soon anyway

Pirlo is not really an issue. With Coman and potentially Rabiot and Sturaro we got that area covered.

Centreback is an issue we need to focus on next summer.

Considering development of Berardi and Coman/Pereyra, we dont need to waste money on the top winger
From Vidal( worlds best box to box) pirlo ( worlds best regista) and pogba/marchisio to rabiot( big question mark) staruro and the likes. That's a huge downgrade.

Asamoah maybe a good lb but what about licht?

We agree on the lack of cbs but there is also Buffon to think about

We are in for a shitstorm
 

Zacheryah

Senior Member
Aug 29, 2010
42,251
From Vidal( worlds best box to box) pirlo ( worlds best regista) and pogba/marchisio to rabiot( big question mark) staruro and the likes. That's a huge downgrade.

Asamoah maybe a good lb but what about licht?

We agree on the lack of cbs but there is also Buffon to think about

We are in for a shitstorm
We cant possibly get a midfielder who has pirlo's impact. It was allways going to be a downgrade
And there is no "from vidal" as he is staying and finishing his (european) career here.
Licht can last a few more years, and Romulo can play rb.

Buffon is an issue, but when will he retire ? Recent game showed he still got it

- - - Updated - - -

Why does Zach seems to think so highly of Sturaro all of a sudden? :lol:

And since when Coleman, or whatever his name is, is a top player? :p
A certain mod (and to a lesser extend some french friends) convinced me of Sturaro, and Coman is a very promising talent of who i expect great things. And i was the first to advocate this.
 

only-juve

Senior Member
Jan 5, 2008
7,451
I had similar discussions with friends over the past years. Those who follow Juve since the 90's know for fact that Juve's strategy have always been focused on developing youngsters. Juve only broke the habit when they had to sell Zidane, and they signed 3 big players not just one.

Those who demand Juve to spend heavily every summer on so-called world-class players are not familiar with the history of this club when it comes to the transfer market. Just like the brilliant Alessio Secco.
Been following JUVE since 1993 and I disagree with your friends.
 

Hydde

Minimiliano Tristelli
Mar 6, 2003
38,987
Been following JUVE since 1993 and I disagree with your friends.
I have to agree on this. By nature, when you are one of the top dogs in the business you are in no need of having to wait for a superstar to raise from your youth ranks...you just buy them from the other teams because you have the money.

Thats what juve did in the past. Pretty much what madrid is doing now on a galactic level style.
 

Jem83

maitre'd at Canal Bar
Nov 7, 2005
22,870
Juve have always bought players, but never behaved like a Real Madrid or an AC Milan under Berlusconi. With the exception of Nedved/Buffon of course, but that was financed by the megasale of Zinedine Zidane, a french player who we in fact got very cheaply (around 4 million euros) due to great scouting and transfer negotiations by the club.

We've signed many great players in the past, like Vialli, Baggio etc., but I'm sure the point K.O. wanted to make was that the typical Juve model has been to supply such good purchases with developed talents and wise, low-cost moves for other good players. Take a look at the 1996 Juve CL winning squad photos, and you will see a squad that was created with this model.

No one is claiming that we never buy players, though. Just that we've never been a club to dish out insane sums just like that.
 

GordoDeCentral

Diez
Moderator
Apr 14, 2005
70,835
except thats simply not true charles, platini, baggio, emerson were all world class players when we bought them and we broke the bank, along with transfer records, to get them. This notion that we suddenly are this high class 'udinese' is not true.
 

Jem83

maitre'd at Canal Bar
Nov 7, 2005
22,870
No doubt under the course of a long, successful history, there will be some buys that are more expensive than others. But we're talking about what has been the core policy of the club here.

A Real Madrid or this modern day circus-like United, we have never been.
 

GordoDeCentral

Diez
Moderator
Apr 14, 2005
70,835
Charles, Platini, Baggio, Emerson?

4 WC players over a 50 year period?

Real Madrid buys 2-3 per season.

...

- - - Updated - - -

No doubt under the course of a long, successful history, there will be some buys that are more expensive than others. But we're talking about what has been the core policy of the club here.

A Real Madrid or this modern day circus-like United, we have never been.

policy is to have 4-5 world class players, acquired whether it be through good scouting or bought at peak, shouldered by solid hard workers, This notion that we gamble our future on potential is wrong.
 

Jem83

maitre'd at Canal Bar
Nov 7, 2005
22,870
Yeah, but I never wrote that. Juve's club policy is to mix purchasing some high end players (although not at all costs), low-cost good players and developing own players.

It's true that Juve always aim to have a couple of world class players in the squad at all times, but if you can't see the difference between us and Real Madrid / Berlusconi-Milan / current United, then you are blind.
 

j0ker

Capo di tutti capi
Jan 5, 2006
22,892
Well yeah I agree with that.

My point is that we hardly can be considered a club thay buys a WC player every season or two. In our case I would say it's a WC player per decade.
 

j0ker

Capo di tutti capi
Jan 5, 2006
22,892
what happened to Vieira, cannavaro, thuram? etc... i know what you're trying to say but Juve have brought in far more world class players in that 50 year period
Thuram, Nedved, Buffon were already mentioned above.

Cannavaro? You gotta be kidding me. He wasn't even close to having the status of players we are talking above when we bought him, what happened next is another matter.

Vieira was at the end of his career, nothing to be excited.
 

GordoDeCentral

Diez
Moderator
Apr 14, 2005
70,835
Yeah, but I never wrote that. Juve's club policy is to mix purchasing some high end players (although not at all costs), low-cost good players and developing own players.

It's true that Juve always aim to have a couple of world class players in the squad at all times, but if you can't see the difference between us and Real Madrid / Berlusconi-Milan / current United, then you are blind.

because this board didnt try and fail to sign a WC player for the last 4 years, it's simply stunning how facts get ignored to support a narrative.
 

Jem83

maitre'd at Canal Bar
Nov 7, 2005
22,870
because this board didnt try and fail to sign a WC player for the last 4 years, it's simply stunning how facts get ignored to support a narrative.
Oh, we try, but when the sums become insane, we usually pull out. Of course we're interested in those kind of players, but we don't sign them at all costs, and never did. Even when we paid alot in the past (Charles, Thuram, Nedved, Buffon etc.), there were always good reasons behind why we decided to pounce.

Never claimed that Juve don't buy players, but we don't throw money around like other clubs and we never had a galacticos-like policy such as you claim.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 128)