Cannavaro"Players more Important" (4 Viewers)

Desmond

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2002
8,938
#44
No one player is more important than the coach.

That said,a team with great players and a shite coach is more likely to win trophies compared to one with a great coach and horrible players.
 

Zizou

Senior Member
Apr 21, 2003
3,965
#45
I think a perfect example is Atalanta. Before the change of coach, they were doing terribly and by January they were already 'relegated'. Delio Rossi transformed the team and Atalanta ended up winning loads of points in the last months which if they had done so from the beginning they would be fighting for a CL spot! (obviously cos of the number of points not cos they deserved it).
 
Jan 7, 2004
29,704
#48
++ [ originally posted by Zizou ] ++
I think a perfect example is Atalanta. Before the change of coach, they were doing terribly and by January they were already 'relegated'. Delio Rossi transformed the team and Atalanta ended up winning loads of points in the last months which if they had done so from the beginning they would be fighting for a CL spot! (obviously cos of the number of points not cos they deserved it).

you are forgetting makinwa
 

Seven

In bocca al lupo, Fabio.
Jun 25, 2003
38,189
#49
++ [ originally posted by m_elayyan ] ++
coach 70 %
players 30%
Oh please. That's absolutely ludicrous. Let's see if Capello can win the scudetto with Lecce. He wouldn't even be able to do so with Inter.
 

ahua

New Member
Jun 5, 2005
31
#51
this is a team sport, so capello is as important as any player, for things to work everyone has to do his part, a good group of players without a god coach is not a god team and viceversa.
 

Maher

Juventuz addict
Dec 16, 2002
13,521
#52
greece is a good example who imagined they could win euro 2004 with average players , the coach was more important than players
 

Cronios

Juventolog
Jun 7, 2004
27,412
#53
Football is a team sport,
the coach is a member of the team,
probably the brain of the team.
If the body(the players) arent good enough to perform the coaches will then having a good coach is useless.

No player either the coach is the 20-30 or even50% of the team,

With the same logic:

Imagine juve without Buffon,
imagine the perfect tactics set by Cap the team is rolling and a mediocre keeper concedes in every good chance the oposition had.
Buffon is there and making the dif in the final score so he worths about 30%?

Cannavaro? if he wasnt there, such a world class player who would make the dif? remember our defence last year?
Canna is about 40% better than Montero so as our defence this year, think of having less exp or potent player, we would concede far more goals than of the other defenders mistakes, so Canna worths about 20%.

xcuse me 19%

the rest 1% is for Camo,Zlatan,Emo,Zambro,Thuram,Neddy etc etc


So any team in Italy,
lets say Lecce or even Udinese could have won this scudetto if they had Cap+Buffon+canna in their ranks?

I m sure some people may believe this but i hope not too many,
football is a sport, u cant win it without good athlets,

Why do the athlets cost more than the coach?
(the athlets are so many but the coaches so few,
since they are so rare and much more important than every player why they dont get what they merit?)
Why Capello doesnt win the championship every year?
He doent apply the same mental work?
Why sould we worry if Milan buy Gilardino,janku,Liunberg and Chivu next year since they ll still keep Ancelotti?

rating one man (player,coach, not the President)
more than 5-10% is already a great honour,
considering that there are 22players, trainer assistants, medical stuff etc etc.
 
Jan 7, 2004
29,704
#54
++ [ originally posted by m_elayyan ] ++
greece is a good example who imagined they could win euro 2004 with average players , the coach was more important than players

a coach must have something to begin with, he cannot pull talent out of the players ass
 
Dec 26, 2004
10,624
#57
++ [ originally posted by Don Bes ] ++



they had some talent to begin with. how do you think they won ?
Military restricted system of training...
Orgnization and hard work...
Commitment to coach instructions...
And the ability to distinguish watremelon from a foot ball...
 
Jan 7, 2004
29,704
#58
++ [ originally posted by DelpieroForLife ] ++


Military restricted system of training...
Orgnization and hard work...
Commitment to coach instructions...
And the ability to distinguish watremelon from a foot ball...

yes take a group of sheepherders and put them through that, see how well they will play
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 4)