Alexis Sánchez - Barcelona - ST (16 Viewers)

Sanchez or Pastore?

  • Sanchez

  • Pastore

  • Neymar

  • Amauri


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Mohamad Anwar

Junior Member
Mar 5, 2011
128
:lol: we are talking about a player who is proven is Serie A,World cup and Copa America and another who proved himself at a league where my grandma would be a star in and a few friendlies with his national team vs scotland and sudan
 

Cheesio

**********
Jul 11, 2006
22,514
:lol: we are talking about a player who is proven is Serie A,World cup and Copa America and another who proved himself at a league where my grandma would be a star in and a few friendlies with his national team vs scotland and sudan
.
he had one good half season in Serie A . :sergio: , none of them is proven, just potentiel and Neymar's potentiel is trough the roof, he's still 19 and sanchez is 23.
and Please FYI Sanchez scoring one goal doesn't make him proven in copa America ;)
 

Mohamad Anwar

Junior Member
Mar 5, 2011
128
.
he had one good half season in Serie A . :sergio: , none of them is proven, just potentiel and Neymar's potentiel is trough the roof, he's still 19 and sanchez is 23.
and Please FYI Sanchez scoring one goal doesn't make him proven in copa America ;)
one good season?he has been playing very well with udinese but stepped to being very good last season and as I said played very well at the world cup too,one goal in copa america?have you seen him in the 2 games or better have you seen neymar with Brazil?
Neymar has splendid potential but who tells us he wont be new Robinho or new Giovanni dos santos considering he is unproven outside the waka waka league,I am sure he disapponted in many copa Libertadores games anyway
 

Cheesio

**********
Jul 11, 2006
22,514
one good season?he has been playing very well with udinese but stepped to being very good last season and as I said played very well at the world cup too,one goal in copa america?have you seen him in the 2 games or better have you seen neymar with Brazil?
Neymar has splendid potential but who tells us he wont be new Robinho or new Giovanni dos santos considering he is unproven outside the waka waka league,I am sure he disapponted in many copa Libertadores games anyway
How you can tell us that Sanchez wont be the new Quaresma ?? a lot of show no end product, you would base you argument on the last half of last year cause until then Sanchez was never consistent, he would have a good game and 6 bad games.
Both of them till now are not proven and i couldn't see how you could debate, Neymar is still 19 and he's arguably the biggest talent in the world of football right now . High risk high reward situation my bro, he could turn out to be another robinho who's still a very good player or you could get a great player like Ronaldo.
 

Mohamad Anwar

Junior Member
Mar 5, 2011
128
well quaresma never proved himself in a decent league,portugese league isnt by any means one of the top leagues so the percent of someone becoming the new quaresma is very high but thats not Alexis Sanchez
 

Cheesio

**********
Jul 11, 2006
22,514
Can't argue anymore, the overrting of Sanchez in this forum is unbeleivable. for a guy who still hadn't proven shit in his carrer
For some people he's better than Aguero, for you he's more talented than Neymar. :sergio:
 

Fred

Senior Member
Oct 2, 2003
41,113
Sanchez would give us more tactical flexibility than Aguero as well. In Krasic' absence, for example, Sanchez could slot in behind our strikers.

Sanchez
Matri Quagliarella

That would, for a fact, be the most cool attack of Europe.


edit;what am I saying. Slot DP in there too, for Matri. Even cooler.
:lol: :howler:

This is going to look so silly in a couple of years time :howler:
How did he and Vidal play yesterday? Which positions? Was Sanchez again playing on the wing and Vidal as DM?
Sanchez played as a second striker but he was shifting to the right a lot. He was very good imo, constantly moving, playing some very nice football in tight spaces and scoring a goal as well. Vidal played most of the game as a DM, but then was shifted to leftback in the second half.
 

GordoDeCentral

Diez
Moderator
Apr 14, 2005
70,865
:agree: I actually agree with what you are saying but the analogy is wrong because you picked the wrong examples. When you are to specify that a factor (scoring goals) is not necessarily relevant to a conclusion (being the better player) you need to fix the other relevant factors such as age.



I doubt it because if you were able to read, you would know that we were not talking about Rossi.
:) its classic ab absurdum all i have to do is bring one instance to counter the rule, age(within reason) was never set as a constant. Moreover even if it was, i brought another example that fulfilled that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 9)