Not sure how you seeing him play pre-injury automatically makes him the best Dortmund player this season. I don't get the correlation. And it's false like others pointed out. Gundogan being good pre-injury and doing well this season aren't exactly news either. The people who're disagreeing with you are fully aware of both facts.
Liverpool might be able to outspend us, but that doesn't mean they have more pull than us. It's ridiculous to think so. It's also up to Gundogan, and we're a better, more competitive team. There's decent chance of 'Pool not even playing in the CL next season.
There's zero chance of us getting Gundogan in January, lol. Dortmund need him now. They aren't gonna sell him in mid-season. It'll be hard to sign him afterwards (but not impossible), but it's impossible to sign him in January. You have it in reverse.
It doesnt automatically make him the best dortmund player, he wasent back then either. That team was carried by several players, among them Gundogan.
Some people here "point it out" that he isnt back to that form, others say he is. Did they watch him ? Did we watch him ? No, most didnt. Nostradamus for example is, probably IgorTudor. Both disagree with each other.
What do analysts in german media or english general media say ? majority praises his return to form, the keyplayer in the midfield of the current Dortmund, of the team with aubameyang.
People here who disagree with me, arent people who watch dortmund. They saw as little as me, but they didnt bother to look up reports.
You tend to formulate educated opinions. If you disagree with what i've read in german and english covering press, feel free to share on what basis you disagree with those that see all his games and comment on them.
Can i ask from wich country you originate ? Because for some reason unknown to me, you seemb to significalty underestimate the pull of the EPL. Belgium currently has a bunch of disgustingly overrated "stars", and their incredible desire for the premier league is a nice example. Every player wants to go to barcelona and madrid. if they cant, they'll go to the EPL, wich to far to many is "the best league in the world".
Germans and the Bundesliga looks down on serie a. They do see the EPL as a big league, a bigger league.
Liverpool simply has more pull because they got CL ambitions, and Jurgen Klopp. One could compare it with benitez' Liverpool, who had a great pull on spanish players, altho they were alot better then today back then.
I agree with you, that liverpool is a ragged bunch of losers, far less competitive then juventus. Because we arent indoctrinated with this "great EPL" bullshit.
Seems we agree about January. I mentionned it cause it would beat the competition who wont make the move now. But Dortmund offcourse isnt going to cripple their team and allow a keyplayer to leave for less then they'd have in the summer.
The competition makes it impossible to sign him afterwards.
Gundogan, Marchisio, Pogba in the hands of an tactically astute coach would be a horrible nightmare to play against. I make myself no illusions, this will only happen in my next FIFA or PES game.