It's so colossal all I can do is laugh. Something bizarre happened in that second half. We stopped playing, we gave up. We didn't fight for the ball, we didn't organize ourselves on the pitch, Pjanic-Khedira who had dominated Barca and been the main reason Madrid's midfield looked so poor in the first half, just vanished. Our CBs, the best in the world this year by far, disappeared, couldn't organize themselves into a proper shape at all, they were out of position and looked helpless on each Madrid attack. And Alves, Dybala, Pjanic, Sandro, our chance creators, literally couldn't make a simple pass in the second half, Higgy couldn't even hold the ball up for 3-4 seconds without losing it.
I keep reading people say we need this or that player, this or that position fixed, etc. I don't see it. We need better depth so we can rotate better and not get as burnt out next season... but this is the same team that annihilated Barca and could have scored a 7-8 goals over the 2 legs if Higgy had his shooting boots on. This is the same team that smashed Monaco. This is the same team that dominated Serie A to the tune of 91 points, against the strongest Napoli and Roma sides in years, and a domestic double with ease in the Coppa over Lazio.
And most telling, this is the same team that clearly outclassed Madrid for the first 40 minutes, and were very unlucky not to be up 2-0, with Madrid scoring their only attempt in 40 minutes on a deflection, and Navas making an incredible save on Pjanic's gorgeous shot.
What happened in the second half was not about starting XI quality. We clearly have that in spades as shown all season long and in the first half. Something went very wrong psychologically. We were like an Inter or a Roma in Serie A, out there in the second half. Our players didn't come out to play, and mentally collapsed after that Casemiro goal. We deserved to get smashed, because we just didn't try. And that's by far the most embarrassing and pathetic aspect of that performance.