I expected us to look worse, considering we always start poorly in the Champions League. We played well in the first half, passed the ball and created some half chances.
Buffon - 7 - Made some good saves on Suarez and Messi and came out well to intercept Dembele. Nothing he could do about any of the goals.
De Sciglio - 6 - Did OK both defensively and with the passes. Would have given him a higher grade if not for that retarded pass.
Barzagli - 6.5 - I though he played well, although there was no real winger on his side.
Benatia - 5 - This guy should only start if everyone else is injured. His passing is reasonable and no terrible mistakes but he always seems as if he is just observing the game instead of actually defending.
Alex Sandro - 5.5 - Not a good game even though Dembele didn't do much on his side.
Matuidi - 7 - The best player from our team.
Pjanic - 6.5 - Some good passes in the first half, but faded in the second like the rest of the team.
Bentancur - 5 - That's not his position and he made some clumsy challenges.
Douglas Costa - 6 - He has quality. I liked that he tried hard in defense, maybe even too hard. He should have had a yellow.
Dybala - 5.5 - He tried, but didn't really do anything.
Higuain - 5 - Same, tried but failed. He is way too slow for games like this. People who think that the fact that he's a fatass doesn't matter should think again.
Sturaro - 4.5 - It doesn't seem to matter what position he plays, he's always garbage.
Bernardeschi - NR - Nice shot.
Caligara - NR -