Anyone wonder why no one has taken into account the 3 year age difference between these two players? Oops, another flaw in their arguments...
Melo, who should be in his "prime" now at 28 years old has 8 DIFFERENT CLUBS TO HIS NAME has done nothing notable aside from the most notable flop for his national team in SA and in his first season at Juve.
Marchisio, as always, has been more consistent in just about everything. If Melo was so good at his role and had such a good season then there is no reason why we would have finished 7th. But the fault will be found on everyone else, but him.