A Blame of Thrones: Mafia Game (11 Viewers)

Fred

Senior Member
Oct 2, 2003
41,113
then what are your reasons for protecting Janna?

She's clearly the weakest right now and ain't doing herself any favours, so how come? first day sucks cause there is nothing to go by, the only one giving anything off is her and you decided from the start she isn't a G even though nothing clearly suggest otherwise
How about you start voting, I'm wondering why your keeping your vote for the end, like you have some kind of strategic use for it, or are you the detective again? :shifty:
 

Alen

Ѕenior Аdmin
Apr 2, 2007
53,941
then what are your reasons for protecting Janna?

She's clearly the weakest right now and ain't doing herself any favours, so how come? first day is usually a toss cause there is nothing to go by, the only one giving anything off is her and you decided from the start she isn't a G even though nothing clearly suggest otherwise
I have no clue about her role. I just don't want her dead. Especially if she's a G.
 

king Ale

Senior Member
Oct 28, 2004
21,689
ok then I am changing my vote to Hoori

The reason is that it kind of seems to me like a G would protect a helpless C who tries to get herself killed. This way Hoori could later use it to defend herself. This seems too suspicious for an experienced and good player. This will stay unless something happens.
I'm not protecting anyone. Read my posts: I repeated a few times that the most likely scenario to me is that Janna is a G having been told (by her more influential teammates) to say she has a special role, did you even read that? I said it is actually a smart move coming from the Gs, did you even read that? BUT, I am not willing to kill her because chances are she is telling the truth.
 

Fred

Senior Member
Oct 2, 2003
41,113
Anyone else think its telling that were close to deadline and nobodys saving hoori or salvo, its relatively unrisky to vote for a third person right now, if one of the two were gs that probably would have happened by now, right?
 

radekas

( ͠° ͟ل͜ ͡°)
Aug 26, 2009
20,137
I'm not protecting anyone. Read my posts: I repeated a few times that the most likely scenario to me is that Janna is a G having been told (by her more influential teammates) to say she has a special role, did you even read that? I said it is actually a smart move coming from the Gs, did you even read that? BUT, I am not willing to kill her because chances are she is telling the truth.
So you suspect her to be a G but you won't vote her out because there's a chance she is not a G? Uhhh...
 

Tomice

Senior Member
Mar 25, 2009
3,024
How about you start voting, I'm wondering why your keeping your vote for the end, like you have some kind of strategic use for it, or are you the detective again? :shifty:
I'm not usually inclined to vote on a whim generally

and yeah, voting is strategic. biding your time to see how the votes shape up so one can apply pressure on other players to react is a solid move imo, unfortunately it's a bit later then I wanted it to be since i was kinda preoccupied today so it might not have any impact, but yeah that was the plan honestly
 

Fred

Senior Member
Oct 2, 2003
41,113
I'm not usually inclined to vote on a whim generaly

and yeah, voting is strategic. biding my time to see how the votes shape up so one can apply pressure on other players to react is a solid move imo, unfortunately it's a bit later then I wanted it to be since i was kinda preoccupied today so it might not have any impact, but yeah that was the plan honestly
Ya, theres just a few minutes left, you still havent cast a vote despite being online for a while now, are you afraid your vote might incriminate you in some way?
 

king Ale

Senior Member
Oct 28, 2004
21,689
So you suspect her to be a G but you won't vote her out because there's a chance she is not a G? Uhhh...
Yes, just like everybody else. I think her move is directed, that's my opinion, I see no other reason why she would bluff like that. But, as slim as the chances are, I do NOT want to kill her yet because she could be telling the truth. How is it hard to understand and how does it make me protecting her?
 

radekas

( ͠° ͟ل͜ ͡°)
Aug 26, 2009
20,137
Yes, just like everybody else. I think her move is directed, that's my opinion, I see no other reason why she would bluff like that. But, as slim as the chances are, I do NOT want to kill her yet because she could be telling the truth. How is it hard to understand and how does it make me protecting her?
Because it's day 1 and you suspect her and won't vote for her. There's always a chance someone is not a G. Also that means that you will put a vote on someone who you don't consider to be a G. That's weird as hell. On day 1 all we have are hunches but ultimately we need to go for someone and logic dictates that you go for the one you suspect.
 

Alen

Ѕenior Аdmin
Apr 2, 2007
53,941
Yes, just like everybody else. I think her move is directed, that's my opinion, I see no other reason why she would bluff like that. But, as slim as the chances are, I do NOT want to kill her yet because she could be telling the truth. How is it hard to understand and how does it make me protecting her?
Her move wasn't directed.

I mean, we both know, despite not saying it loud, that you're implying that I told her to make that move. I didn't. And yes, as we both know, noone else did or would have done it.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 11)