The fook is G? (10 Viewers)

king Ale

Senior Member
Oct 28, 2004
21,689
What kind of twisted logic is that?

The BG shouldn't trust my suspicions, yet the G's should. Sorry, you completely lost me there.
The Gs don't trust you but when they pick their targets to whack they only go after someone who's more likely to have a special role. When you as a C say publicly that you are convinced that she has a special role, you make them choose her. At a normal case, whacking Sabet (in case she is a C) is no different than whacking member A or B but when you say that, they prefer to go for Sabet. Of course I'm not saying that Sabet is a Civilian.

But the bodyguard simply can't and shouldn't trust you. He has to protect him/herself. He doesn't know if you are a G or C, he doesn't know about Sabet either so he will keep saving himself until he becomes sure about a civilian who is in danger.

I think a G must be more careful. A G (IMO) never votes active members so blatantly on the first day. In case he is a G, he must know that I'm a Civilian and lynching me means that he's going to be lynched in the night after so he might try to avert the attentions to me but he won't do it so directly like that :D
 

Alen

Ѕenior Аdmin
Apr 2, 2007
53,991
I think a G must be more careful. A G (IMO) never votes active members so blatantly on the first day. In case he is a G, he must know that I'm a Civilian and lynching me means that he's going to be lynched in the night after so he might try to avert the attentions to me but he won't do it so directly like that :D
Yeah, but he voted for you right after Sab and I did the same. When he voted for you I still didn't change my vote from you to Salman, so if we both kept our votes it was me who was gonna be suspected for lynching you (in case you're a C) and Osman might have even been the loudest one in blaming me for lynching you and how he just "trusted me and followed me".
 

BillyG

Caribbean Ultra
Nov 25, 2006
4,151
Yeah, but he voted for you right after Sab and I did the same. When he voted for you I still didn't change my vote from you to Salman, so if we both kept our votes it was me who was gonna be suspected for lynching you (in case you're a C) and Osman might have even been the loudest one in blaming me for lynching you and how he just "trusted me and followed me".
u know u love a bit of Osman behind u! :D

u guys/girls gettin too technical.....let's just lynch any ole sum-bitch (gotta love the rock) and get this bad boy on the road!
 

king Ale

Senior Member
Oct 28, 2004
21,689
Yeah, but he voted for you right after Sab and I did the same. When he voted for you I still didn't change my vote from you to Salman, so if we both kept our votes it was me who was gonna be suspected for lynching you (in case you're a C) and Osman might have even been the loudest one in blaming me for lynching you and how he just "trusted me and followed me".
But he knew that you were not going to keep your vote, didn't he? Or maybe you wanted to keep your vote? In that case you'd deserve to get lynched in the night after :D

For the record, Osman hasn't PMed me yet :p
 

SABSAB

Snoop Stinks
Dec 10, 2008
10,832
The Gs don't trust you but when they pick their targets to whack they only go after someone who's more likely to have a special role. When you as a C say publicly that you are convinced that she has a special role, you make them choose her. At a normal case, whacking Sabet (in case she is a C) is no different than whacking member A or B but when you say that, they prefer to go for Sabet. Of course I'm not saying that Sabet is a Civilian.

But the bodyguard simply can't and shouldn't trust you. He has to protect him/herself. He doesn't know if you are a G or C, he doesn't know about Sabet either so he will keep saving himself until he becomes sure about a civilian who is in danger.
But I am one:sad:



M.G.
 

Buck Fuddy

Lara Chedraoui fanboy
May 22, 2009
10,888
The Gs don't trust you but when they pick their targets to whack they only go after someone who's more likely to have a special role. When you as a C say publicly that you are convinced that she has a special role, you make them choose her. At a normal case, whacking Sabet (in case she is a C) is no different than whacking member A or B but when you say that, they prefer to go for Sabet. Of course I'm not saying that Sabet is a Civilian.

But the bodyguard simply can't and shouldn't trust you. He has to protect him/herself. He doesn't know if you are a G or C, he doesn't know about Sabet either so he will keep saving himself until he becomes sure about a civilian who is in danger.
All right, I understand what you were trying to say. But I still do not agree with it, since I am just 1 guy. And so early on in the game, the thoughts of 1 participant just don't mean all that much.

Bear with me here:
I have made it clear that I suspect Sab of having a special role. Possibly a G, possibly not. Which leads you to believe that the G's could be going after her.
Now imagine (I know, imagining is Fred's forte, but just try it :D) me not mentioning my suspicions about Sab, but instead just voting for her. If I do that, the G's (assuming she's not one of them) will also know about my suspicions towards her, because why else would I vote for her.
End result is the same imo: Everyone (G's & C's) know that I'm watching & suspecting Sab. And how the G's act on that is their decision.


But hey, maybe I just should have kept my mouth shut :D
 

Alen

Ѕenior Аdmin
Apr 2, 2007
53,991
What is your problem with me Buck?
Shall we vote for him? :eyebrows:

One of the favorite members to everybody, but boy does he give me an unpleasant feeling about this game. I don't know if it's due to the past games when he was a G, but I simply can't see a C in him.
 

king Ale

Senior Member
Oct 28, 2004
21,689
Shall we vote for him? :eyebrows:

One of the favorite members to everybody, but boy does he give me an unpleasant feeling about this game. I don't know if it's due to the past games when he was a G, but I simply can't see a C in him.
Same here. However I feel that you are a G saying that about your fellow G ;)
 

Fred

Senior Member
Oct 2, 2003
41,113
Going after an inactive member in the previous two games was gonna mean lynching a G.
Blondu and JBF were the only two inactive at the beginning of the second to last game. I voted JBF and we almost lynched him. He was a G.
If people went after Suns and Kyle on the first days of the last game, again a G would have been lynched.

It sure doesn't mean that the inactive ones in this game will be gangsters. There is always a +70% chance that they aren't Gs. But fuck it. As it's been noticed many time around here, an inactive poster is ruining the game in so many levels.
You're right, even when i was a G once, two of the other G's on my team were inactive.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 10)