So called stats? lol. Its a fact that we won ~2.42 points per game he played, while 1.75 when he didnt play. That is already accounting for that retarded pass.
We WON MORE with Arthur playing than not, how annoying it might be to concede.
It was a stupid pass indeed. But we can pin every loss at a single player, depending on how far we are willing to go. They cost the same amount of points.
Objective facts are rubbish.
What does your eyes say?
I say we had our great spell of the season when he played 6 games in a row including the Copa double with inda in January.
After he got injured for 3 4 weeks and we turned to cack again.
Also blaming Arthur for the benevento defeat

when a team like Juve should have been 3 0 by then with a competent manager.
There's only one to blame there and that's the Thesis.