We can tell them they are glory hunters and that we are ultras, then when Badass_Devil starts to feel like he's finally fit in, we let the even the new members make fun of him.
Splitting up won't work at all, trust me on that. It only works if they register in number but they always register serially.
First come first serve is a better approach, it will be mostly Andy eating their lunch unfortunately.
I am sure that the other purchaces will be after we release players.
For example a new RB will come when we sell Zebina and we will sell him.
Central midfielders also when we release Tiago or someone else.
Etc.