the situation is like this:
Melberg will most likely be our only addition to the center of the defense. He's a solid addition but not a world class one. Which means that our defense is not really improving to the next level as much as it is just getting good depth. Now, we've seen how easily our defenders are prone to mistakes and losing concentration. And this is just against teams that are mid table such as Palermo, Lazio, Milan.
Now imagine if we are playing Bayern or Man Utd in the CL. These teams will eat our defense alive. Now, We've seen how much Sissoko has improved our team and allowed us to limit opponents from controlling the midfield. but 1 ninja alone can't protect our fragile defense. Flamini will add a lot of protection to our defense. Flamini + ninja will destroy the midfield of any top team in Europe without an exception. Which of course means that our defense will be under a lot less pressure. 2 DMs will also allow our wingers and fullback to push up.
So yes, this limits the creativity in the center, but at the cost of protecting the defense. But If Camo can continue his assist machine form, and if Gio has no trouble settling in, then our wings would be our source of needed creativity.
I have to disagree. Flashes of the Capello era are falling right infront of me .
It's true, our back line would be under a lot of less pressure but our offense would be massively predictable. Our attacks would lack variation and surprise. The opposition would know exactly what to expect and that would make their job a whole lot easier.
When you employ two destroyers in the center of midfield, you are basically telling your opposition exactly what to expect from you and that's the last thing you want.
When we had the nightmare duo of Emerson and Vieira, our attacks were so easilly stopped it was pitiful. We would play long balls into donkey face and hope he would create something from it. Our only sparks of creativity were Nedved and Camo, and even they became predictable. We played boring football then a lot like Inter now. I would hate to see us go back to playing that way.
The Capello style we used play by only worked in serie A against small Italian teams that our midfield could bully but never against European teams such as Arsenal, Liverpool. Even when we played against the big teams in serie A, we would end up winning by a Del piero/Nedved freekick or a set-piece.
Look at how we are beating these teams now, it's refereshing to see Juve beating the biggest teams in serie A out of sheer attacking creativity.
I think you overlooked the biggest problem we have had this year, our fullbacks.
That's the area we need to focus on. Countless goals have been scored on us this season because of our fullbacks. The Fiorentina and Milan games for example.
If we could get worldclass fullbacks I think our defensive problem is solved.
I'm happy with the Zanetti-Momo partership. If Flamini comes, he would replace momo, not Zanetti. Flamini and Sissoko can take eachother's places all year long. That way, we would maintain the creativity that has made us the best attacking team in serie A.