To be fair , I cannot think of any Juve's player being overrated as we simply do not go for them kinda players, not the ones with big reputations as we go for players that are effective and not pleasing on the eyes , so its hard to say overrated by the press.
I see some are saying Dp is overpaid, really? You think he is getting what he is for his football ability alone, you think Beckham is getting what hje gets for his abilities? You think Tom Cruise gets 30m and Pacino or DeNiro get barely 6m because Tom Cruise is the better actor? Its commercial and how much you bring to the club in that way.
But if I am going by overated in this forum then its definitely Oliveira and Maresca as ppl shout about them here but they are ordinary even if Maresca is marginally better so far