It was actually first half of a season and no, he wasn't.
Yes he is, like it or not, he is. We bought him for 25 mil € and he was hailed as one of the best players in world. At the start of the season we were even tipped by some to win the CL, be competitive on all fronts. What we have achieved was knockout at group stages, demolition by Fullham in the lower Euro competition and a fight for the 4th place. The fault is not only his, like I said he is one of the better performers in this horror of a season, but he is a flop. Not a major one like Melo, but a flop nonetheless. He did nothing he was brought here for. Didn't make us play any better, didn't set the pitch alight, nothing to justify his investment. Hell we were better last year without him, even with Ranieri.