Exactly my point. Hence, it very often was not based on performances.
A popular opinion shared by most people on this forum. Funnily enough not shared by the media / analysts / outside of Juventuz.
And I personally don't agree with it either. For me, Melo & Marchisio had a pretty similar season performance wise. Overall they were more or less equally "good".
Which was not that good at all.
A popular opinion shared by most people on this forum. Funnily enough not shared by the media / analysts / outside of Juventuz.
And I personally don't agree with it either. For me, Melo & Marchisio had a pretty similar season performance wise. Overall they were more or less equally "good".
Which was not that good at all.
Casper jokes were being made because he was almost invisible in some games. It got to a point where the joke was exaggerated a lot, as almost always is the case in here, even by me, but it still remains a fact that Marchisio was very average in the last couple of seasons.
Ah, "popular opinion". I like how you put it.
I guess sometimes you need to evaluate a player's performance not by just stats, Buck. You of all should understand that.
Ah, "popular opinion". I like how you put it.
I guess sometimes you need to evaluate a player's performance not by just stats, Buck. You of all should understand that.
and it is still true
For the past 2 seasons I don't think we even had one player that was good overall. Imo, they all ranged from dreadful (for example: Motta & Bonucci last year, Melo in his 1st season, ...) to average.
Well, if an opinion is shared by most members here, it is the popular opinion, right? Not much I can do about that
And I'll evaluate players based on how I watch games & on what I think is important. Purely personal, stats are interesting but nothing more.
Edit: I think we more or less "rate" Marchisio's last season the same: completely average. Only difference would be how we both perceive Melo's season. Which was completely average for me as well, but probably not for you/others.
Ah, "popular opinion". I like how you put it. I guess sometimes you need to evaluate a player's performance not by just stats, Buck. You of all should understand that.
I guess sometimes you need to evaluate a player's performance not by just stats, Buck. You of all should understand that.
And I'll evaluate players based on how I watch games & on what I think is important. Purely personal, stats are interesting but nothing more.
Edit: I think we more or less "rate" Marchisio's last season the same: completely average. Only difference would be how we both perceive Melo's season. Which was completely average for me as well, but probably not for you/others.
Not really. There were games where he was probably our best midfielder and still people thought he was 'invisible'. A lot of it was unwarranted and unnecessary. But then this is Juventuz and it's to be expected. Anyways, I was just pulling your leg. Not really interested in the 'war'. Even though I do enjoy him proving his 'doubters' wrong. I'm probably a fanboy . (Me and Buck share the same opinion when it comes to Marchisio, like other things we share 
)
. (Me and Buck share the same opinion when it comes to Marchisio, like other things we share )
