Let's ponder for a moment the latest coach this forum is obsessing over, Simeone. Let's just look at his results last year. 3rd in La Liga with 76 points, won that pathetic competition Copa Del Rey... and best of all crashed out of Europa in the round of 32 to Anzhi... yes, you read that right, Anzhi. If Conte had a year like that everyone on the forum would be screaming for his firing. Losing to Anzhi that early in the EL, while having both Costa and Falcao in the side, is absolutely pathetic. Simeone is doing very well this year, but Conte blew him out of the water last year as far as results go. 2nd straight scudetto, and UCL QFs (losing to the eventual champions by much less than their SF opponent did).
Their first years were a wash in my opinion. Simeone won the Europa, yes, but he also only gained 56 points in La Liga, which was less than 58 gained under their previous coach the year prior. Conte, took a Juve side of consecutive 7th place finishes to an unbeaten scudetto and a coppa italia (lame competition, yes) final.
So right now.
Year 1 results Conte = Simeone
Year 2 results Conte >>>>>>>> Simeone
Year 3 results Simeone > Conte (assuming Atletico win La Liga at the very least)
Hmmm.