Capitano Giorgio Chiellini (68 Viewers)

Boksic

Boksic

Senior Member
#15,642
May 11, 2005
13,441
#15,642
I don't think I'll ever forget his performance against Zlatan after our return to Serie A. Quite possibly the best display of man marking I have ever seen. He out battled him on every ball and had him completely rattled.

A magnificent defender who could do it all in terms of aggressive man marking or perfect positioning. His passing was also underrated despite looking awkward at times.
 

Fab Fragment

Senior Member
#15,645
Dec 22, 2018
3,253
#15,645
Mokku said:
Ramos in terms of ability is not in that group, success-wise for sure. Also, Cannavaro was incredible but he only spent a few years there while Maldini and Nesta were brilliant forever.
Click to expand...
Cannavaro was brilliant but maybe more so with the national team.
I wouldn’t call Ramos tier 1: goes around injuring other players eg. Salah.

- - - Updated - - -

Also Franco Baresi was excellent.
 
BayernFan

BayernFan

Senior Member
#15,652
Feb 17, 2016
6,848
#15,652
Elvin said:
Scirea, Maldini, Ramos, Nesta, Beckenbauer, Puyol etc.
Click to expand...
Well most of these won the World Cup and CL/European Cup, but I dont know if I’d say Puyol was better than Chiellini.

To me is it Beckenbauer, Maldini and Nesta in tier 1. Everyone else is a notch below, especially the first two.

In terms of pure defending I’d say Chiellini was better than Ramos and Puyol, people just tend to rate Ramos higher because of all those clutch goals and Puyol for being part of that Barca 2009-2012 team.

Not to forget Spain 2008-2012.

As a pure defender I’d take a prime Chiellini over these two.
 
JuveE46

JuveE46

Senior Member
#15,655
Dec 6, 2015
1,595
#15,655
Elvin said:
Scirea, Maldini, Ramos, Nesta, Beckenbauer, Puyol etc.
Click to expand...

If you want to bring out the microscope then those players are still not at the same category
In the "all time" consideration Scirea and Beckenbauer are on different level they changed the game and redefined what a defender could and should be.. I don't see the game owing anything to maldini and nesta other than they are great players but not on same level.
In the third group as a defender you have first puyol then ramos and I don't give two fucks that they happen to have played with two of the "GOAT" and have so and so medals and titles.


"legend"
great
good
 
Last edited:
Elvin

Elvin

Senior Member
#15,657
Nov 25, 2005
36,857
#15,657
JuveE46 said:
If you want to bring out the microscope then those players are still not at the same category
In the "all time" consideration Scirea and Beckenbauer are on different level they changed the game and redefined what a defender could and should be.. I don't see the game owing anything to maldini and nesta other than they are great players but not on same level.
In the third group as a defender you have first puyol then ramos and I don't give two fucks that they happen to have played with two of the "GOAT" and have so and so medals and titles.


"legend"
great
good
Click to expand...
No CL = no 1st tier. It's my opinion and I think most neutrals see it that way.

If you have a 20-25 season career and don't win a CL in that span (don't care how or thanks to whom), you are not a 1st tier legend in my opinion. ESPECIALLY for players after 1990.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 60)