I was excited to see Cannavaro back again, but on second thoughts I don't think he is gonna do something more than Legrottaglie. The real change we need is a young and fast defender. I think we're gonna regret this signing when he gets owned by a fast striker in the CL next year.
Pace is all well and good, but only if a defender can defend with it. Are there many defenders of the right age who can defend and have athletic ability who are available and for a price we can afford? I can't think of many, either way you would be taking a gamble unless it is a world star.
Say Zapata for instance, he is young and seems to have all the attributes required, but I have seen him make one or two horrid mistakes, and he would undoubtably make more playing for Juventus at the top level. With Cannavaro you would see less mistakes, but perhaps not so much in an all-round capacity and certainly not in any long term scenario or as an investment. But this is the thing, we as fans demand very high standards from our club and its players and staff, so that means winning and continual improvement. Whether we would win in the short term with younger players who have potential to be champions is another question. Will we be happy seeing more younger players come in and have another two or three years of improvement or are we now demanding great signings, Diego, Silva, Ribery etc? Is that realistic?
If, for example, Secco and co added a young talent or two like Zapata/A. N. Other to an experienced signing like Cannavaro, then the Cannavaro signing would suddenly look more appealing. It would provide a balance. I'm not saying this will happen, but surely they see the same flaws as we do, so is a probability. Central defender, full backs, midfield-attack linkman. This is why I give the signing of Cannavaro the benefit of the doubt as a stand alone signing. What the sporting directors achieve from our mercato as a whole will determine our season, and I prefer to wait until the end of the window to make a judgement on signings. Even then, it will be difficult to tell how that will affect the team.
What I don't agree with is running a player down before he has a chance to prove something. If any of you guys don't like Cannavaro for his actions in 2006 then fair enough, treat that as a seperate entity. If you think he is well past his best and are unprepared to give him a chance because of that then that is up to you, you make that choice based on watching him, not from general concensus or opinion. Don't mix the two, he isn't a crap defender because he is a 'traitor'. It all boils down to how he plays, if he plays well and Juve are on the up as a team then all this traitor talk will be forgotten quickly, this is football. If he doesn't play well then he will be judged on that, we have to wait and see. Let's have a bit of patience in this era of demanding instant success. Secco and co have quite a tough job balancing between creating a team for today and one for tomorrow, perhaps they aren't up to the task but I think this will be a defining season for their future. If they get it wrong this summer there is little coming back from that, we can't have another season of underperforming.