But we are not talking about Chelsea, nor Italy, but Juventus. The current Juventus. And the needs and aims and condition and problems of Juventus means that comparing managerial requirements with other clubs is pointless.
Yes, I agree, a change of league, even just a change of club in the same league, can have a dramatic effect on a manager's fortunes.
Rafa's reputation amongst my peers in England, who are all heavily involved in an almost fanatical devotion to the premier league, and to football in general, is not of 'undoubtedly a great coach'. In fact I have only ever heard or read of people referring to him with such reverence on these forums...which is both interesting and strange. Perhaps it implies his reputation outside of england is far stronger than within england.
The great coaches in england...Ferguson....
Martin O Neil...Wenger...Capello.
It would seem like a wind-up, for someone to tell me that Benitez is obviously better than those guys, or even as talented as those guys. yet he has won trophies, which to some people, especially on here, makes him something special.
As a player at a club who has had a season of massive disappointment, and some of the worst form for many years, it seems logical for them to be filled with greater enthusiasm for a manager who has recently done something decent with another club, before coming to Juve. And I go back to the main aim of Rafa at Liverpool, which has been to challenge for the title. Has he been a success there, on his main aim?? definitely not. Yes, to many, that ultra lucky champions league campaign which ended with the trophy, makes the original aim of challenging for the title a mute point...but it is not a mute point to me, when my main desire, is to have a Juve which can once again, as is our tradition, challenge every season for the title. On that score, I do not see how anyone can say GET RAFA GET RAFA GET RAFA!!!!!!
here is an interesting article by a scouse from late last year...:>
http://www.liverpool-kop.com/2009/10/official-rafa-benitez-has-spent-over.html
I wasn't aware of all those players he had signed, neither had it dawned on me that he has little interest in developing HOME GROWN YOUTH PLAYERS. I suppose he purchased glen johnson...for a snip at 17m gold nuggets.