Endless Summer Mercato 2016 (72 Viewers)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mar 3, 2014
3,866
James is terrible as CM, that's the whole point of why he is flopping, he is misused in that position.

Skickat från min SM-G930F via Tapatalk
Definitely true - IMO the only way he'd work as a CM is in a Pogba role where his defensive responsibilities are very muted (Mezzala), still not optimal though. That being said, he'd be a good secondary striker.
 
Mar 3, 2014
3,866
James = overpriced, overvalued, incosisents and has no work-ethic
Conclusion: He doesn't suit Juve

#notoJames
I think I disagree with every one of those points:

-Overpriced? We just paid 94 million for Higuain. James is under 25, and a world class talent.
-Overvalued? synonym as overpriced
-Inconsistent? Maybe at CM. As a CAM/Winger, he is incredibly consistent. See his performances with Colombia/Porto/Monaco.
-No work ethic? On what basis? Being limited defensively doesn't mean lazy. He isn't strong enough defensively to be a CM.

If we bought James, he'd become a club legend IMO.
 
Apr 9, 2015
3,936
I think I disagree with every one of those points:

-Overpriced? We just paid 94 million for Higuain. James is under 25, and a world class talent.
-Overvalued? synonym as overpriced
-Inconsistent? Maybe at CM. As a CAM/Winger, he is incredibly consistent. See his performances with Colombia/Porto/Monaco.
-No work ethic? On what basis? Being limited defensively doesn't mean lazy. He isn't strong enough defensively to be a CM.

If we bought James, he'd become a club legend IMO.
- Overpiced, I mean I won't pay 70m+ for him, but I won't also give 90 for Higuain
- With overvalued I mean his abilities are overvalued, there is a reason why he isn't a regular starter by Real Madrid. He is class, but for that amount of millions you can buy 2 good players or one special player
- His perfomances with Porto are outdated and playing with your nation is always another thing. Look at Isla he is a beast for Chili, but he can't impress by his clubs.
- He gave me a lazy impression like Pjanic, but I can be wrong.

The thing I mean is I won't spend 70m+ on him. I would max spend 50m and Real Madrid will never accept that.
 
Mar 3, 2014
3,866
- Overpiced, I mean I won't pay 70m+ for him, but I won't also give 90 for Higuain
- With overvalued I mean his abilities are overvalued, there is a reason why he isn't a regular starter by Real Madrid. He is class, but for that amount of millions you can buy 2 good players or one special player
- His perfomances with Porto are outdated and playing with your nation is always another thing. Look at Isla he is a beast for Chili, but he can't impress by his clubs.
- He gave me a lazy impression like Pjanic, but I can be wrong.

The thing I mean is I won't spend 70m+ on him. I would max spend 50m and Real Madrid will never accept that.
It's tough when you play behind Bale & Ronaldo. James is a very attack minded player, and in a 4-3-3 is optimal as a playmaking winger. He just doesn't suit Zidane's Madrid. As a CAM or secondary striker with a free role, we'd see a much better James IMO.

James was a stupid purchase by Madrid, but Madrid doesn't purchase on the basis of fit, but rather by marketability. It is tough when great players have support roles. Think about Sanchez on Barcelona. He was basically splitting time with Pedro, because he was a support player to Messi. I think anyone would argue Sanchez is much better than Pedro, but it is hard to demonstrate that in a support role. I think James is similar. With more offensive responsibility, he would shine more. Unfortunately, Bale and Ronaldo are the faces of that team.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 66)