what about this idea !!!! (1 Viewer)

[immortal]

well....al of us know that every week there iz a match for juve or maybe 2...
so...
i liked this idea .. what about u ??

every week we choose which player was the best in the match
every player will take a point... & in the end of this season... we will count the points.. & realize the best player for juve
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
:thumb::greedy::flirt::extatic:

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[dpforever]

Good idea :thumb: ..

 

[denco]

There are downsides as how many ppl on here actually watch 90 minutes and how many will be subjective and not let personal feelings cloud their judgements

 

[Respaul]

I agree with denco.... as theres what, maybe 5 people on this forum that actually see the games in full..... how can the majority give a fair judgement!!

 

[Sivori]

They shouldn't, if only those who've watched the game vote then it could be more interesting.
But it's, of course, down to any member's' conscious not to vote when he/she has not seen the match.
It's a fun enough thing to try out, but it won't be fun if it doesn't work.

 

[Ian]

++ [ originally posted by respaul ] ++
I agree with denco.... as theres what, maybe 5 people on this forum that actually see the games in full..... how can the majority give a fair judgement!!

Who cares about a fair judgement. It doesn't matter that most people don't see the games, it would be fun anymore.

 

[immortal]

ok... as u like.. i just wanted to give it to u ...
nevermind...
by the way...
ur forumz r great & i'm happy to be amember here...

 

[dpforever]

And we're happy to have u abroad with us, immortal

 

[Wings]

interesting .... :thumb:
welcome to the forum

 

[dinoo]

great idea,but there is one thing to be decided before official games starts.we must decide up to what time we can vote.
For example: if Juventus played today in 15:00 lets make a rule that all of us must vote up to 22:00 or something like that.it has to be decided ,so we can decide a player of Juventus game,i mean,that we must decide a time to counting a votes,ok?

FORZA JUVE!!!

 

[Desmond]

that's kinda difficult for me because the juve matches usually end at 12 midnight here in s'pore,how am i gonna vote then?i was just hoping that the voting time could be extended,the counting isn't that urgent is it?

 

[s0ftcore]

So do we like take all the points.... and then average it? That will be more fair.

 

[Ian]

We would have to have some system of throwing out clearly ridiculous votes.

 

[Desmond]

yeah.the posters could view and suggest here that a particular vote was ridiculous and we could have a vote and then eliminate it.

 

[dinoo]

so,can someone of us write exactly rules?i think the best is that after the match everybody get connected and just say who was man of the match(Juventus players,i mean)of course who be first he make thread/topic and,every later make reply with just 1 name (player)and that would be open 3,4,5 hours,we have to decide,and after topic is closed we just count a votes and make for example :3 points for player with maniest votes,2 for second and 1 for third and just write it down untill the next match.of course 1 member = 1 vote!

 

[Ian]

Sounds complicated

 

[BigIzz]

Why not just have an option where we can rate all of the players in a given match. All you need is a page that has all of the players who played for JUve and a choice from 1-10 and a NR. We can track players averages for the entire season as well.

Even if the votes arent perfect and not everyone has seen the match, who cares? It is supposed to be a fun thing, the votes wouldn't really count for anything that important anyway.

 

[Ian]

well then, that sounds like you're volunteering to do the statistical analysis.

 

[BigIzz]

No no, I just volunteer ideas. I never volunteer to do work

 

[Ian]

Ohhh.... I get it, so you're an idea man like me.