Giuseppe Marotta (70 Viewers)

[ZoSo]

Yeah I'm probably not being clear.

Top striker - €30m, split over 3 years (2012, 2013, 2014)

Asamoah/Isla - €18m combined for halves, split over 3 years (2012, 2013, 2014)
Asamoah/Isla - remaining €18m, bought in either 2013 or 2014, split over 3 years (2013, 2014, 2015 or 2014, 2015, 2016)

So you see, if we buy out the second halves this summer it would be spent over 4 years, if we do it next summer then it would be spent over 5 years. So for co-owned players the money is spread over a longer period than spending it all on one outright transfer.

It's one reason why clubs do co-ownerships and loan-to-buys, it spreads deals out longer than the allowed 3 installments.

Ah, I see now.

Although this could all be invalid if the top striker €30m is split over 4 or so years, but I don't think real life is FM

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[LowLife]

Caceres
Giaccherini
Asamoah
Isla
Giovinco
Leali
Lucio
Masi
Boakye
Pogba
Rubinho
Bendtner
Peluso
Pirlo
Ziegler
Pazienza
Motta
Pepe
Quagliarella
Matri
Lichtsteiner
Vucinic
Estigarribia (loan)
Elia
Borriello (loan)
Padoin
Storari
Lanzafame (loan)
Bonucci
Martinez
Constantino
Krasic
Aquilani (loan)
Camilleri (loan)
Rinaudo (loan)
Sorensen
Toni
Barzagli
Traore (loan)

Caceres
Giaccherini (fail)
Asamoah
Isla (fail, at least so far)
Giovinco
Leali
Lucio (big fail)
Masi (fail)
Boakye (n/a)
Pogba
Rubinho
Bendtner (fail)
Peluso (fail)
Pirlo
Ziegler (fail)
Pazienza (fail)
Motta (fail Marrotta's masterpiece)
Pepe
Quagliarella (18 mil, fail)
Matri (18 mil, fail)
Lichtsteiner
Vucinic
Estigarribia (fail)
Elia (no comment)
Borriello (fail) 2 goals in 5 months
Padoin (ok player)
Storari
Lanzafame (Fail)
Bonucci
Martinez (fail)
Constantino (who the fuck is this?)
Krasic (fail)
Aquilani (fail)
Camilleri (loan)
Rinaudo ( )
Sorensen
Toni (fail)
Barzagli
Traore (disaster)

 

[Klovn]

Caceres
Giaccherini (fail)
Asamoah
Isla (fail, at least so far)
Giovinco
Leali
Lucio (big fail)
Masi (fail)
Boakye (n/a)
Pogba
Rubinho
Bendtner (fail)
Peluso (fail)
Pirlo
Ziegler (fail)
Pazienza (fail)
Motta (fail Marrotta's masterpiece)
Pepe
Quagliarella (18 mil, fail)
Matri (18 mil, fail)
Lichtsteiner
Vucinic
Estigarribia (fail)
Elia (no comment)
Borriello (fail) 2 goals in 5 months
Padoin (ok player)
Storari
Lanzafame (Fail)
Bonucci
Martinez (fail)
Constantino (who the fuck is this?)
Krasic (fail)
Aquilani (fail)
Camilleri (loan)
Rinaudo ( )
Sorensen
Toni (fail)
Barzagli
Traore (disaster)

You forgot Vidal (fail)

 

[The Curr]

I think you're harsh on Estigarribia, Masi and Giaccherini.

Constantino was 4th choice keeper for one season.

Edit: oops, I've added Vidal to the list now.

 

[LowLife]

You forgot Vidal (fail)

That list was not made for celebrations and hairstyle. I stand correct.

 

[ZoSo]

List of players

To be fair, I will split this into 2 categories. Good or bad. No middle ground. For the most part, it is based this on the how player has perfomed to this day and economic values do not matter (i.e. selling for more than paid does not a good transfer make in this list). Also, I'm not counting youth players like Leali, Masi and Boakye, since they haven't played for the senior team in official matches.

Good:
Asamoah
Giaccherini
Giovinco
Pogba
Rubinho
Pirlo
Pepe
Quagliarella
Matri
Lichtsteiner
Vidal
Vucinic
Estigarribia (loan)
Padoin
Storari
Bonucci
Sorensen
Barzagli
Caceres
Isla
Krasic


Bad:
Lucio
Bendtner
Peluso
Ziegler
Pazienza
Motta
Elia
Borriello (loan)
Lanzafame (loan)
Toni
Aquilani (loan)
Camilleri (loan)
Rinaudo (loan)
Traore (loan)
Martinez
Constantino


Hardest to classify was Krasic.


Good: 21
Bad: 16

Out of 37 transfers in, 56.7% were good and 43.3% were bad.

 

[LowLife]

To be fair, I will split this into 2 categories. Good or bad. No middle ground. For the most part, it is based this on the how player has perfomed to this day and economic values do not matter (i.e. selling for more than paid does not make good transfer in this list). Also, I'm not counting youth players like Leali, Masi, Boakye either, since they haven't played for the senior team in official matches.

Good:
Asamoah
Giaccherini
Giovinco
Pogba
Rubinho
Pirlo
Pepe
Quagliarella
Matri
Lichtsteiner
Vidal
Vucinic
Estigarribia (loan)
Padoin
Storari
Bonucci
Sorensen
Barzagli
Caceres
Isla
Krasic


Bad:
Lucio
Bendtner
Peluso
Ziegler
Pazienza
Motta
Elia
Borriello (loan)
Lanzafame (loan)
Toni
Aquilani (loan)
Camilleri (loan)
Rinaudo (loan)
Traore (loan)
Martinez
Constantino


Hardest to classify was Krasic.


Good: 21
Bad: 16

Out of 37 transfers in, 56.7% were good and 43.3% were bad.

This is very bad. I mean this is not an exam when you get 51% and you pass. So Marrota got a C+

 

[Nzoric]

To be fair, I will split this into 2 categories. Good or bad. No middle ground. For the most part, it is based this on the how player has perfomed to this day and economic values do not matter (i.e. selling for more than paid does not a good transfer make in this list). Also, I'm not counting youth players like Leali, Masi and Boakye, since they haven't played for the senior team in official matches.

Good:
Asamoah
Giaccherini
Giovinco
Pogba
Rubinho
Pirlo
Pepe
Quagliarella
Matri
Lichtsteiner
Vidal
Vucinic
Estigarribia (loan)
Padoin
Storari
Bonucci
Sorensen
Barzagli
Caceres
Isla
Krasic


Bad:
Lucio
Bendtner
Peluso
Ziegler
Pazienza
Motta
Elia
Borriello (loan)
Lanzafame (loan)
Toni
Aquilani (loan)
Camilleri (loan)
Rinaudo (loan)
Traore (loan)
Martinez
Constantino


Hardest to classify was Krasic.


Good: 21
Bad: 16

Out of 37 transfers in, 56.7% were good and 43.3% were bad.

Out of 37 transfers 43,3% of those were bad. Out of the 16 'bad' transfers, 6 were loans . FFS this is rudementary.

 

[BIG DADDY!!!]

How can players that were brought in on a free transfer be considered bad though?

The only money that was spent was for their wages and none of them except for Aquilani were considered starters.

Aquilani was great the first few months here and formed a great partnership with Melo.

His form dipped like krasic when the whole team stopped performing.

 

[The Curr]

Out of 37 transfers 43,3% of those were bad. Out of the 16 'bad' transfers, 6 were loans . FFS this is rudementary.

7 were loans. Bendtner is too.

 

[Turk_Bianconero]

Good:

Quagliarella
Matri

33 million to toilet.

 

[Nzoric]

How can players that were brought in on a free transfer be considered bad though?

Because his statistics are full retard

 

[LowLife]

Marrotta's strategy is to sign quantity player, not quality, obviously, when you sign 40 players half might be good and 2-3 world class (vidal, & Pirlo), I would like to know how much did he spend all? is it over 300m or not?

 

[abstract]

To be fair, I will split this into 2 categories. Good or bad. No middle ground. For the most part, it is based this on the how player has perfomed to this day and economic values do not matter (i.e. selling for more than paid does not a good transfer make in this list). Also, I'm not counting youth players like Leali, Masi and Boakye, since they haven't played for the senior team in official matches.

Good:
Asamoah
Giaccherini
Giovinco
Pogba
Rubinho
Pirlo
Pepe
Quagliarella
Matri
Lichtsteiner
Vidal
Vucinic
Estigarribia (loan)
Padoin
Storari
Bonucci
Sorensen
Barzagli
Caceres
Isla
Krasic


Bad:
Lucio
Bendtner
Peluso
Ziegler
Pazienza
Motta
Elia
Borriello (loan)
Lanzafame (loan)
Toni
Aquilani (loan)
Camilleri (loan)
Rinaudo (loan)
Traore (loan)
Martinez
Constantino


Hardest to classify was Krasic.


Good: 21
Bad: 16

Out of 37 transfers in, 56.7% were good and 43.3% were bad.

Matri,Quagliarella and Krasic (50 mil) are bad transfers.

 

[Maddy]

oh u guys and ur list on bad/good transfers.

cracking me up real good.

talk about simplifying. stronk.

 

[Turk_Bianconero]

It is easier to count his good moves rather than bad ones. Guy is Ranieri of directors. Temporary solution but will not take you to next level.

 

[ZoSo]

Out of 37 transfers 43,3% of those were bad. Out of the 16 'bad' transfers, 6 were loans . FFS this is rudementary.

They are transfers. And they certainly can't be classified as good.

 

[Nzoric]

Marrotta's strategy is to sign quantity player, not quality, obviously, when you sign 40 players half might be good and 2-3 world class (vidal, & Pirlo), I would like to know how much did he spend all? is it over 300m or not?

It's definitely not over 300m :S

 

[LowLife]

33 million to toilet.

We could have bought: Balotelli, Suarez, Dzeko, Villa, Levandowski, list goes on. So yeah Marrotta is a big fail, at least when it comes to strikers.

 

[Nzoric]

They are transfers. And they certainly can't be classified as good.

How is it a transfer if there is no contract of full player rights are signed between club and player?